Arisa |
Ecrire une critique
Devenir seigneur
|
Des alternatives:
English: Arisa
Japanese: ARISA 〈アリサ〉
Auteur:
Ando, Natsumi
Taper:
Manga
Volumes:
12
Chapitres:
48
Statut:
Finished
Publier:
2008-12-29 to 2012-08-03
Sérialisation:
Nakayoshi
En train de lire Veux lire Lis Retirer |
En train de lire
Veux lire
Lis
Retirer
4.2
(17 Votes)
|
23.53%
70.59%
5.88%
0.00%
0.00%
|
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Des alternatives:
English: Arisa
Japanese: ARISA 〈アリサ〉
Japanese: ARISA 〈アリサ〉
Auteur:
Ando, Natsumi
Taper:
Manga
Volumes:
12
Chapitres:
48
Statut:
Finished
Publier:
2008-12-29 to 2012-08-03
Sérialisation:
Nakayoshi
But
4.2
17 Votes
|
23.53%
70.59%
5.88%
0.00%
0.00%
|
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Sommaire
Tsubasa and Arisa are twin sisters who haven't seen each other for three years due to their parents' divorce. They have communicated through letters, but finally decide to meet each other again. Arisa, the more gentle of the twins, suggests that Tsubasa take her place at school for a day, just for fun. However, there are things about Arisa and her school that she hasn't mentioned to Tsubasa -- dangerous things.
(Source: MU)
(Source: MU)
Personnages
Commentaires (17)
Ecrire une critique
Arisa review
I was surprised that summaries everywhere don’t say the whole plot. Leaves you wondering what the heck it can possibly be about (left me wondering), which can result in some reviews not making sense (including my own).
Arisa is about secrecy, lies, friendship, trust, and bullying. What makes this one special? The only thing that kept me reading this manga is trying to untangle the “who.” Who is responsible for everything that is going on. It might help if you know more of the plot. At the risk of not making sense I feel like I have to shed a little more light on the plot. Due to her parents divorce, Tsubasa and Arisa both grew apart, so after months of exchanging letters they finally decide to meet. Tsubasa, who is awed at her twin’s sister Arisa’s perfect life jumps at the chance to experience life as Arisa for one day. How can they look so alike but be completely different? Not only is Arisa more gentle as opposed to the “delinquent” Tsubasa, she is also more popular. Her school life is just the best according to Tsubasa. After Arisa tries to commit suicide right in front of her eyes, Tsubasa decides to become Arisa in order to find out what drove her sweet younger sister to kill herself. Everything points to Arisa’s school. Turns out there are dark secrets there, and a note left in Arisa’s locker calling her a “traitor” starts Tsubasa’s story in understanding Arisa. [Mild Spoilers] and what they don’t tell you. After her sister’s close call with death, Tsubasa can’t understand what could have happened to Arisa. Under the pretense that she is Arisa and has lost some of her most recent memories she stays in her sister's school and uses her sleuthing skills to detangle the mystery that was Arisa. After days and days of searching all she has to show for it is a reserved boy who everyone in class avoids. That is until that week’s “King Time” arrives. A game that involves everyone making a wish to the King and only one gets chosen. The one wish which is chosen will come true. They ALWAYS come true. That’s the real mystery of this manga, figuring out who King really is. Because as they say, it is all fun and games until someone gets hurt. What really bothered me is that it was all child’s play to me. I mean, I’m a skeptic. I don’t believe at all that King is an almighty deity, so why not give a wish he really can’t grant, like world peace? Then he’d be declared a failure and the students wouldn’t believe in him…but again, that is just one girls opinions and since the idea of King reminded me of, a small, tiny almost inexistent amount, of Lelouch. But then it went again before it could take form because King is/was just a kids game in the grand scheme of things. So far. I did think the darkness of bullying was grasped well here and with more than one character, we see how trapped they felt and how far they felt the had tog o to make it stop. There are a few characters in this one. Since it’s kind of like a guessing game of “who do you think King is,” that makes sense. To say the truth none of the characters were great or amazing. They were just ordinary in manga world. You have: The lovely and enigmatic Arisa. I have to say that she’s one of the characters we know very little about. I also feel for Tsubasa that she's learning the hard way , how little we know of the people close to us. Sweet and brave Tsubasa with her fun nature and bad social skills. Not to mention her ability to surprise you by being kick-ass. It makes me feel better that Tsubasa is just as lost as we are in this manga. No idea what is going on that girl. But you have to hand it to her on the not giving up front. The mysterious and aloof Manabe. Who could be son of The Dark Lord (referring to Voldemort) for all we know because we know next to nothing about him. Except that he has ulterior motives to everything. And lets be honest, since the beginning he’s sketchy. There was one other character that his role is more or less a weird one seeing as he only appears sometimes and others he is nowhere to be seen. Making us wonder if the mangaka has plans for him in the future. The art is really attractive. Just the way the characters are done shows that it took time and planning. Otherwise the making them look evil wouldn’t have been so convincing. Other than that Arisa and Tsubasa do look exactly the same except for tiny differences and the big difference that it their hair color. No flaws that I could see on the art section. So far, “Arisa” is unfolding rather slowly, we still have no clue as to what’s next or going on. Hopefully there is new development in upcoming volumes. the plot is a little weak because of the whole lets suspect this person this volume/chapter but it's worth a read. I won’t lie I have suspected everyone at least once and even characters from other manga, like some characters from Doubt could be King. Weirder things have happened in the manga world that’s for sure. |
Arisa review
Wow. What a ride.
