Les critiques de livres

Angelo_Moon8
Mar 26, 2021
Last Game review
Ahhh, how much I wanted to love this series, but I just couldn't.

I'll go straight to the problem: pacing and characters.

For the most part, the story is slow, that in and of itself is not a problem, it allows the reader to become attached to the characters and understand them. Which in turns yields a more rewarding story, especially in romance. The problem is that at a certain point the story drags out to a painfully slow pace where the author does everything within their power to stop the story from progressing. The story would have been perfectly fine being 10 chapters shorter.

Adding insult to injury, the ending is then rushed. With the characters revealing their feelings in a ridiculous cliche moment and tieing all loose ends in just 3 chapters.

As for the characters, they are perfectly fine during most of the story, but towards the end, it feels as if I'm reading about two completely new people **SPOILERS AHEAD** Yanagi goes from being the guy that wants to prove himself by his own merits and who wants to be there for his love to being a clingy love-struck moron. Meanwhile, Kujou goes from being a girl who is learning how to relate to others and who is discovering her love for Yanagi to being cold and distant. **END OF SPOILERS** I don't think the way they behave towards the end is unrealistic or bad, but I do feel like they are completely different characters to the ones that they had been before and there is no progression from A to B to bridge the gap.
0
0
0
ikutokun906
Mar 26, 2021
Last Game review
Story: 9

Honestly, this manga overloaded me with so many different emotions. There were times where I would be crying because of how cute Yanagi and Kujou were together, but there were also times wherein I had to take a break from reading because of a headache of frustration. The plot isn't completely original, I've seen other shoujo manga with an extremely similar plot to it, however, out of all the others, I strongly believe that this was the best way they were able to explain the actual story and what was going on in it. There are two things that disappointed me in the story, which was, firstly, the ending, which I thought was kind of rushed. The second thing I disliked was how slow-paced it was, but that didn't bother me TOO much.

Art: 8

The art was decent, but not enough for me to give it a perfect score. I did like the art very much and did in fact think it was cute, but it's just not my cup of tea. But that was only during the very beginning. Later on, I learned to slowly fall in love with the art style, and I have to admit, after finishing the entire manga I did miss it very much.

Characters: 9

The characters are slightly cliche in a way, I have to admit. But I do love them all. Though they may be stereotypes, the author proved that it's possible for a stereotypical story to be good, if written well. The two leads have an amazing relationship, and it always made me go "Aw!" Additionally, I don't usually favor clueless, way too innocent leads, but Kujou was an exception, she's definitely one of my all-time favorite shoujo manga protagonists.

Enjoyment: 10

I can't even explain how much I loved this manga. It's definitely one of my favorites and it really did raise my expectations for shoujo a lot higher. My heart was so happy as I read this, and it broke into pieces when I finished it (but that's only because I wanted more chapters).

Overall: 9/10
0
0
0
Nikki_Manga9
Mar 26, 2021
Last Game review
So I found this manga on a whim. Read it quick, like I would any Shoujo.

But as went down my list, and read more and more, I kept re-opening it to check over the small things.

Then a few updates just so happen to catch my eye, and I was taken in, absorbed into the beauty that is Last Game.

Shorty after, I bought the volumes, and now, everyday, I check to see if the scanlators have translated.

EVERY. DAY.

**NO SPOILERS**
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Story:

I'm quite surprised when I say that the story is actually rather simple, as most Shoujo are, but this one seemed a bit unique, at least. Yanagi Hisato, stands at the paramount of society, high above those deemed beneath him in the social totem pole. He has the intellect, the athletic prowess, the drive; everything you'd need to be considered "Perfect".

But then she comes.

Kujou, a girl that eclipses him at everything: sports, tests, games; except that her place is perhaps the ground at which the social totem pole sits upon. She has no friends, and with her personality, it is definitely a possibility that she wouldn't ever.

