Les critiques de livres

SANstorm8
Apr 02, 2021
Omoide Emanon review
Will make this review short. Thanks for reading in advance.

Story - 7
Art - 8
Character - 8
Enjoyment - 7


Memories of Emanon is a short, sad story of this wander with no name possessing a 3 billion-year-old memory of life on earth, not just human life, the life before as well, the entire evolution. Whilst the premise may seem great, the story is just a cut of one of the multiple different eras the wandered dubbed 'Emanon' goes through. Emanon is interesting, she leaves you with quite a bit of vague denotations such as a one I will give. You can tell that she has been wandering for a very, very long time. This in itself is an understatement. Thorugh this grand journey, she has come as far as to have lost her name. She has probably been named so much that her original/first ever name just isn't something she can't remember, which would be a contradiction, depending about how you look at it. As for the unnamed narrator, who by the way narrates for quite a stretch of time considering the size of this story which made for the flow to be a little bit boring at the start, is just a plain dude with a deep love for sci-fi novels. He is one of the many people Emanon has encountered. I find him ironic about how he has never been named in the duration in the story, yet he gives the Emanon, an anagram of 'no name', a name. One could perceive this as the writer's way of showing that Emanon has, is, and will go so far on this roam that the dude's name would have never made it to the future anyways. Or the writer was just lazy. I prefer (and believe) the former. The story is good at leaving little details to make you think, kinda like Emanon and her thoughts with the sci-fi dude.

The art is really good. When I first saw the cover you could tell that this was a style that if you were to come across again, your mind would instantly refer back to this. The art has been made well, the only reason I am not giving it a 9 or 10 is that it isn't groundbreaking. It is a coined style that has its glory but doesn't have the bright shining light to go with it.

This isn't the most enjoyable thing in the world but it makes you think, namely, about Emanon and the countless encounters, sights, places she has been associated with over the past evolution of life. That is where the enjoyment lies, the enjoyment of thinking about such a power.

Overall - 7.5 (8)


I recommend this manga, I read it in about 1 hour and it is one of those short stories that need to be added to one's collection of manga that needs to be read.

It is sad.
It is sweet.
It is unreal.
It is mysterious.
It is deep.

Memories of Emanon can show you all of that.
0
0
0
monosyllable9
Apr 02, 2021
Omoide Emanon review
A work that doesn't sell itself by the conceit, it just sells the conceit.

Its awesome how something so short can be so fascinant, I got really involved by the idea and by the interaction of the characters, even though it was brief.

The conceit.

The conception of Emanon is consistent enough for the story get close to perfection. The Emanon's billions of years were pass on a few of pages and have a shallow explanation, but it gives me space to imagine satisfatorily how was to Emanon. Even though its absurd to imagine that one generation had survive for billions of years, and that all of them have procreated (as the idea is awesome, I obviously already imagined myself in her place, and I would worry about the next generation, since I couldn't die without giving birth).

The "No Name".

As the conceit, Emanon is also a great character. By her vision, the decades are like just some hours for us, and its very well reflected. Her behavior and ideals are justifiably amorals and on the same time, perfectly humanizated. The pages without dialogues, that we don't know if its break of time between one of another was of some minutes, or if was of decades, they are so engaging that I got myself looking at them by some time. Its incredible how the manga really pass to me how lives the No Name.

The artists

Also, the art is particullarly beatiful, just like Emanon (isn't a commentary that I made previously, neither for my waifu...), its charts have excellent angles and it helps in the immersion of scenes. Simply, an excellent work to the illustrator.
And the writer made a great job as well, his subtle character characterization and his philosophic and ellegant metalanguage make a consistent and deep atmosphere. Even though the narration was a little excessive, his story is pratically perfect for its propose.

My personal experience.

I had a block to get emotionally involved with the work. It passes a lot of feeling by an indirect way, almost imperceptibly, and it can be a problem if you want to get personally involved by the drama, because at least with me, the story was just interesting.
By the way, I get involved after all, at levels so complex that I can't explain easily. I loved the idea, and really imagined myself on the situation of both main characters, because both are well structured the sufficient to open space for that. I yet didn't read the season 1, but I really hope that be a literally sequel and that doesn't push a second plot cannon in the story, becaute for me, the "empty"'s conceit is absolutelly interesting, I'd like to see Emanon's natural life.

Conclusion.

If you have interest in meet some different manga, with ideas and approaches differents of anything, take it a shot. As mush for the experience of reading something so different as for the baggage of knowing that something like Emanon exists, the work is worth it.
0
0
0
AoiRingo1
Apr 02, 2021
Omoide Emanon review
Imagine having a three billion old memory that encompasses everything that has happened, even that of the origination of life itself. Is it possible to cope with it? How will your life and surroundings affect you and vice versa? Omoide Emanon is a heartwarming and fascinating tale of a 17 year-old girl who possesses an ancient memory that dates up to the creation of life.