I always found myself fascinated with the premise of this manga even before I began reading it, because it had the "psychological" and "shoujo" tags on MyAnimeList but not a tag for romance, despite the girly art. That, along with various recommendations online for this manga really got me intrigued, and I ended up speeding through Arisa in a couple of days. The story of Arisa was never a simple shoujo school romcom. From the very beginning, a mystery is presented in the form of Arisa's attempted suicide and Tsubasa's resulting desire to find out why her twin tried to kill herself. The subsequent twists and turns shape this manga into a very interesting psychological thriller, albeit involving middle school kids. Now, I'm not going to pretend that Arisa's story didn't have flaws. I won't doubt that many people will pick up on various plot holes and bullshit moments in this manga. However, I found myself so engrossed in the story that I overlooked a lot of these finer details, and I feel that anyone else who gets really into this manga like I did will probably experience the same thing. Arisa is also not your typical shoujo manga, as it relies on mystery and suspense rather than romance to advance the story. The demographic may be shoujo, but much of the drama in Arisa focuses on non-romantic elements. One of the main reasons I was able to forgive some of the plot conveniences in Arisa was because I was so invested in the characters. Tsubasa really is an endearing lead, and I loved that no matter how tough things got for her, she would always get right back up and try to fix things. She was such a refreshing change from the average helpless shoujo protagonist, and in some ways I disliked Arisa (the character) because she reflected the latter archetype a lot more. There were times when the characters' motives were rather far-fetched, to the point of being ridiculous for a bunch of 13-14 year old kids. But that didn't hinder my enjoyment of the manga, and there were numerous moments in Arisa (the manga) that were genuinely mature and insightful. Arisa has absolutely gorgeous artwork, if you enjoy very girly shoujo-styled artwork. The lines are crisp and clean, and the female characters' eyes are all sparkly and huge. I especially loved how the mangaka drew the sisters' hair, as it was always portrayed to be perfect and flowing regardless of the situation they were in. I didn't really care for the male character designs, but I probably would have found them attractive if I was a bit younger. Also the mangaka likes to feature Arisa (the sister) and Tsubasa in various outfits and hairstyles on the covers and on the pages before the manga, which was really beautiful. The only small gripe I have with the art in Arisa is when certain characters would make evil faces, as these were always overly twisted and hideous for a bunch of middle school kids. But then again, Arisa isn't exactly perfect in its realism (or lack thereof), which I will get to a bit later. For me, Arisa (the manga) was love at first sight. Everything from the perfect girly art style to the psychological exploration of its characters was exactly what I wanted from this manga. Arisa isn't deep or complex, but it's interesting and immensely enjoyable. I loved reading this manga, and that's why I've rated it so high and why I now have Arisa added to my favorites on MAL. However, I understand that Arisa may not be for everyone. In many ways, Arisa is a rather unrealistic portrayal of middle school life. Some of the characters' actions in this manga would seem drastic even for adults. But in a sense, Arisa does touch on many aspects of human nature, just in a very melodramatic fashion. For example, the idea of "groupthink" and the diffusion of responsibility that often occurs in preteen and teen social groups was over-exaggerated to extremes in Arisa, but the manga was highly effective at conveying the message that young people need to think for themselves and take responsibility for their own actions. Overall, I think Arisa is a very good manga when you simply enjoy the story for what it is and don't try to pick apart every little plot device in the story. I would definitely recommend Arisa to shoujo fans, but I would also like to recommend this manga to fans of mystery and psychological thrillers who would like something lighter but in the same vein. Of course, that isn't to say Arisa is light and happy. In fact, much of the story is quite dark. But if the summary (and this review) has you thinking that Arisa might be a good read for you, then I would go ahead and start reading. Hopefully, you'll be sucked into this story as I have been for the past few days. |
Arisa review
I’ve read up to chapter 28 in Arisa, I’ll update my review when I pick this up again later.
