Les critiques de livres
thisguy20114
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
Not gonna write a long review cuz people always be like TL;DR
( Fooly- Male MC; Leo - Female MC )
Story :
Story itself isn't intriguing , just a guy who loves abs confesses to strongest and toughest warrior -and that's that. Story itself is basic but little hints and cute moments also some cute aspects and a light hearted romance. but not original ( but nearly every manga has so less significance but yeah influenced the story). but story does progresses slowly and in a neat and affectionate manner.
Art:
Art Style is good and characters are really smooth. No much dialogues, clean style and lovable pacing. Not so details yet not lacking anything.
Character:
Fooly being the Male MC has some good moments and some good areas and is dedicated. Leo - Female Lead has a likable character and good story with harem being slowly formed . supporting characters have likable personalities.
Enjoyment:
Writing this review means i definitely enjoyed. good pacing, and readable manga nonetheless with good developments. Enjoying it till now.
Overall :
Good art , charcters have likable and unlikable personalities and also every chapter is for something even if its for little. so love it and hope to read more chapters and hope to see it going at good heights.
(Note: all people have different opinions, so suit yourself try 5-10 chapters and decide for yourself)
(P.S: loved the manga and enjoying it very well, so read the manga and give it a try! )
( Fooly- Male MC; Leo - Female MC )
Story :
Story itself isn't intriguing , just a guy who loves abs confesses to strongest and toughest warrior -and that's that. Story itself is basic but little hints and cute moments also some cute aspects and a light hearted romance. but not original ( but nearly every manga has so less significance but yeah influenced the story). but story does progresses slowly and in a neat and affectionate manner.
Art:
Art Style is good and characters are really smooth. No much dialogues, clean style and lovable pacing. Not so details yet not lacking anything.
Character:
Fooly being the Male MC has some good moments and some good areas and is dedicated. Leo - Female Lead has a likable character and good story with harem being slowly formed . supporting characters have likable personalities.
Enjoyment:
Writing this review means i definitely enjoyed. good pacing, and readable manga nonetheless with good developments. Enjoying it till now.
Overall :
Good art , charcters have likable and unlikable personalities and also every chapter is for something even if its for little. so love it and hope to read more chapters and hope to see it going at good heights.
(Note: all people have different opinions, so suit yourself try 5-10 chapters and decide for yourself)
(P.S: loved the manga and enjoying it very well, so read the manga and give it a try! )
Valdrigr6
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
A simple comedy manga with a tomboyish knight girl, and her new companion, who loves her abs (and her in general S2).
TL;DR
+ cute and funny both main characters
+ blushing tomboy is always nice
+ some dark past from the female leader, adding some relevant plot besides all the romcom
+ 6-9 pages every chapter, so u can read really fast, and don't get bored
+ nice art
+ side personagens are nice, few but a imouto and a dark elf is a 10/10 IMO
- male character has no background, it's really piss me off because i always want to know more about everyone important in any series
Not much spoilers full review next
Story: 7/10
This manga is funny and cute, seeing a female tomboy blushing is a high reward itslef, never get bored, but this manga goes further, she has a lot of scars because of her fights, but her romantic interest doens't care about this (this is very beatiful and has a deep meaning for me), and always care about her, it is lovely seeing both interating, like snaping in afternoon or taking trainning
Art: 8/10
It is clean, no much dialoges, so u can read really fast and don't get bored
Character: 7/10
Female leader, Leo is a 10/10: cute, funny, strong and with a nice background history, it is everything u want from a girl in a romcom and never get, but the male MC, Fooly, has a lot to improve, like everything, with 0 background. He love abs and love her, and that is about it.
