Maa-chan no Nikkichou review
mizu_girl4
|
I read this title quite a while ago on an old manga kick, so forgive my retrospective view detailed below.
Story, 5: The chapters in the translation I read were 4-koma panels that detailed the life of a preschooler engaging in various activities. The stories were not unlike something you would see in a newspaper's comic section. Due to the short nature, there wasn't much developed or enthralling.
Art, 5: For the time period, it was fine and very similar to Western comics. I wasn't blown away with anything in particular.
Characters, 5: The extremely short stories didn't really help any characters feel particularly distinct in any way, but they were relatively charming from a comedic aspect.
Enjoyment, 3: It was a quick read but I was entirely bored.
Overall, 5: For fans of Tezuka's work, this may be a nice look into the past. There is a certain charm to its simplicity, but I unfortunately would not call myself a fan by any means.
Story, 5: The chapters in the translation I read were 4-koma panels that detailed the life of a preschooler engaging in various activities. The stories were not unlike something you would see in a newspaper's comic section. Due to the short nature, there wasn't much developed or enthralling.
Art, 5: For the time period, it was fine and very similar to Western comics. I wasn't blown away with anything in particular.
Characters, 5: The extremely short stories didn't really help any characters feel particularly distinct in any way, but they were relatively charming from a comedic aspect.
Enjoyment, 3: It was a quick read but I was entirely bored.
Overall, 5: For fans of Tezuka's work, this may be a nice look into the past. There is a certain charm to its simplicity, but I unfortunately would not call myself a fan by any means.
Faire un don
Maa-chan no Nikkichou
|
Auteur
Tezuka, Osamu
Artiste
|
commentaires