Kimi ni shika Kikoenai |
Ecrire une critique
Devenir seigneur
|
Des alternatives:
English: Calling You
Japanese: きみにしか聞こえない
Auteur:
Tsuzuki, Setsuri
Taper:
Manga
Volumes:
1
Chapitres:
5
Statut:
Finished
Publier:
2021-12-06 to ?
Sérialisation:
Asuka (Monthly)
En train de lire Veux lire Lis Retirer |
En train de lire
Veux lire
Lis
Retirer
4.0
(6 Votes)
|
33.33%
33.33%
33.33%
0.00%
0.00%
|
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Des alternatives:
English: Calling You
Japanese: きみにしか聞こえない
Japanese: きみにしか聞こえない
Auteur:
Tsuzuki, Setsuri
Taper:
Manga
Volumes:
1
Chapitres:
5
Statut:
Finished
Publier:
2021-12-06 to ?
Sérialisation:
Asuka (Monthly)
But
4.0
6 Votes
|
33.33%
33.33%
33.33%
0.00%
0.00%
|
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Sommaire
A volume featuring two short stories. Calling You—A lonely pair of high school students begin to psychically communicate through the “cell phones in their heads.” Their connection grows, and they discover that they’re not only separated by distance, but by time, as well. Kids—a story about high school bullying and abuse.
Note: Kiyohara Hiro also did a manga based on the same story.
(Source: MU)
Note: Kiyohara Hiro also did a manga based on the same story.
(Source: MU)
Commentaires (6)
Ecrire une critique
Kimi ni shika Kikoenai review
I think this manga is a clear example of how a bad storyboard can ruin a story.
The manga includes two stories: Kimi ni Shika Kikoenai (Calling you), a one-shot about two highschool students who communicate psychically through cellphones they created in their minds. Kizu (Kids), a story organized in two chapters, about a boy who can absorve the wounds of other people. I have nothing against one-shots, or short mangas. I´ve read really good ones, and there are even some one-shots among my favorite mangas. I also think works should be judged within their genre and kind. Comparing a short and a long manga would be the same as comparing a short story with a novel. There is no use in doing that. But in this particular case, I think there was too much information to convey in such little space. At moments, the story isn´t clear, it´s too rushed, there are many gaps in the storyline, it´s chaotic. I think the art didn´t help either. I found it two "girly" and overly ornamented. The general feeling I got is that it ended up dealing with a deep and moving matter in a very superficial way. To be true, the feeling I got may be related to the fact that I already knew the stories when I read the manga. When analyzing it, I cannot help but compare it with another version of these two stories, both drawn by Kiyohara Hiro, which are much, much better. They are two separate mangas, with the same titles: Kimi ni Shika Kikoenai, and Kizu. The first one has 5 chapters, the second one 4. They have a much slower pace, the character development is way deeper, the art is simpler, and has a more mature feel to it, which suits this plot better. This version is just average. The story is still good. Otsu-Ichi´s story is still the same, so I can´t rate it as "bad". The problem is the adaptation. I highly recommend reading Kiyohara Hiro´s version. |
Kimi ni shika Kikoenai review
I know my '7' overall rating does not compliment my positive review; its just as I read on, my guesses were always right which made me think that not alot of imagination went into the storyline. If the last chapter was different I would have given it an '8'.
The development of the characters was not rushed which made the manga seem longer than the one volume. It also does not concentrate too much on building a romantic feeling between Ryo and Nozaki (until the last chapter:); but concetrates more on character and storyline development. Due to this concetration of detail, we are able ton learn more about how the imagined phones work as well as the characters's past and drive to imagine a phone in their heads. Which I believe give the reader more reason to read on due to intrigue |
Kimi ni shika Kikoenai review
"I will not change the future, the past, as they are things that I felt that I had to do, maybe this is the so called inevitable fate."
Similar people has similar ways to interact, and through this story is about knowing someone through an imaginative cellphone. A rather simple story, about a lonely girl who is somewhat envious of people, and a kindhearted boy. The characters were rather realistic on how they would approach a conversation through an cellphone of nonexistent, to doubt oneself's sanity when they could talk through this phone.The girl was a timid girl, but a girl that was looking to change. As they helped each other in the simplest ways, both of them started to change for the better, especially at the end the girl changed a lot. This was quite enjoyable, though a bit cliche especially at the end, everything went as expected, but for some reason it was still very enjoyable. An ending that was somewhat cheesy, somewhat touching,,,. To anyone that likes drama, maybe this isn't necessary everyone's cup of tea, but for me... it was spot on. |
Kimi ni shika Kikoenai review
The idea of talking to someone you didn't know from a cell phone that didn't exist was too good to pass up on reading...
Summary: Aihara Ryo is not a regular high school girl. She doesn't think she is anyway. Every high school girl has a cell phone, she doesn't. Tired of wishing for one she decides that she'll get one. She pictures one in her mind so clearly she even gives it her favorite song as ring tone. One day during class, she hears her song on a cell phone and wonders why no one is answering. Not even the teacher asks to shut it off. No one could hear it but her. It's ringing in her mind. What can she do but answer it? It was fate. In the other line was a boy, a high school boy who's talking to her the same way she is talking to him...by their made up cell phones. Just like that she is lonely no more. She has someone to talk to and at last a friend. Suddenly it occurs to them to meet. Aihara is going to learn the hard way that you can't change destiny. It's well written, and by the time you finish you should ask yourself if you believe in fate or destiny. That's what this manga is about, more or less. That no matter what some things have to happen and you can't change them, no matter how much you try. They are not your choices to make. I don't think character development was the main goal of it but it still did well. You could see by the end how the main character changed and became stronger, but sometimes you have to fall down to really get back up. The art in this manga is nothing out of this world, it's actually very real looking (as real as manga gets anyway). This isn't your typical shojo manga. It's actually a breath of fresh air for someone like me who is constantly just reading shojo's. |
Kimi ni shika Kikoenai review
Nobody can hear me but you is a story of a timid girl who found a friendship through an invisible cellphone which can surpass even time space and how she move on with it as a tragic accident occurs. See Aihara Ryo's Transition, from a timid girl to a Head Strong girl throughout the story. If you're into drama, then this manga is worth to read.
For me, the art isn't that good (well not too detailed in some parts) but since the story is well written and well-paced as well as the character built was constructed very well, it overshadowed the deficiency in the art part so all in all it was a good manga. |