The manga has an dark elf and an imouto of the male leader, and they are good adiction for the manga
Enjoyment: 8/10
i like this manga, its very nice and funny and cute moments never get old, i just hope more background from the male leader, and will be a 9/10
Overall: 8/10
Leo definitley carry this manga, she is just awesome and overall it is enjoyable
TL;DR
+ cute and funny both main characters
+ blushing tomboy is always nice
+ some dark past from the female leader, adding some relevant plot besides all the romcom
+ 6-9 pages every chapter, so u can read really fast, and don't get bored
+ nice art
+ side personagens are nice, few but a imouto and a dark elf is a 10/10 IMO
- male character has no background, it's really piss me off because i always want to know more about everyone important in any series
Not much spoilers full review next
Story: 7/10
This manga is funny and cute, seeing a female tomboy blushing is a high reward itslef, never get bored, but this manga goes further, she has a lot of scars because of her fights, but her romantic interest doens't care about this (this is very beatiful and has a deep meaning for me), and always care about her, it is lovely seeing both interating, like snaping in afternoon or taking trainning
Art: 8/10
It is clean, no much dialoges, so u can read really fast and don't get bored
Character: 7/10
Female leader, Leo is a 10/10: cute, funny, strong and with a nice background history, it is everything u want from a girl in a romcom and never get, but the male MC, Fooly, has a lot to improve, like everything, with 0 background. He love abs and love her, and that is about it.
The manga has an dark elf and an imouto of the male leader, and they are good adiction for the manga
Enjoyment: 8/10
i like this manga, its very nice and funny and cute moments never get old, i just hope more background from the male leader, and will be a 9/10
Overall: 8/10
Leo definitley carry this manga, she is just awesome and overall it is enjoyable
AoiRingo1
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
Simple yet amazing.
"How to Treat a Lady Knight Right" is a comedy manga about a romance between Fooly, a guy who's really into abs, and Leo ,a female knight who has never been treated as a woman ,as you may expect it's not the most sophisticated story ever written, but it was never meant to be one. Each chapter is 8 pages long, full harem tropes and for some reason very funny.
The characters are one-dimensional, there's no actual plot and worldbuilding but despite that this manga is one of the funniest things that I've read so far, why? Because it's very self-aware, the premise of this manga is an obvious parody of many new fantasy stories, with long titles, distinctive premise and not so unique story , that have been appearing recently. Parody elements also appear in the actual story and ridicule far fetched plot points that we know from other stories (like sudden power ups or force of friendship). The romance, regardless of the fact that it's full of cliche elements, is really entertataining to follow, Leo is a really cute character and watching her develop a relationship with fooly is extremely delightful.
As I stated before the characters are very one-dimensional but it works for this manga, the interactions between their various personanilities oftenly turn into really funny situations with oftenly not so obvious outcome. Provided what I've written so far you'd probably expect me to say something like " the art is relatively modest but it suits the story" but actually it's not, we're obviously not talking about Berserk level of artwork but character designs, action scenes and the background are well designed and pleasant to look at, every page conveys enough information for the reader to get the joke, appreciate the panel and move forward without getting an overwhelming amount of uselles information. As I said before the characters are really well designed, each design is distinctive and suits the characters, overall the designs are very simple and have little to no details but given the nature of this manga you shouldn't expect anything more.
To sum up, if you're looking for a funny fetish manga that you can spend an evening with then "Imamade Ichido ..." is something for you. So far there are 108 short chapters which both parody and follow the tropes that we know and have seen many times, the cast is small yet diverse and consists of loveable characters, there are also nice action scenes a lot of fanservice and great comedy which only improves the experience of reading it.
"How to Treat a Lady Knight Right" is a comedy manga about a romance between Fooly, a guy who's really into abs, and Leo ,a female knight who has never been treated as a woman ,as you may expect it's not the most sophisticated story ever written, but it was never meant to be one. Each chapter is 8 pages long, full harem tropes and for some reason very funny.
The characters are one-dimensional, there's no actual plot and worldbuilding but despite that this manga is one of the funniest things that I've read so far, why? Because it's very self-aware, the premise of this manga is an obvious parody of many new fantasy stories, with long titles, distinctive premise and not so unique story , that have been appearing recently. Parody elements also appear in the actual story and ridicule far fetched plot points that we know from other stories (like sudden power ups or force of friendship). The romance, regardless of the fact that it's full of cliche elements, is really entertataining to follow, Leo is a really cute character and watching her develop a relationship with fooly is extremely delightful.
As I stated before the characters are very one-dimensional but it works for this manga, the interactions between their various personanilities oftenly turn into really funny situations with oftenly not so obvious outcome. Provided what I've written so far you'd probably expect me to say something like " the art is relatively modest but it suits the story" but actually it's not, we're obviously not talking about Berserk level of artwork but character designs, action scenes and the background are well designed and pleasant to look at, every page conveys enough information for the reader to get the joke, appreciate the panel and move forward without getting an overwhelming amount of uselles information. As I said before the characters are really well designed, each design is distinctive and suits the characters, overall the designs are very simple and have little to no details but given the nature of this manga you shouldn't expect anything more.
