Catégorie
club
Commentaires
Activité
Langue
Français
Faire un don
Faire un don
Oh o, cet utilisateur n'a pas défini de bouton de don.
Les critiques de livres
Shingeki no Kyojin
Koe no Katachi
Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou
Beck
Beck
Beck
Beck review
Beck
Apr 14, 2021
Beck review
Yet again before i get started Beck was written and drawn by Harold Sakuishi and was published in english by tokypop around 2000.

First off i'd like to point out that i've never read nor watched a music anime/manga so i really had nothing to compare it to, with that in mind i'll get started

-STORY-
To be honest the story was one of it's own being good nor bad; based around real life and real people. sometimes it drags a bit and you feel like your going know where but despite that i really enjoyed the struggle, pain, loss and joy beck go through as they learn more about themselves and each other (being music or otherwise). if your under 13 maybe you shouldn't watch it (depending on how mature) it has a lot of blood, weapons and sex references; sometimes it isn't always needed but i think it was just part of the humour the artist was going for so i let it go through saying that i did enjoy the drama.

-ART-
At the beginning i have to say i really didn't like it all to well; it had a stiffness about it which i have to say improved without even realising. it reminds a little bit or hajime no ippo (fighting spirit) which also got a lot better.

-CHARACTERS-
I know i scored this setection low but i can't say i have a reason; all members of beck have there known hardships they have to over come rather being school, themselves, music or each other- they do however break down every wall and end up trusting each other and realise that with even one missing nothing would have happened or could ever happen- but this took all 34 volumes to do and even though for the style he was using it was right; i wanted results quicker.

-ENJOYMENT-
What can i say? beck (even though as i said before brags on) is a great manga and i can see why it was made in to a anime, it's funny and filled with drama it kept me hooked for hours; heck i even reread the four last chapters, once the art style became more nature and easier on the eye was very likeable and one of my personal favourites; though sometimes it can feel repetitive and boring, i continued to the last volume and was very happy with it; also if watching because you've watched the anime; the manga has more back story(even though thats usually the case) and goes way past the bands reunion:).
I hope you read and enjoy it
P.S. i did this a bit impulsive and wrote this close to 1am so am sure there are a lot of mistakes that i will take care of once i've hap at least 7hours sleep. night night
0
0
0
TORCH SONG ECOLOGY
TORCH SONG ECOLOGY
TORCH SONG ECOLOGY
TORCH SONG ECOLOGY review
TORCH SONG ECOLOGY
Apr 14, 2021
TORCH SONG ECOLOGY review
This manga, Torch Song Ecology is really different. Looking at it's cover, it's not what one would expect at all. The cover has a sort of BL vibe to it, but this manga is not that so don't let that put you off, this is fine for gals and guys to read. It's supernatural with sadness and tragedy thrown in. The feeling of it is sort of dark, because it deals with a lower ranked actor who is depressed due to deaths of those close to him, so it has a sort of heavy feeling but at the same time it is very funny. He is haunted by ghosts but the ghosts are quite funny.

I hand it to this experienced josei mangaka, she really throws some unusual twists into this one. There is a lot of abstract surreal quality to it to, as it's often his thoughts and dreams and memories that are shown not just the current time line. It's almost hard to tag this - I guess supernatural and tragedy fit the bill. A torch song is a song before death. Yet if you like unusual manga that are unpredictable I think this is a good one.

Obviously, it does not have a big readership, but the scores it's gotten are not indictative of the quality of this work. I think it has suffered from something common to josei - slow translations. It's apparently 3 volumes but josei are not translated quickly enough for those of us who like them. I happen to like it when I get something that is more than it looks like from the outside. The whole you can't judge by the cover thing really is applicable here. Anyway I give it a 9 for it's quirkiness. I'm not sure if I will change this further in, but after one volume I find this story intriquing.
~ reviewed by inzaratha for ~ reviews for the unreviewed.
0
0
0
Arata Primal
Boku dake Shitteru Ichimiya-san
Boku dake Shitteru Ichimiya-san
Boku dake Shitteru Ichimiya-san
Boku dake Shitteru Ichimiya-san review
Boku dake Shitteru Ichimiya-san
Apr 13, 2021
Boku dake Shitteru Ichimiya-san review
What is an antagonist?
An antagonist is the character in the story that is against the protagonist.
Every antagonist has a backstory that shows how he deviated from a normal life.
~~This story has one too.

As a story progresses, there are two paths an antagonist can take - either he takes the redemption path or he stays the same.
Usually if one takes the redemption path, they undergo a long, grueling, and humbling process of trying to make up for their past crimes.
And if one does not take the redemption path, well.. he remains unfazed by the outcome of his actions and would re-do them if given the chance.
Both paths are acceptable according to me. I can't bring myself to hate the story if he chooses the 2nd path.