Now, Yanagi isn't exactly fond of being merely "second place" at everything. The world doesn't seem to care - of course - a rich, beautiful, intelligent, romantic Yanagi is all they need. But Yanagi is different. His drive to succeed forces him to despise Kujou, and for a decade he follows her, through elementary school, middle school, high school, and college with the ultimate goal to make her fall for him, and then ruthlessly dump her.

Of course, that doesn't exactly work the way its intended. Their prolonged relationship eventually results in an unrequited love, and with how dense she is, its going to take a very long time until poor Yanagi finally gets to tell the lifeless Kujou how he feels.

Rating: 10.
tl;dr:
Romance. Comedy. College Students/Young Adult. Unrequited Love.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Art:

The art was simply outstanding. It's simple, but Amano is just perfectly showing off here. His artistic prowess gives the feel of beauty just when its right, and throws enough chibi in to alleviate a lot of the seriousness.

All of the characters have distinct eye patterns and hair to easily distinguish them from one another while not seeming too unrealistic or ridiculous. Backgrounds, scene transitions and panel framing is excellent, a top-quality piece.

Rating: 10
tl;dr: You shouldn't have any issues with the Art. Hell, that shouldn't even be an issue with manga anyways.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Characters:

Both Kujou and Yanagi adhere to the simple "Better but not best" paradigm in their own right; Yanagi is a perfect sweet talker, and knows girls like the back of his hand, while Kujou remains perfect at nearly everything BESIDES social interaction.

The only person on earth that Kujou can say she honestly cares for is her mother, as that is her ongoing source of inspiration of love. And despite having to remain "Spoiler Free" I will say that it's quite obvious that this eventually turns into Yanagi(C'mon its a Shoujo).

There are other side-characters that contribute to the feel of the story and allow motion of the main plot, but I wont reveal them for spoilers sake.

Rating: 10
tl;dr: Funny characters put into a horrible position of unrequited love with the densest romantic partner since the last intergalactic collision of Black Holes(although given the scale of the Universe that could be actually every second)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Enjoyment:

If you don't like Special A, you probably wont like this manga. But if you are an avid fan of shoujo and you're looking for something to take up the next 2 hours of your time with restlessness and laughter, I HIGHLY recommend you find your favorite manga viewing site and give this bad boy a try.

I enjoyed it enough to write a review.

About an UNFINISHED manga.

Yeah.

Rating: 10
tl;dr: Read the last 3 lines. Yes.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Overall:

Now, it doesn't come flawless. There are a few things here and there that are a bit weird, but in the end, you find yourself so immersed in it that they are ignored. If you have any last minute questions, feel free to PM me. I am very, very, interested in Last Game, and I have been for about 8 months now.

Rating: 10.
tl;dr: This could use an anime adaption.
0
0
0
Amberleh14
Mar 26, 2021
Last Game review
**Some spoilers ahead**


Okay so on the rare occasions that I'm really, really satisfied finishing a series and I just want to write a review on a whim, I will do it like I usually do. I just had to let my feelings out, okay?


It's currently 3 am, and in the span of three days (under 24 hours actually), I finished Last Game: 9 chapters on the first night, up until Chapter 16 the next, and the rest of it today. Who can blame me? I loved it. SO MUCH.


So Last Game's premise is pretty common to me, especially with Shoujo manga. Rivals? Check. Dense female protagonist? Check. A rich heir to a prestigious company? Check. Love triangles? Check. A whole series devoted to two people who like each other, hold out on confessing and only get together during the final chapters? Check, check, and check.


Although nothing can really be considered original anymore, and one would prefer something unique, I believe that clichés can be good, if executed properly. Last Game is one of those; earning my perfect 10 was a no-brainer.


I admit I strayed away from Shoujo once I got into anime and manga again. I 've been invested in Seinen and Shounen for so long (What's not to love? Adventure! Action! Blood! Implied Romance!) But lately, I've been giving Shoujo a chance, and this manga reminded me how fun this genre was.


It's a light read, but it made me tear up a few times. It had me laughing a lot, too. Of course there were some situations that I already predicted, and some surprised me. (My favorite was Yanagi's dad!)The pacing was not bad for me. (Probably because I binged it, though.)


