Chou yo Hana yo

Ecrire une critique
Devenir seigneur
Des alternatives: Synonyms: Of Butterflies and Flowers
Japanese: 蝶よ花よ
Auteur: Watanabe, Asia
Taper: Manga
Volumes: 1
Chapitres: 6
Statut: Finished
Publier: 2021-03-06 to ?
Sérialisation: Hanaoto

En train de lire

Veux lire

Lis

Retirer

En train de lire

Veux lire

Lis

Retirer

4.0
(4 Votes)
0.00%
100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Des alternatives: Synonyms: Of Butterflies and Flowers
Japanese: 蝶よ花よ
Auteur: Watanabe, Asia
Taper: Manga
Volumes: 1
Chapitres: 6
Statut: Finished
Publier: 2021-03-06 to ?
Sérialisation: Hanaoto
But
4.0
4 Votes
0.00%
100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Sommaire
Lately Tamao has been finding the pink nipples of his cute and slutty papa, Kouzuki, irrestisible. On his 20th birthday, his papa tells him that they aren't really father and son. Well, of course they DO IT, don't they?

(Source: Blissful Sin)
Mots clés
comedy
yaoi
Commentaires (4)
Ecrire une critique
Chou yo Hana yo review
par
leingodf86
Apr 04, 2021
What happens if the person you love is your superior as well as your servant? Well you got to read this manga to figure it out!

If your are looking for a really serious romance, this is not the one you should be reading. This manga is a farce (a type of comedy that uses improbable situations, physical humor and silliness to entertain).

The story revolves around these two main character: Doumoto and Chouko. Doumoto is Chouko's lover, superior, and servant. All these three panels of their lifestyle creates a humorous romance story. It is not really a serious romance but there are moments when it really gives you the feels. Most of the time the jokes are centered around 'sex', but without a doubt I have to say that those jokes were some of the best that I have read. All in all, the story is really captivating with lot of comedic plot that leaves you smiling until your cheek hurts.

Moving on, the art is perfect for the story. I mean it is not something that really excites your eyes, but something that tickles your stomach. What I mean to say is the art also uses 'unrealistic' drawing such as chibi Chouko, or people getting shot with guns (but do not die) and stuff like that to create a funny atmosphere. All Characters look unique and are easy to differentiate so I have no complain here.

There is not really much of a character development here. The manga jumps right into the story, and some of the time it goes back and forth with past and present to show the relationship between our two main characters. As soon as you read first chapter you will already get an idea of what these character will turn out to be like. It might take more then the first chapter for Chouko though. She is kind of unpredictable. Doumoto is straight forward with what he wants, so you don't really have to worry about those 'awkward' moments that happens in typical shoujo mangas. Starting off, Doumoto questions Chouko,"Are you a virgin?". That just proves how open the characters are.

This is a really funny and well drawn romance manga. Like I said, this does have quite a lot of sex jokes and if you dislike such jokes this is not your cup of tea, but if you do like such jokes...What are you waiting for?

Chou yo Hana yo review
par
ShinXShinra3
Apr 04, 2021
In general, shoujo features more innocent romance, while josei doesn't shy away from delving into the sexual side of relationships, with a more mature approach to storytelling and issues. 'Chou yo Hana yo' fits firmly into the second category, its story built on office romance with a little twist. It revolves around Chouko Kuze, whose family lost its fortune and is now struggling to stay afloat. She gets a job as a secretary under a very inappropriate boss, who turns out to be none other than the servant who used to tend to her as a child — and still insists on doing that, in an odd mistress/servant - superior/subordinate dynamic.

Story, Characters - 6/10

Right off the bat, the story is unusual for a Yuki Yoshihara manga: her scripts usually rely on subverting shoujo tropes and stereotypes, most often by having the main female character be horny and assertive while her love interest is the "prey". Here, Yoshihara plays the shoujo personality tropes straight, with Masayuki relentlessly pursuing Chouko instead, oftentimes in outlandish ways bordering on sexual harrassment. Other characters are given appropriate time as well. However, I would have liked to see more of Chouko and Masayuki's relationship as ojou and servant when she was young, instead of repetitive flirting attempts, as it wasn't developed enough to make their connection as adults believable.

True to Yoshihara's style, raunchy humor and visual jokes often interrupt a more serious scene; most of their effectiveness comes from how bizarre they are. However, as funny as they are, you can stretch this plot only so much until you run out of material, and CYHY ran for too long to be considered a "tight" story. And, in my opinion, some of the sexual harassment crosses the line into "too much": a certain subplot has Chouko almost raped after having a spiked drink and the outcome is handled very poorly. Other than that, the constant sexual harassment from Masayuki himself was annoying.

Art - 8/10

The art is clean, with pleasant-looking character designs, as is the norm with Yuki Yoshihara; with Masayuki hogging the story so much, Chouko in monstrous chibi form (Yoshihara's own words) doesn't appear quite as often. There's also some fairly explicit sexual content later on, but it's done tastefully and not dwelled on for too long. Yoshihara has her specific style but it's easy to tell the characters apart, and we even get a cameo from Itadakimasu's Maria, although she is more toned down.

Enjoyment - 6/10

It's a fun premise but definitely stretched past the point of being enjoyable, and I found myself becoming impatient with the repetitiveness and just wanting it to end already. Some attempts at serious moments fall flat (see above) and, as much time as we spend with the characters, there still seems to be something missing.

Overall - 7/10

All in all, 'Chou yo Hana yo' is a cute story, albeit one that I feel went on for too long; the sweet spot would have probably been around 5 volumes, without losing any of the story or slipping into tedium. If you've already read other works of Yoshihara's and are familiar with her style, it might come across as less funny. However, it's OK if you're in the mood for some wacky office romance with a different relationship dynamic than what you'd usually encounter.
Chou yo Hana yo review
par
fukak8
Apr 04, 2021
I have read the first five volumes, and I am eagerly awaiting more!

The story bascially revolves around a mistress/butler relationship - although now, many years later, they are poor. Chouka has just started working, and who should be her boss, but her previous servant, Masayuki. Whose opening question appears to be "are you a virgin?".

And this pretty much sets the tone. It is pretty much a humourous exploration of the relationship between these two. And their relationship has so many levels. That of master and servant, that of boss and subordinant, that of boyfriend and girlfriend.

I like the art. I sometimes find Chouko's chibi a bit uuuuugly, but she looks quite nice most of the time. Despite there being quite a cast of characters, everyone that you need to know is drawn well, and clearly

The characters are archetypes. Across the 5 volumes that I have read, I do see Chouko and Masayuki changing - and that is nice. The side characters are also important, and there are a few side stories that I really hope get resolved! Masayuki's character in particular I like. It is through him that a lot of the humour is worked. All in all, I have to say, I *like* the characters, and I look forward seeing where they go!

I reccomend this to people who like saucy humour. I have been laughing out loud whilst reading this. There is a lot of visual humour. and overall it is just plain funny! A lot of the humour does centre around sex, so if that is not your thing, avoid it. Otherwise, this is light, and humourous, and all in all, a lot of fun!