I actually liked this manga in the beginning, however, that all changed when I reached the 'conclusion'. It completely ruined my overall experience of the manga.
If an antagonist takes the redemption path, he should SUFFER the consequences of his actions, no matter how grave or light his actions were.
You CAN'T skip the "suffer the consequences" part and give the antagonist a happier ending than the protagonist just like that.
That's just plain wrong!
Heck, after completing this, I wished that I was the bad guy in this story.
If you can commit a crime and get away scott-free, can you really ask for something more?

Also, this is my first review. Hence, the poorness in its quality. Now, I don't write reviews at all. But as this manga left me with a very bad aftertaste, I just couldn't leave it alone and had to express my thoughts. I tried my best to not spoil the story.

~Thank you for taking your time to read my review.
0
0
0
Renai Shinjuu
Taboo Tattoo
Taboo Tattoo
Taboo Tattoo
Taboo Tattoo review
Taboo Tattoo
Apr 08, 2021
Taboo Tattoo review
Minor spoilers ahead. Just skip to enjoyment if you want it completely spoiler free, although the amount isn't really that much to begin with.

Ecchi and action: a match made in heaven. Unfortunately, that's only the case if the proper set up and balance are created, which Taboo Tattoo does not accomplish. What it does do is it creates a visually sound action adventure of pervs, sadists, heroes and homosexuals.

Story: Right off the bat, the classic set up of "boy gets dragged into secret war between two sides" comes into play. Battles are not in short supply but are instead brief albeit brutal affairs with lots of blood and guts, which was somewhat surprising considering the manga can sometimes come across as juvenile with its copious amounts of fan service done is ways that disrupt the flow of the scenes and plot. That's not to say the use of sexual imagery is completely for fan-boners. Rape, suggested and not so, is used a source of shock value, as if the series is trying to prove its grittiness.

As for the series' pacing and tone, the first parts seem inconsistent, as breast fondles and sexual comedy happen while hearing exposition dumps and sometimes the manga goes out of its way to give more fanservice, changing entire characters just to pander to the readers.

Characters: On the subject of characters, almost everyone, from the protagonist, to the antagonist, fits into some sort of archetype, albeit some more snugly than other. That being said, some characters, like B.B, do a great job at fulfilling their roles, making the audience care about their struggles and pasts, while others, like the enemy Princess (who seems to be a kind of hyper-genius girl with OP powers), fail by letting the fanservice affect them. The antagonist especially actually has a decent reason for her objectives, but she loses credibility when she surrounds herself with a same-sex harem just for kicks and playfully molests the childhood friend of the protagonist after the later loses to her in a game of table tennis... As a whole, the characters are unremarkable except for a select few like B.B and Lurker.

Art: Art is meant to supplement the story and for the most part the artwork of the manga succeeds in this respect. Illustrations can have a sketch like quality on a few occasions, but the well-paced battles exhibit the artistic chops of the illustrator. The character designs and backgrounds are a tad on the generic and unremarkable side, made painfully obvious by the characters themselves.

Enjoyment: If the fanservice was dialed down or at least integrated more naturally, I probably would have enjoyed the series a lot more. Fanservice is not a pet peeve of mine, but if it interrupts the tone and pacing of the story completely, then it can turn a decent series into a lacking one. Characters are defined by their actions, not just their motivations, and this is where characters like the antagonist and other characters fall victim to the manga's immaturity. Those who like typical action manga's with guns and superpowers may find something to enjoy, but beware of the awkward tone and sluggish pacing of the first part. The series has some highs and I intend to finish it, but so far, it's below average.

Let's hope that the next few chapters fix the sins of its predecessors.
0
0
0
Shinsekai yori
Ajouter une étiquette
d'accord
Résultat de la recherche
Balise ajoutée
Populaire
S'inscrire
Trouvez votre mot de passe
Obligatoire Le format de l'e-mail est incorrect L'e-mail a existé Doit contenir entre 6 et 14 caractères Les mots de passe ne sont pas les mêmes Plus Vues Effacer Réponse Juste Échec de la suppression du commentaire Envoyer Soumettre un succès Échoué Le titre est requis Le contenu est requis Supprimer avec succès Échec de la connexion Nom (obligatoire Email (requis Réussir Le fichier doit être .jp (e) g /.png /.gif La largeur minimale est La hauteur minimale est La taille doit être La taille maximale de la photo est Ancien mot de passe Veuillez saisir du texte Le tarif est obligatoire Prévenir Comme commentaires L'ancien mot de passe n'est pas correct Le format de l'url n'est pas valide, vérifiez et réessayez s'il vous plaît L'URL doit être comme ceci: https://youtu.be/xxx ou, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxx ou, https://www.youtube.com/embed/xxx Membres Joindre Des postes Suivre Rejoint Suivi * Le nom du club ne peut pas être vide. * Le nom du club a existé. Une couverture est requise Le fond est requis Un problème avec la vérification du nom Pas plus En attente de vérification Le créateur ne peut pas quitter Le club a existé, peut-être en attente de vérification Le chat ne peut pas être vide