The approach on the narrative is utterly fascinating and well done; it is narrated in a span of a couple of hours, then makes a jump to the future. The story is established in 1967, which starts off by slowly building up the scenario and introducing the main characters. The protagonist Emanon, financially low on resources, decides to return on ship to her hometown in Hokkaido. Therein she encounters a young sci-fi lover: through soothing and everyday dialogues, the story transmits the personalities and emotions of the characters well. Emanon will ultimately reveal her secret to him, which leads to the past of the lead character and other reflections she has from current society and how it changed.The reader can really begin to appreciate and ponder about humanities nature, and specifically how such a memory would have potentially affected their own life (and that of Emanon), the decisions and hardships.

The cast of characters in the manga is composed of the two mentioned previously. There is Emanon, who continually fell in love in her childhood and adolescence due to her memories. After enduring one rejection after the other, she decided to travel, in order to explore and search for answers about herself. Then there is the young man who is a sci-fi lover. Because the manga is short, little character development takes place, but the reader gets to appreciate the characters personality. It is interesting to see how the man represents how most young, optimistic people turn out to be: having a decent job and a family, without changing and adapting themselves to society.

The art of Omoide Emanon is fantastic. Stunning and realistic character designs, detailed backgrounds; almost every panel had a background, which enhanced the realistic setting and overall narrative. There were some inconsistencies to be appreciated throughout the manga, but this was a minor issue.

To sum up, Omoide Emanon is a brilliant story with a fascinating idea that was well executed and presented to the reader. With the fantastic art and good pacing of the narrative, this manga fulfilled almost every aspect it thought to explore, though it doesn't go into too much detail. It could have had the potential to be a longer series, but nevertheless I would highly recommend this to any reader.

Thank you for reading.
0
0
0
Aureole4
Apr 02, 2021
Omoide Emanon review
I randomly came across this manga when i was in the library with some friends. The cover caught my eye and i curiously lifted the book off the shelf. After inspecting both the front and back cover i had my hopes raised. I was hoping for a sad, slow-paced story about a lonesome girl and the ocean, and i got more than what i was expecting.

The art. Yes this was the main point that i loved about this manga. I simply love rugged, imperfect backgrounds with plenty of detail and shadows. You can probably tell by my profile, but this was more than i asked for. On several occasions, i had to stop reading in order to grasp the picture, grasp the detail and relive the effort that the artist had when drawing every single brick, powerline and railbed.

For me, the story was nothing special. However, i know what the author felt like when making this story. When i am bored, i occasionally daydream. I create beautiful scenarios that i feel that only i can enjoy fully. I dream of playing with a girls soft brown hair while sitting in a train coupe. The wooden benches are uncomfortable, but her presence makes me ignore that. The morning sunrays sift through the small white curtains and land on her face. We pass dense forests, open lakes and even large hills. Where are we going? To be frank it doesn't matter.

For us dreamers, this is complete bliss. Even though i cannot appreciate Emanons story good enough, i know that for the author, it was a fantastic daydream. So good, that he turned it into reality.

Emanon is a fine character. It's the girl of our authors dreams - different and mysterious.

Those are my thoughts on this great manga. I am glad that my eyes stopped on this blue book during that tired afternoon, it filled the rest of my week with happiness and enjoyment.
0
0
0
Keitaro0046
Apr 02, 2021
Omoide Emanon review
I really find it difficult to talk about Omoide Emanon. I think the word I'm looking for is alexithymia. It really is rare for me to read something like this, actually this is the first thing I've ever read of this kind. I picked this up from a list of one of my friend and I'm glad that I had the pleasure of stumbling upon this little gem, quite frankly I think this is one of the best one-shot manga ever written. This was originally published as a story by Shinji and later Kenji's editor asked him to start working on this. And later it was serialized and released as one volume manga.

Despite being a nine chapter one-shot, Omoide Emanon goes considerably deep into philosophy. It splendidly manages to transact a poignant and beautiful tale of reminiscence and wonder. It is surprisingly lovable and astonishingly emotional. After I was done with the reading, it left me wondering how short we live and how ephemeral everything we do is. Omoide Emanon serves as a catalyst for our brooding illustrates how abortive things we strive to do are. My manga reading journey is short and plain fruitless, and I enjoyed reading this than I had in a while. It certainly succored to evoke some thoughts and has affected the way I see things. This IS really a short read, and also I'd recommend anyone to read this, in fact, if you're reading this then please spend an hour of your day to read Omodie Emanon.

Emanon is definitely a fascinating yet enigmatic character portrayed. She confides in the protagonist that she holds a 3 billion year old memory that dates back to the beginning of life on Earth and spans entire lifetimes. There is a hint of nostalgia in her words as she talks about her past lives. Yet despite her vast knowledge, she travels alone and doesn’t seem to make many close personal connections. It is their shared mutual loneliness that leads her and the protagonist to make a connection during the night aboard the ship, and they end up talking about a variety of topics from pop culture to philosophy. There are numerous hints at her background, and it’s a bit disappointing that we don’t get to learn more about her past lives.

