Shoujo Tsubaki

Ecrire une critique
Devenir seigneur
Des alternatives: English: Mr. Arashi's Amazing Freak Show
Synonyms: Midori, Camelia Girl
Japanese: 少女椿
Auteur: Maruo, Suehiro
Taper: Manga
Volumes: 1
Chapitres: 8
Statut: Finished
Publier: 1984-09-13 to ?

En train de lire

Veux lire

Lis

Retirer

En train de lire

Veux lire

Lis

Retirer

2.1
(7 Votes)
0.00%
0.00%
42.86%
28.57%
28.57%
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Des alternatives: English: Mr. Arashi's Amazing Freak Show
Synonyms: Midori, Camelia Girl
Japanese: 少女椿
Auteur: Maruo, Suehiro
Taper: Manga
Volumes: 1
Chapitres: 8
Statut: Finished
Publier: 1984-09-13 to ?
But
2.1
7 Votes
0.00%
0.00%
42.86%
28.57%
28.57%
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Sommaire
The series is about an orphan girl named Midori, whom is taken in (enslaved) by a traveling freak show. The freak show includes such unsavory characters as a mummyman, a snake woman, and a drooling man with no limbs. The owner of the freak show, the eponymous Mr. Arashi, is a strict man who allows his freaks very little freedom or joy in life. He is especially cruel to Midori. Midori works, not as a freak since she is normal, but as a sort of caretaker of the freaks.

(Source: everything2)
Mots clés
horror
Commentaires (7)
Ecrire une critique
Shoujo Tsubaki review
par
Silvermuffin6
Apr 12, 2021
I don't write reviews much but I feel like I should explain why I gave this the rating I gave it.

I'm keeping this short and simple. This was horrible. Not because of the gore itself, not because of the r4pe, not the p3dophilia, none of that. It was horrible because there was nothing to it. At all. Reading this for the story is like watching child porn for the plot. WHAT FUCKING PLOT?? You just watch a girl get harassed and assaulted by pedophiles just to find love and comfort IN ANOTHER PEDOPHILE while ABSOLUTELY NOTHING IS HAPPENING IN THE ACTUAL PLOT.

I enjoy disturbing, crazy, fucked-up horror of all kinds but this was a just bad. I understand the era it was written for but let me explain:

1. This story has no depth or substance AT ALL. There's nothing happening, nothing really going on, we were just following the horrible life of this 12 year old who was kidnapped by a circus. It was basically like a horror slice of life except slice of life mangas usually have a plot.

2. The characters are ok, theres was no development (again, because there was no plot) and I just don't enjoy reading something that has characters that are just there. No significance.

3. It was gore-y and "disturbing" solely for the sake of being so. I understand the argument that it was written in the ero something era blah blah blah but that doesn't change the fact that the dark topics it was portraying weren't significant at all.

Final thoughts: If you are someone who enjoys reading horror and disturbing manga that actually have a plot and bring some usefulness to the dark topics being portrayed, this is not the manga for you. If you just like dark things and don't' care for plot or actually well written stories, then fuck it. Go read this. But reevaluate your taste after cause stories like this aren't enjoyable, they're not even disturbing, just disgusting.
Shoujo Tsubaki review
par
dolfinkiller12
Apr 12, 2021
If you are new to the work of Suehiro Maruo, boy you have a big storm coming. 'Shoujo Tsubaki' is his most popular work, garnering attention as being known to many people as "The most disturbing anime/manga of all time." In my opinion, 'Brother's Conflict' and 'Papa to Kiss in the Dark' are FAR more disturbing than this, but I digress.

To be quite honest, this story is actually more streamline and almost makes sense is comparison to his other work. That being said, there is almost no actual storyline to follow and does not make too much sense at times. Things just happen and you have to roll with the punches. If you were hoping for actual plot and a resolved conflict, you will not be satisfied with this.

What makes this manga special is the art; The stark contrast between the black and white without excessive use of screentones to mellow out those harsh lines. Instead of screentones, much of the shading is hatching, which just makes the art feel that much grittier to me. The best usage of hatching I found was on page 115, I can literally feel the hand cramp just from looking at it.

I'd like to just reference some of my favorite pages, because I only really enjoyed this book for the artistic value. Page 84, the "Ant Scene.." go ahead and try to figure out what happens in the ant scene. Pages 106-107, which I would like to refer to as "An actual nightmare, OR a really good time!!" My favorite of all though was on page 111, where we see Midori standing in front of a cold night sky. It's not the most detailed or refined drawing, but it is just really nice to look at, when you see it you'll know what I mean.

I am not even going to bother talking about our "lovely" cast of characters. There's nothing to talk about, other than the fact every character other than Midori is an ACTUAL PREDATOR and will not hesitate to bust a nut at any given second. But I will give credit to Muchisute for eating with his feet though, what a king. He can't play rock paper scissors but MAN he do be dressing well!!

If you are a horror/guro fan and haven't given this a chance yet, literally what are you waiting for. Or if you're someone who simply wants to expand their horizons by reading something different or weird, I'd say give this a go! Keep in mind there are tons of explicit and disturbing scenes, such as r*pe, mutilation and murder. 'Shoujo Tusbaki' is a mere 1 volume, so a quick read that I would say is very much worth it :3c <3