The Voices That Call Me |
Ecrire une critique
Devenir seigneur
|
Auteur:
Yamamoto Naoki
Artiste:
Yamamoto Naoki
Taper:
Manga
Statut:
YES
Publier:
0000-01-01 to ?
En train de lire Veux lire Lis Retirer |
En train de lire
Veux lire
Lis
Retirer
1.5
(4 Votes)
|
0.00%
0.00%
25.00%
0.00%
75.00%
|
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Auteur:
Yamamoto Naoki
Artiste:
Yamamoto Naoki
Taper:
Manga
Statut:
YES
Publier:
0000-01-01 to ?
But
1.5
4 Votes
|
0.00%
0.00%
25.00%
0.00%
75.00%
|
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Sommaire
Kaoru was an aspiring mangaka, with big dreams and (what he thought was, and still does think,) oodles of talent. Now he's just another hikikomori (recluse) who hasn't left his room in 5 years...Until one hot summer night, when he hears, from some distant place, voices which call him. Voices that only he can hear. Voices that are calling for help. Following the voices, Kaoru opens the windows, and steps out into the night.
Commentaires (4)
Ecrire une critique
The Voices That Call Me review
This is the first manga I have ever rated a "1" so far. I love psychological stories and, while I know they are often confusing and do not always have clear conclusions or lines between reality and make-believe, "The Voices That Call Me" just has absolutely nothing going for it. It is very confusing, has an extremely open ended ending with almost absolutely nothing having been accomplished, has a lot of pointless philosophical banter that goes on for about 6 or 7 pages, and it's also kind of a hentai.
Let me rephrase that for anyone quickly skimming through here, this one shot is extremely explicit (despite MAL not listing it as such). It does not focus much on the nudity but there is still a blowjob, fingering, and a little other stuff for a couple pages. This is a one shot, so of course it's a fairly quick story, but it wastes a lot of time on things that really don't seem to have any purpose. Anyway, about the story, it follows a hikikimori (loner who hardly ever or never goes outside) who one day hears voices calling him (this part was so quick I forget what they even said to him if it actually mentioned it all). So, following the voices, the man decides to leave his room for the first time in 15 years. He wanders around and ends up at a convenience store. He hears someone say something and asks the man next to him if he said anything, to which the man responds "No." However, the man is one seriously fucked up guy (can't think of a better way to put it). He starts rambling about some philosophical thing that seems to apply to him and makes it sound like he recently divorced his wife. The hikikimori kind of ignores him for a while, but eventually gets dragged into even weirder stuff with the guy (one of my main problems with this one shot is this weird guy because his rambling goes on for far too long and he's just plain psychotic). Some more stuff happens and the hikikimori ends up following the voices he hears to a girl's house. And that's where the short hentai stuff happens so you can probably guess kind of how that goes. I'll stop talking about the story there to avoid giving away any of the few somewhat important parts of the story. As for the art, it is also very weak. The characters are drawn poorly (the main character looks especially weird and bland). The short hentai part isn't even long enough for someone to really "enjoy" it if that's what your reading this for (which I wasn't since I didn't even know it was like that beforehand). The characters really just consist of the hikikimori protagonist, the philisophical psychotic, the girl whose house the hikikimori invades, and the girl's friends. None of them stand out in the slightest aside from being annoying. I did not enjoy this manga at all (it had like one funny line towards the end but that was about it). The story was confusing and pointless, the art was bad, the characters were bizarre and annoying, and the story ended quickly with a confusing ending. I would not recommend this manga to anyone as I feel there is no reason to read this. Just leave this page and don't read it. |
The Voices That Call Me review
There are manga that try to be something and succeed, there are manga that try to be something and fail, and there are manga that don't try to be nothing and end up being exactly that, nothing.
And that's the case of this One Shot called The Voices That Call Me, from the author of Arigatou, an amazing manga with a great cast of characters, good use of its art and a good story. And it's curious to say that while i'm reviewing this, because The Voice That Call Me contains the exact opposite of the pros that Arigatou has. I don't know what the author had in his mind, but that was just a non sense gorefest. I must admit that i was interested in his other work after finishing Arigatou, so i decided to check this one shot.. and it's definitely the worst thing i've ever read. This manga is confusing, but not because of an accumulation of information and details, not because it has great ambiguous philosophies, but because it is a complete very badly made mess. Dialogues, characters, art, story and even the ending were poorly done. Emptiness of meaning, gratuitous, poorly drawn, bad dialogues, confusing and an ending without any sense. That's it. |
The Voices That Call Me review
A brief and entertaining one-shot for those who understand firstly that this is bizarre and explicit. Other reviewers seem to feel that there's nothing going for the story meaning-wise to justify, in a sense, the goings-on. It's one thing for a manga to entertain through strange happenings, but when a manga attempts to directly philosophize it and bring meaning to it, the audience suddenly shrinks. I'd actually wager that if the mangaka took a more subtle approach it might've connected better with people, as while we all understand words on a basic level, we don't all understand things well through the same use of them.
Anyways, "The Voices That Call Me" is a mild exploration of the "hikikomori", which is a person who chooses to live to themselves within a room - their finances sustained by another. This story in particular explores the basic idea that every human being seeks companionship, but that through the experience of a hikikomori they grow to only really care about themselves. The hikikomori's search for companionship shows how although they want interaction, it's down to a physical level. We're social creatures, so it goes to show how much of an outcast this hikikomori truly is, even if he leaves his room right now. It goes to show they can't re-enter society without assistance. |