The characters were not hard to love either. Yanagi was the most relatable of all, (yes, I definitely break down in embarassing and awkward situations, if only internally) and Koujo's social awkwardness was familiar as well. I also freaked out when she took up accounting, because I'm taking up the same thing! Of course I had the initial dislike for the ones in the way of the main characters: Souma and Momoka (who I strongly felt are compatible and should get together.) I definitely like the character development of these two; falling in love with someone who doesn't feel the same, getting rejected, and finally, not just trying to move on, but cheering for their love as well. I ended up loving them as well


I've found that the antagonist of this story was not some disapproving relative or a long lost childhood friend, but how cowardly the main characters were with confessing to the other. I definitely don't want to hold a grudge against someone long after finishing reading. Everyone went through a lot, (although it wasn't fixated on the romance sometimes, thank God), and when it has come to the conclusion, it's unfolding was extremely gratifying.


Though it is hard for me to get some life lessons from plots with a light mood, (because I definitely need a long-ass mission with revenge and betrayal for me to get the picture) I definitely picked up some. It made me realize how effort is important, and superficial exteriors aren't. It's also okay to have people do things for you, and not just you doing it. Most of all, you need people in your life, too. There are people who love and care about you.


I must be pretty lucky to stumble upon this manga when it has already concluded. God knows I would've died waiting for the next update. I also found it at the right time because another semester in college has started and I needed a stress reliever of some sort.


Someone needs a read that isn't too heavy, and makes them smile, laugh, and feeling good after. I recommend this one. It's not bad to read all at once, too. (Or rather it's impossible not to read all at once.)


This is my first review by the way, probably my only one in a long time. (Unless I find another series that affects me so much, I want to write about it.)


Please excuse me while I think about this amazing manga for a week more.
0
0
0
SANstorm8
Mar 26, 2021
Last Game review
This is the first time I am leaving a review for a manga--especially one that I didn't particularly enjoy much--but I feel compelled to do so due to the high rating of this series.

While it's true that the overall rating of this manga is quite high (beyond the 8 point mark), I personally couldn't possibly fathom why that is.

Firstly, there's the story that's with a decent setup. After all, with a cold female lead and a charming male lead that lets himself be led around by the nose, you already have the recipe for something good. So how come that it never amounts to much? It's weird to have a romance manga where there's very little romance between the main characters for the entire duration of the series. (Is it just me who thinks that way?)

The art style is quite cute but at the same time, there's something a bit immature about it? I don't know how to phrase it, but the characters feel significantly younger than they actually are supposed to be. This conflict between their baby faces and their drunken escapades at times really gave me a sense of discord. (Then again, that's probably just me.)

That said, the main reason why I didn't give this series an even lower rating is because it does have redeeming features. For example, a lot of the gags between the characters and the comedic situations can truly give you a good laugh. Despite their cluelessness and cliched behavior, the characters are quite charming in their own right as well. Overall, this is what brings up the enjoyment factor of this manga.

However, if you're looking for something on par with other giants in this genre, I would not recommend Last Game as a title for you to go after.
0
0
0
energumene7
Mar 26, 2021
Last Game review
First review, so please bear with me here :3
Plus I'm also very easy to please so this review may be going a lil soft on this manga.

What do I think of Last Game? Its absolutely adorable. This is my first time actually reading a manga without having an anime to watch first, and let me tell you, this was probably the best choice I could have ever chosen to start with.

Story 9/10
Okay so the story is really cute. Yanagi was the perfect prince of his elementary school; rich, smart, athletic, and good looking. All until the poker faced and emotionless Kujou transfers and begins beating Yanagi at the top spot of the grade, and the top athlete. An angry little Yanagi declares her his rival, and follows his "rival" all the way into college, until he realized it was love all along. My only problem, and the reason I didn't give this a perfect ten was the fact that they do cut out most rebel elements of their relationship, but I can blame that on character development. The story is precious, and I adore the fact that Yanagi followed Kujou for ten years of his life.

