Les critiques de livres

sentience13
Apr 03, 2021
Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu review
# Let’s get the first thing out of the way! I do not know how the author managed, but they put drama in every, single, chapter. Yes from chapter 1 to 99. Albeit that most of the drama was cliche and you could spot it from a mile away, but wow that is a record. After reading 99 chapters in one sitting, all the constant drama was getting annoying. Everyone could use breathers and a pause from some of the eye-rolling I was doing.

# This plays up the “ideal” couple. Now when I say that yes they do have their flaws, but overall they are happy, and faithful just to name two. And before anyone can tell me that it does happen in real life, yes it does. But it is soooo rare so the “ideal” couple is not something everyone can resonate with and raises the bars for guys/girls. But again they had flaws, which was great. They could grow and become better people together and that was something to read this manga for.

# This manga felt like life lessons were thrown one after one at me. They were sly but it felt like that nonetheless. One being decide your own path for yourself. Work together and support each other, each other’s dreams and wishes. respect. Happiness takes work. You can always change and better yourself if you choose to.

# The side characters were just brought in when needed or for a side gag. That’s all. Only 2 get major improvements to themselves, but after that poof. And yes, I get it, they aren’t needed overall but they shouldn’t be dumped either, but thats something I greatly believe. For one example, I actually thought that Tsubaki and Sakura’s father wasn’t in the picture until I saw him in ONE PANEL around chapter 80.

# [SPOILER]
I am not a big fan of having the guy force themselves on a girl. And that happened in the first few chapters (although there wasn’t any sex, that happens WAY later). Even if it is a kiss or undressing someone, no. I extremely dislike when the male characters (based off the majority I’ve read/seen) do this.

# Apparently, in most places you try to read this, some of the pages are scanned terribly and/or missing translations. So sometimes its just plow through and try to enjoy by zooming in.

# To stop my ranting about the negatives, let’s go to the positive. The story flowed so smoothly. The romance parts were well written.

# Art I would say rates a 8/10 for me.
Also side note, for some reason this reminded me of Lovely Complex? I can’t say why nor was it the art solely but there was something there that led me to that thought.

# The drama as much as I complained that there was a lot, was not dragged out. And the whole story didn’t dwell on one thing for too long that ended up killing it. The ending was great as well, it left you happy for the main characters without spoiling it too much.

# The characters, the emotions, and even some of the experiences can and will definitely resonate with readers.
0
0
0
Johncli117112
Apr 03, 2021
Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu review
Story:
I like the story. It does start off very typical and shallow which off puts people at first glance but then after awhile you notice that this isn't gonna be all roses and candy and that these characters really do think like a person would (even if it's not rationally). I think once you get over about the first or second story arcs, which I didn't mind and did enjoy, you get into some of the more entertaining and interesting parts. It's those chapters that got me hooked and keeping updated with this manga.

Art:
The art is really enjoyable in my point of view. Most things are in proportion, the clothing is recognizable (and cute!). I really like how the characters hair are draw as well! Also even the sub-characters have recognizable faces, cause sometimes all the background kids have the same face and you can't even tell who's apart of the conversation.

Characters:
I think the characters are constructed well. They have problems that have been rutted into them from past experiences, albeit they can be a little over the top about it sometimes but you do understand where they come from and why they feel the need to do things.

Although the main character Hibino can be misunderstood a lot or seems annoying, I did feel a connection to her because I felt we were kind of similar (not that I'm gonna go chopping off peoples hair and falling in love with them LOL). Not really in her romantic point of view but some of the other attributes she has. She was an insecure yet hard headed girl with a big sense of responsibility. She changes gradually, although she still keeps a lot of her previous attributes, but I think it works out well for her character.

Overall/Enjoyment:
I really enjoyed it! In all honesty I read it, I liked it, I continued reading it. I decided to write a review because I really do think it deserves a little more credit than it is given. Maybe it isn't for everyone, or maybe I like it more than I think I do, but really it's up to whoever reads it to decide. C:

NOTE: I'm not really so much a nit picker about reading manga or watching anime which is why my review is probably all over the place.
0
0
0
washington-rain3
Apr 03, 2021
Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu review
I do not understand why this terrible series is so damn popular (though I say the same thing about Twilight too) and just when you think THAT story couldn't be made to be more misogynistic than it is, Kyou, Koi Wo Hajimemasu will unpleasantly surprise you. This is bad as Mayu-f*cking-Shinjo's works. In fact, I will be amazed if the author of this garbage didn't EXCHANGE WRITING NOTES with Shinjo, let alone know her They'd probably be best friends! Yes, I imagine it would go something like this:

Minami Kanan: Hello! I love your work! Your men are so hot. God, asshole rapists sure do turn me on!

Mayu Shinjo: Oh yes!! They are the best! RAPE IS LOVE! I love your work as well! Horrible men are beautiful! They are so perfect too...like GODS! They should be the only sex in this world....that's what I've always believed.

Kanan: LOL! I know....women are so STUPID! All they do is cry! They belong in the kitchen for all eternity!!

Shinjo: Like TOTALLY!! I wish I'd been born a man. :(

Yeeeeeah.

Art: The artwork is nothing spectacular. It's much like the mediocre style of shoujo series that remain that: mediocre. But to call this series as a whole "mediocre" is far too much of a compliment.

Character: This is the part that will probably make you bash your head against the wall...if you were holding high expectations. Because shoujo manga in general really does characters right when it tries.

