Usagi Drop review

WhoCanPeliCan6
Apr 04, 2021
TO THE CRITISIZERS OF THE SO CALLED INCEST, (my storyline review below this message)

In a review, I think that the thing to be reviewed is how well the intended storyline is potrayed, character and/or world development, art etc. It is senseless to criticize the plot.

If a manga/anime just has to have a stereotypical storyline with no uniqueness and if the unique path selected by the author is condemned for being in the so called wrong path (evil, incest, negative...), then just a single, ideal story is required, why bother to make new manga/anime?
The unique storyline here of how an adopted daughter develops romantic love for her adoptive father is what this story is about. Why criticize the story? You(storyline critisizers) didn't like it, that does not mean it is not depicted well.

Even I don't like stories which depict an evil-natured MC's life or stories where MC has all the luck and opportunities he needs or those with harems, but that is just my taste and that does not mean The story is not good. A story is a story. It can't be judged. You can only judge the characters and setting, but how can story be bad? The badness(that you think) is itself the story! In this story it's how filial feelings change to romantic feelings.

And incest is condemned in society just because the baby has higher chances of genetic defects and causes complications in relationships, but this problem which plagued the adoptive daughter's mind was removed. And the father already knew about it long back, when he read the will.

So please don't share your preferences in the name of review. Nor I nor you are acceptably eligible to post reviews for stories whose storylines we don't prefer.

MY REVIEW,

In the storyline, the transition of filial feelings to romantic feelings was not smooth and not clearly displayed; it was a bit unrealistic as not much flags were shown for it. And the time skips seem erratic but that bit is necessary I believe. And in my view the story had a very happy ending as the father and daughter who loved eachother (may be familial or romantic) didn't split up due to her marriage or father's death or anything.
The story intended by the author was (mostly)clearly conveyed to me in a mostly reasonable format without much plot armour and plot holes, hence I consider this story to be a grand success!
Faire un don
0
0
0

commentaires

Usagi Drop
Usagi Drop
Auteur Unita, Yumi
Artiste