To sum up, if you're looking for a funny fetish manga that you can spend an evening with then "Imamade Ichido ..." is something for you. So far there are 108 short chapters which both parody and follow the tropes that we know and have seen many times, the cast is small yet diverse and consists of loveable characters, there are also nice action scenes a lot of fanservice and great comedy which only improves the experience of reading it.
euniceeloise3
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
As I'm writing this review I've read up to chapter 126.
This is a very light hearted comedy about a guy who loves strong women and their ABS.
Up until recently, this didn't have a story. Like none at all. The chapters are really short and usually end up in the same 3 punchlines:
1. MC loves Leo
2. Someone is actually a nice person
3. MC loves ABS
That's it. That was the story for the first 70 chapters at least.
And then it actually gets some development. And it's ok I guess?
Anyways, it got kinda repetetive about 50 chapters in, but the last few chapters made me wish there were more.
If you don't really need a well developed story or worldbuilding, you can enjoy this.
6/10 for me because I like women with abs as well.
This is a very light hearted comedy about a guy who loves strong women and their ABS.
Up until recently, this didn't have a story. Like none at all. The chapters are really short and usually end up in the same 3 punchlines:
1. MC loves Leo
2. Someone is actually a nice person
3. MC loves ABS
That's it. That was the story for the first 70 chapters at least.
And then it actually gets some development. And it's ok I guess?
Anyways, it got kinda repetetive about 50 chapters in, but the last few chapters made me wish there were more.
If you don't really need a well developed story or worldbuilding, you can enjoy this.
6/10 for me because I like women with abs as well.
elementalcobalt4
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
Story: 2
Just read the first 2 chapters, then after that you can watch any other chapter in any order. That's because there is virtually no progress ever in the story. You don't have to worry about spoilers... Boy confesses to female knight and joins her questing party, but for all 55+ chapters after, their relationship stays in a limbo state and the female knight never truly responds to his feelings.
Art: 8
Well, if you're reading this you're probably into fit girls or girls with abs. The art gets the job done, at least.
Character: 3
Everybody is predictable and their personalities stay the same. The main character only talks about and thinks about the knight, and we never know his background. The female knight always gets flustered when the dude does anything romantic but she never commits. Then she gets extremely mad and jealous when he talks to other girls but refuses to admit it. Repeat for 55+ chapters and you get this manga.
Enjoyment: 5
Well I have to admit I started reading this because of the girl, but halfway through the whole manga I realized it was the same crap over and over again. So I'm putting this manga on hold until the knight actually does respond to his feelings (or rejecting him). The slice of life filler isn't worth your time.
Just read the first 2 chapters, then after that you can watch any other chapter in any order. That's because there is virtually no progress ever in the story. You don't have to worry about spoilers... Boy confesses to female knight and joins her questing party, but for all 55+ chapters after, their relationship stays in a limbo state and the female knight never truly responds to his feelings.
Art: 8
Well, if you're reading this you're probably into fit girls or girls with abs. The art gets the job done, at least.
Character: 3
Everybody is predictable and their personalities stay the same. The main character only talks about and thinks about the knight, and we never know his background. The female knight always gets flustered when the dude does anything romantic but she never commits. Then she gets extremely mad and jealous when he talks to other girls but refuses to admit it. Repeat for 55+ chapters and you get this manga.
Enjoyment: 5
Well I have to admit I started reading this because of the girl, but halfway through the whole manga I realized it was the same crap over and over again. So I'm putting this manga on hold until the knight actually does respond to his feelings (or rejecting him). The slice of life filler isn't worth your time.
Nameless07
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
I'm just getting started with this so this is really a first impression of the first several chapters or so....
I've got a thing for athletic women, so that got my attention. Getting into it, it is laying out like it's being "Monte Pythons Holy Grail" with gender reversal but a romance tale. It's trying hard to not be corny, while at the same time trying very hard TO be corny. Another reviewer mentioned this being a self-aware parody of the fantasy romance genre, and I can see it going that way, but I'm not quite deep enough, yet.