But this manga doesn't try. Not at all. Neither main character is likable. The heroine is a doormat who puts 1+1 together and ends up with "purple". The "love interest" is an abusive jerk who makes the childish "bad boys" of the more family-appropriate shoujo series look like saints, BEFORE their character development. He's perverted, he's a bully, he's mean. I don't mean as in name-calling or playing impish pranks or tsundere-pretending that he doesn't care (when he clearly does)
I mean "MEAN" as in "why hasn't this girl called one of those hotlines that help with domestic abuse yet?"

Now, as you can see, I did not finish this manga. I don't want to....because the ending to chapter 6 disgusted me so much that I don't think anything could possibly save it. NO girl with a brain or an ounce of self-respect would come to the same conclusion the heroine did. Unless she was a complete masochist, perhaps. It's so infuriating that I'd probably throw this book into a wall and then burn it.....had I been reading a physical copy...and thank God I didn't decide to buy this on a whim because I'd be demanding my money back in order to do something more productive with it, like using it to clean up my dog's poop. :(
.......actually that's a brilliant use for this manga for everyone who was unfortunate enough to spend money on it. :'D
0
0
0
Suzuhana8
Apr 03, 2021
Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu review
This was the worst manga I have ever read. Recently, I've been on a girly romantic manga binge so this seemed right up my alley. Wow, was I in for a shock.

The main male character is a huge dick, no seriously this guy treats his girlfriend horrible.

You might find this spoiler-ish so read at your own discretion,

This poor girl starts out a innocent girl, poor girl gets harassed by her whole class and then somehow falls in lover with the guy that almost rapes her and the one that treats her like absolute garbage. This guy is CONSTANTLY bringing her down.

They take a school trip and Tsubaki really wants to not sneak out and stay an extra night because she could lose important recommendations she needs to further her life. This asshole actually makes her feel bad about it and basically guilts her into it.

This girl made it painfully obvious she was not ready for sex but this doucheturd literally makes the moves on her everytime and then somehow HE gets his feelings hurt over it,

This manga was painful. The main girl was a crybaby constantly looking like she was butthurt about something. Constantly apologizing for shit that wasn't even her fault. Plus she almost gets raped THREE TIMES and just shrugs it off. One of the guys even leaves marks on her but she ends up helping him out later on. Come on girl.

Tsubakis sister Sakura, is a damn whore, who's writing this shit? She's 14 and sleeping around. This whole damn family needs help.
You know what forget the family, let's talk about the members in the school. Do these kids have anything better to do than to sleep around with the school whore, aka Kyouta the main male character. These people are literal trash. Why does no one bat an eye that EVERYONES slept with this guy? And Tsubaki is totally fine with it?.


So if you want a crybaby girl, who blames herself for her asshole boyfriends actions, look no further than Tsubaki, if you want a total toolbag main guy, Kyouta is your guys,

Join these two on their everlasting struggle to stay in a relationship over bullshit fights that don't even make any sense. Don't waste your time, please. This was absolute trash
0
0
0
Nayoko-Kihara4
Apr 03, 2021
Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu review
Reading shoujo manga, at one point of time, was almost a hobby of mine, something that I enjoyed tremendously. I could read almost anything and everything that the genre had to offer, irrespective of how good, bad (or downright horrible) that piece of work was. The obsession was relatively short lived though, thanks to the gradual loss of interest in the genre. Through the course of pursuing this guilty pleasure activity, I came across works that could be passed off as decent and those which made me feel like I might punch my computer screen in disgust if I read any further.

Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu without a doubt falls rightfully in the latter category for me. Yeah, you get the drift; get ready for the rant.

If I have to sum up this manga in one word, then it is ‘atrocious’. It is your clichéd, run of the mill shoujo story without any substance or sensible development; rather it only keeps getting worse with every chapter. Actually, there’re better stories out there with more or less the same setting and plot but this one is so bad that even calling it ‘mediocre’ is unimaginable, in my case at least. Throw in a bunch of shallow, stereotypical characters of the worst sort and you have the recipe for a horrendous piece that is Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu.

Speaking of the characters, Tsubaki Hibino, frankly speaking, is one of the most infuriating shoujo manga heroines I have come across. She was somewhat likable in the beginning when she actually had a backbone and didn’t let her guards down before the male lead but that façade of her wears off in the blink of an eye when one morning she wakes up and the realization dawns upon her that she is in fact madly in love with Tsubaki Kyouta, the male protagonist of the story and an equally annoying character who appears to suffer from something called the jerk syndrome. He is your clichéd, school’s heartthrob with a nasty personality and yet girls dig him because he is just so hawt! The other characters, if there are any that is, are more or less bystanders. Oh wait. Did I mention Hibino’s sister? She pulled off her role of the ‘bitchy rival’ in this incredible love story pretty well. I will give her that.

The artwork is the only aspect of this manga I can rate a bit high in comparison to everything else it has to offer. There is the typical shoujo feel to it but it is well done nonetheless.

For some reason, this manga is actually admired by many people which comes as a surprise to me. Well, whatever said and done, I am no one to question their taste. But now that I contemplate, I wonder why I even went through the trouble of reading those 13 chapters. Was I that bored and jobless? Possible. That or I, somewhere deep inside me, was wishing for something good to happen in the story, only to be utterly disappointed as it did not even come close to anything that would make me feel optimistic about it. The bottom line is, Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu is by no means worth recommending to anyone who is looking for a decent piece to read. You might pick it up if you wish to pass your time but if you ask me, I would suggest you to look for something else.

-Dissection of the score-
Story: 3 | Art: 6 | Character: 2 | Enjoyment: 2| Overall: 3

[This review is an edited and improvised version of the original review posted on October 16, 2011]
0
0
0
Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu
Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu
Auteur Minami, Kanan
Artiste --