The art was definitely great and stroked well with the manga. The artwork carries the beauty of the manga perfectly, it was also due to artwork that the complexion was so gripping. The colored pages are actually water colored were beautiful to look at and firmly rooted in reality, will be waiting for a full colored version, hope there'll be one.

In short, Omoide Emanon is a unique science-fiction on a large scale and I promptly fell in love with the story and the characters. There are two more sequels and I've started reading one of it already, though it is shame that I think we don't get into the depth of Emanon's past, nonetheless I'll be definitely reading the sequels.
0
0
0
Muzi081
Apr 02, 2021
Omoide Emanon review
Omoide Emanon is a short manga, adapted from a japanese speculative fiction. The story revolves around a young compulsive man, who meets a mysterious wandering girl, referring to herself as "Emanon". The man becomes aware of the fact that Emanon's memory begins 3 billion years ago, with the formation of life, and will continue to be passed down, in the fashion she received it, to her offspring. This short manga illustrates the affect the two have on each other, and the unique nature of their relationship beautifully, seeking to assert a claim about the tricky topic of purpose.

The highlight of this manga would definitely be the characters. All the characters are realistic, and incredibly compelling. I found myself falling in love with Emanon in tempo to the fascination and companionship that the man eagerly seeks throughout the work. The man and his life painted a portrait so true to the human experience, that is not revealing or insightful, but hopeful.

The conflicts depicted in the work, are well portrayed, easily anticipated as they are somewhat scripted. The entire situation of their fateful encounter, and subsequent interaction would be much more compelling if the circumstances were more expansive, or perhaps, just better thought out.

The art, while nothing new, holds a familiar charm that helps to accent the realism that the work strives for

All in all, Omoide Emanon is a short, but bittersweet read that no enthusiast should pass over..
0
0
0
Exill12
Apr 02, 2021
Omoide Emanon review
How would it feel to have 3 billion years of memory? My brain can’t even begin to comprehend something so vast. And yet, this is exactly what this manga is about.

Honestly, it's hard for me to find the right words to describe this manga. I don't want to simply recommend a manga because it's good. I want to share an experience. I won’t hesitate to say that this, at least for me, was a masterpiece. Of course, it’s not perfect, but after reading tons of mangas, Omoide Emanon was like a pearl in the sea of clichéd and boring stories.

First of all, let me be clear that there's no action here, no real character development. The story doesn't focus on romance and it's not exactly a slice of life either. The plot is surprisingly simple and yet it feels like it doesn't fit into any category. It's a very heartfelt, one of a kind story that simply draws you in and makes you feel at peace.

Emanon is a young, beautiful and mysterious lady who without much ado starts telling her unbelievable story to some stranger she met on a cruise ship. A story of how she came to possess 3 billion years worth of memories. I'm not gonna say anything else about the plot. The story is short as it is. Instead, I'll tell you how I felt while reading it. I felt like I was in tune with the entire universe.

It's been some time since I've read this manga, but it still remains fresh in my memory. It firmly occupied a place in my heart and no other story has come even close to the uniqueness that is Omoide Emanon. I would recommend this manga to any mature reader.
0
0
0
Master10K11
Apr 02, 2021
Omoide Emanon review
After I had read Omoide Emanon's description, I was positive that it would be an experience out of the ordinary. Having finished it, it left me with a feeling hard to describe, the closest one being pure awe.

The story starts off on a cruiser en route to the southernmost of Japan. Sitting cuddled in a blanket against the cold outer wall of the ship, an ordinary male high school student soon finds himself in the company of the not-so-ordinary titular character Emanon: a beautiful young woman with long, lustrous hair, a wave of freckles sprinkled across her nose and a memory as massive as the Earth itself.

One thing leads to another and the two end up in the cruiser's diner, where Emanon offers to tell her unbelievable story, having noticed the huge amount of sci-fi books in the student's bag and feeling that he bears a resemblance to someone dear she knew long ago. He happily lends her his ear and becomes subject to an amazing tale; as it happens, Emanon possesses the memory of life itself; it has been passed on from mother to daughter since the first single-cell organism was born in the vast ocean of three billion years ago.

Omoide Emanon consists only of one single volume, but it packs more of a punch than most longer manga I've read. The story is original and mind-boggling, the art consistent in its detailed excellence and Emanon herself is one of the most charismatic and attractive characters I have come across in manga/anime. It rendered me speechless - in a good way.

I can imagine that reading Omoide Emanon is very much like watching the Earth from orbit: to be enveloped in the inescapable knowledge that your own meager existence is but an insignificant, infinitely ephemeral moment in the history of the universe and be taken aback by the awe-inspiring beauty of it all.
0
0
0
Omoide Emanon
Omoide Emanon
Auteur Tsuruta, Kenji
Artiste --