Peach Girl review

Gin-iro13
Apr 04, 2021
I know it is a really old manga, but i just read it several days ago and i can say that i enjoy this manga.

Story (7/10)
This is a really long manga and there are so many dramas. But i still think the story is okay since i still enjoy reading it (i can’t believe it i am not bored by this manga at all). The things that keep bothering me to give the story a better score is the fact that the author takes the dramas too far sometimes. (SPOILER) For example, momo, the main character, keep changing her partner between toji and kairi everytime she has a huge problem with one of them. The funny thing is This girl is not even trying to find out more about what is really happening and just keep thinking about her own happiness. But the worst drama is when toji has to break up with momo because sae (the villain) threatening him. I know from the first time that kairi is the first male lead, but i never think that the author would pull a plot like this to make kairi and momo together. I think it is a really bad way to break up relationship and it is so unfair for toji, he needs a happy ending too. (SPOILER STOP HERE) Anyway, despite the drama that is so long and too much, i still enjoy every chapter of this manga and i think that is the most important part.

Art (6/10)
If only the author can maintain the art just like the first 20 something chapter i would give it a better score (Maybe she is tired and forgot how to draw the character lol). The art keeps dropping and dropping. When i read it, i realized that the character becoming more like a child (smaller and smaller), especially kairi. At the end of the chapter kairi looks totally different than the first time u read it. He looks more like a cute guy at the end instead of a cool guy. It is a really big dissapointment for me.

Character (8/10)
For me, the character is quite good but not that great. First, lets talk about this MC, momo. I think she is not impressive at all. She keeps worrying over a small thing and doesn’t developed so much at the end of the series. Next is kairi. He is good and so funny, i like how he transform to become a better and more serious. Next is toji. Tbh, i dont see any development in him at all, he is not a bad person to start with though. The last one is sae. I never hate this girl although she did so many bad things and even cross the line. She is funny and makes the story keeps going and interesting. For the role of a villain, she is not that annoying and i think shoujo manga this days have worse MC than this girl (well, i mean look at that MC crying all the time just irritates me).

Enjoyment (9/10)
Like i said before, never even once i bored reading this manga. And i think when u read something. Enjoyment is the most important thing. So, i really appreciate the author for making this manga so fun to read.

Overall (8/10)
Overall it is a really good manga for me since i enjoy it so much. I also love the ending. U must read this manga instead of searching for shoujo manga nowadays which is full of a slut, crybaby, goody two shoes MC.
Faire un don
0
0
0

commentaires

Peach Girl
Peach Girl
Auteur Ueda, Miwa
Artiste