I’ll spare you most of the details but the story starts off with Arisa and Tsubasa who are twins at different middle schools. Tsubasa takes Arisa’s place for a day and thinks her sister has the ideal life. After Tsubasa returns home from Arisa’s class, Arisa says’ her life isn’t actually so ideal. Tsubasa doesn’t know the secret in her class or even Arisa’s own secret. With that Arisa attempts suicide and falls out her bedroom window. Tsubasa is left to solve Arisa and class 2-B’s secret. This one you just have to stick with it. Around chapter 9 I was rolling my eyes. It becomes very repetitive in many ways. Series of characters appear, you’ll peg each one to be the king but after the chapter ends you have no choice but to rule them out. Then new characters are introduced and this process begins to repeat. ..Once you get through all that though, its starts getting pretty good. I really had no idea who the King was. The bullying is at a whole new level in this manga but I actually found it to be interesting. The king became a dictator or even god to the 2-B students, if you think back to our own world history there similar cases on a larger scale. It’s a new way or looking at things, I came to like what the author did with the class. The amount of suicidal students is a little ridiculous and several students go through momentary period’s insanity. It’s just one of those things you have to let go. Like the fact that Tsubasa hasn’t been to her own school in months and no one seems to notice… I have my issues with it but at the very least its interesting. Story: 7 [good] Art: 8 [very good] Character: 8 [very good] Enjoyment: 7 [good] Overall: 7 [good] |
Arisa review
It's cool to be different.
Arisa is definitely one of the most unique shoujo manga I have ever read. It's a psychological and mystery shoujo manga written by Natsumi Andou, a mangaka who is popularly known for the art of Kitchen Princess (one of my childhood faves 😄). I read some of Arisa a while back in my library/bookstore days, but never finished it. After seeing someone praise it online, I decided to pick it back up again. I'm really glad that I did! I have to admit that at first, the story kind of creeped me out. The first time I read the manga was when I was in middle school, so I wasn't used to reading manga with dark elements in it. I didn't even read that far into it because it had just come out, but it scared me that there was an anonymous culprit (the "king") that could grant any wish, even if it meant hurting others. There seemed to be no limit to their power. I find it really enjoyable now, however. The story is very intriguing and suspenseful so that you'll want to keep reading after every chapter to find out what happens next. There are also a fair amount of plot twists. In other words, it's a good mystery. I like how original the story is, too. I've never read anything like this before. Because a lot of shoujo is more like ordinary school life 😂. The art is what you would expect in a shoujo manga with the big eyes. However, the mangaka does a good job with making it fit for a psychological manga by the way she draws people's facial expressions. The art is pretty, detailed and clean, which I like. She's also skilled at drawing hair. I thought the character designs were well-suited as well. In terms of characters, I think the mangaka did a pretty good job with them. There is good character development in the manga. We see characters come to terms with what they're doing wrong, and we see other characters mature and become stronger. I mean, unless you're tired of having a headstrong and determined protagonist, there isn't really a problem with the characters. However, I do kind of wish that the students in Arisa's class had more humanity and could think for themselves. They're all very blah as individuals. When it came to king time, they would be so caught up in it that they would act mindlessly. This is a psychological manga, though, so I don't know whether I should be complaining about that. Overall, I found this manga enjoyable and would definitely recommend it! It's a good read whether you're a mystery lover or whether you're just looking for something different from a typical shoujo manga. |
Arisa review
Have you ever read a shoujo manga and thought "We should put these characters in a psychological thriller"? If so, Natsumi Andou has got your back.