Art 10/10
THE ART IS SOOO CUTEE AHHHHHH xD
Its adorable and fits the style of the show reallllyyy welll. Its cute and I feel like I'm looking at detailed chibi. The characters look well drawn and all have their own charm with appearance.

Characters 10/10
Now what makes this show is the adorable and squeezable characters. Yanagi and Kujou's interactions made my adorable meter explode a few thousand times, and the rest of the characters just tie into a well balanced slew of buds. Fujimoto's adorableness and awesomeness just makes me love her, Souma is so cute to watch, and the side characters really support the main cast well. And on to them, Kujou, my adorable child, may be a personality that I have seen before in shoujos, the airheaded type who learns a lot from having friends, but one that I don't get tired of from her. She's cute and fun to watch, and plus her cool skill with martial arts doesn't feel forced on her character. Theres also Yanagi, who for some reason reminds me of Tamaki from Ouran Highschool Host Club. His over the top reactions and crazy blushes make you love him, and then love him even more. He's precious, and I feel he received the most development from when he was in elementary school, going from this arrogant and "must be better" attitude to the cute and cool way of interaction with others. Plus he freaks out every four seconds, which never gets old.

Enjoyment 10/10
YES I LOVED THIS. It was cute, funny, and overall a really good manga to read. I am still reading it as I write this review, because I just had to express how much I loved it. The characters are enjoyable, adorable, and sooooo cute. I would love to see this manga get an anime.

OVERALLLLLLLLLLLL
This was amazing, and I recommend it to those who love mushy and cute shoujos with a touch of comedy and an adorably sweet story line. If your a mushy otaku like me, then try this manga! Thanks for sticking through this long, and my first review :D

0
0
0
dragon1542312
Mar 26, 2021
Last Game review
This was one of the first mangas i ... didn't want to read. The description sounded wierd, it's name sounded not like most shoujo, romance types, and i just ignored it several times.
But when you read it and give it a chance, it's amazing. It captures you with the very first page. At first you see the perspective of Yanagi, a prince like character who thinks highly of himself and is practically perfect. Then he meets Kujou, a girl who has average looks, not afraid to speak her mind, and manly in many ways, but she exceeds better than Yanagi, getting better scores. This of course as you say, pisses of Yanagi, who is angered how an ordinary girl like Kujou is better than him, making everything he does a game or competition with her. But as time passes by, Yanagi starts to develop feelings for her as he learns that she has a heart, tries her best and cares for others than herself, all with a beautiful smile. This story tells of Yanagi's goal making it the last game. Who will win?
The story by now may seem like any ordinary manga, Yanagi and Kujou will (maybe) eventually realize their true feelings, or maybe a love triange will apear (?!). But the story is brilliant with it's pure setting, it adventures into a story with not the typical story but making it into an adventure for Yanagi and the red string of fate. The story is a colision of comedy, romance, and "doki doki" moments giving it a score of 9 for story.
The art is cute. Of course it's not the best, but it's cute and unique in it's own way, enough to spot which guys are hot or which girls are cute (XD). I'd give it a 7.
Character, i think this is best. Sure you'd find characters like Yanagi, but what makes him unique is that the mangaka makes him seem like any ordinary pure boy falling in love for the first time. I love seeing his innocence and pretty childish personality making it hilarious and cute. I LOVE kujou's personality. It's definatley not the typical girl personality! She's strong willed, and quite straight forward. Although she's smart and athletic, she's really dull when it comes to love and friendship. Her personality makes me laugh but also warms my heart. I also love Souma, he's good looking, cute but really selfish and usually a fake prince, although i think he may have a soft side. Giving character 9.
I really enjoy and LOVE this manga. I reccomend you read it if you wish to have laughs and heartracing moments. Overall 10 marks. I can't wait for more and this is truely and amazing manga.
0
0
0
Last Game
Last Game
Auteur Amano, Shinobu
Artiste --