First things first: This is not a romance. This is a story about a girl who loves her sister more than anything and also a thriller. It gets a little macabre. Not gory, but pretty horrible at times. It's a thriller first and foremost, and that's where it excels. Characterization can be weird and arbitrary in the way people suddenly act illogically in a way that's convenient to the plot, and the author's prone to a lot of half-assed, unearned swipes at redemption for previously evil characters, but ultimately it's not really the point. This is a thriller. And while you have to suspend your disbelief way more often than not, it's not more than most shoujos, and it's worth it, because Andou keeps you on your toes. There is absolutely nothing predictable about this manga - from beginning to end, it engages you completely. Not to say it's perfect; this manga has very little reread value. After the initial shock, there's usually a lack of substance, resolutions that come far too easy. But it's not quite a disappointing or a regrettable read, either. There's something to be said for a story that's engaging like this, and it definitely handles its twists better than M. Night. It's akin to that really good thriller you catch on TV; maybe it's not worth $12 and a trip to the theater, but it's not time wasted. If you're in the mood for a good mindless thriller, go for it. |
Arisa review
This manga is new, so I'll update this review later when I have more material to work with...
So far, the story has developed pretty quickly. We know that there are two twin sisters named Uehara Tsubasa and Sonoda Arisa. At first the series seems like a typical shoujo cutesy manga, but turns out to be a psychological detective-mystery. ARISA at times has charm, appeal, and comedy but also manages to send a chill down your spine. It definitely has a dark undertone and hidden meaning to it. The plotline captures interest and is pretty original. I admit I got sucked more and more into the story as it progressed. It's difficult to get bored reading this, as it is fast-paced and not slow at all. After reading a couple chapters, you will definitely want to know how the story ends. The art is very good and fresh, the kind of art that you don't get tired of looking at. The characters look their age and events can be seen clearly from the reader's point of view. I love the backgrounds and the detail put into drawing the characters. None of them look similar (except for the twin sisters, of course, but you *can* tell the difference). I admire the steady pace that Andou Natsumi works at with her art. The characters seem well-developed so far. They act their age and have distinct personalities; they suspect others and make mistakes in judgment. In other words, everyone acts human. Even the antagonists manage to be likeable on some degree. It leaves you wondering what everyone's "secret" is. I can't say much else for this category at the moment. ARISA has moved at a rapid pace in only eight chapters, so I'm not quite sure if the manga will be long. For me, it's pretty impossible not to like the series. I enjoyed reading this and recommend it! |
Arisa review
So.. I was browsing some kind of shoujou to read when i stumbled upon Arisa(though means of a photo on a facebook group)
I looked up the manga because i like the way the art was drawn. Thus the rating of 10/10 :D. Read this manga in one night cause the story was different to most shoujous I'VE read 10/10, but different doesn't always mean good. The way the story portrays each character and how much I WANT TO KILL ARISA AND HER BF.... Getting ahead of myself.. Anyway.. This story really toys with how you feel with each individual. thus the 10/10 Heres where things get tricky... My enjoyment of reading this went from 10 first few chapters.. Then dropped to a 5 because of how f***ed up it all was in the following chapters.. RLY HOW CAN YOU DO THAT TO SOMEONE WHO LOOKS LIKE YOU hhhnnnnngggg.... Overall.. It wasn't bad.. Story was good (even though i feel like i wont ever be able to look at cute shoujous the same way again) i give this a 7/10 for having good art,story,characters and how that mixes with my overall enjoyment of this manga... BE WARNED ITS NOT AS CUTE AS IT LOOKS :( TSUBASAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA |
Arisa review
Though this seems like a "i love my sister so much" type of mushy shoujo manga, it is actually dark and sinister. The protagonist in trying to live the life of her sister is thrown into a strange classroom with creepy classmates that are all too perfect. She has no one she can trust or rely on, even the ones that seem trustworthy might turn out to be her worst enemy. So far it feels like a horror movie... I cant comment on the romance yet but in terms of mystery i will say that this is recommended
|
Arisa review
This manga is unpredictable.
I read this when I was like 9 or 10 and it was amazing, it's a physiological manga. It has many twists that make you flip, although this is a shoujo, I can see males enjoying this manga too (if they're not picky). This has VERY, VERY, VERY light romance. It focuses on the plot rather than useless conversations or actions that don't contribute to the story. The art is beautiful and simplistic, the covers are wow. In terms of character development, it progresses steadily. I gave an 8 as an enjoyment because I would have enjoyed some Tsubanabe, but I guess that's just a preference. I don't really see anything bad about this manga, the characters have their own backstory of why they have turned out that way. This makes the antagonist interesting and enjoyable. |
Plus