I, for one, am looking forware to some light hearted romantic goofyness.
I've got a thing for athletic women, so that got my attention. Getting into it, it is laying out like it's being "Monte Pythons Holy Grail" with gender reversal but a romance tale. It's trying hard to not be corny, while at the same time trying very hard TO be corny. Another reviewer mentioned this being a self-aware parody of the fantasy romance genre, and I can see it going that way, but I'm not quite deep enough, yet.
I, for one, am looking forware to some light hearted romantic goofyness.
mangoseller1
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
idk its not so good but I like it and it make me enjoy this story
Also is kinda xd
I mean I dont know if this would work as an anime but I does as a manga, its funny and also is lovely.
idk its not so good but I like it and it make me enjoy this story
Also is kinda xd
I mean I dont know if this would work as an anime but I does as a manga, its funny and also is lovely.
idk its not so good but I like it and it make me enjoy this story
Also is kinda xd
I mean I dont know if this would work as an anime but I does as a manga, its funny and also is lovely.
idk its not so good but I like it and it make me enjoy this story
Also is kinda xd
I mean I dont know if this would work as an anime but I does as a manga, its funny and also is lovely.
Also is kinda xd
I mean I dont know if this would work as an anime but I does as a manga, its funny and also is lovely.
idk its not so good but I like it and it make me enjoy this story
Also is kinda xd
I mean I dont know if this would work as an anime but I does as a manga, its funny and also is lovely.
idk its not so good but I like it and it make me enjoy this story
Also is kinda xd
I mean I dont know if this would work as an anime but I does as a manga, its funny and also is lovely.
idk its not so good but I like it and it make me enjoy this story
Also is kinda xd
I mean I dont know if this would work as an anime but I does as a manga, its funny and also is lovely.
vaberella7
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
The power of abs is strong here 😂 its a really funny and cute read. Basically its about a weak (yet OP once he taps in his true power) mage that confesses his love to a powerful knight. Obviously she tells him to beat it, he decides to stay by her, she slowly warms up to him, and yeah that's about it.
Development is a bit slow but as the story goes on she developes feelings, and becomes a tsundere. There is harem but isn't too bad, lots of funny moments, support characters are funny, some do go a bit far but its good. Also abs 👌👌 wish the fighting picks up more, there is combat but just a few here and there. Still good read, highly recommend.
Development is a bit slow but as the story goes on she developes feelings, and becomes a tsundere. There is harem but isn't too bad, lots of funny moments, support characters are funny, some do go a bit far but its good. Also abs 👌👌 wish the fighting picks up more, there is combat but just a few here and there. Still good read, highly recommend.
Playcool2
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
A lot of people reviewed this WAAY too early. It's by no means a masterpiece but it's a cute and fun palette cleanser with some quirky humour. If it awakens any muscle fetish in you- well that's on you not the manga.
Small amount of pages means no wasted time on fluff but given enough time all characters get a measure of progression and backstory. Art style is fine, better than any web comic but nothing to brag about either. Characters are fun and light-hearted. Great in small bursts in between harsher and darker shows/manga.
In what seems to be the final arc, the stakes are high and the characters' relationship seems to be close as it can to it's final stages.
Anyone looking for something easy to read and fun should give this one a read. It will likely be finished in less than a year from this review so here's to a good ending.
Small amount of pages means no wasted time on fluff but given enough time all characters get a measure of progression and backstory. Art style is fine, better than any web comic but nothing to brag about either. Characters are fun and light-hearted. Great in small bursts in between harsher and darker shows/manga.
In what seems to be the final arc, the stakes are high and the characters' relationship seems to be close as it can to it's final stages.
Anyone looking for something easy to read and fun should give this one a read. It will likely be finished in less than a year from this review so here's to a good ending.
animelancer12
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
This is actually way more disappointing than it should.
Don't expect anything beyond the manga's attempt to present you the fetishes in the most boring and cliched way possible. There is no real nuance even with its main forte, and every other aspects of the series is as bland as it can get. Every chapter is structured the same way, and almost every attempt at progressing the relationships gets written off as a joke instead, so you won't get anything meaningful with its "fluffy" elements and romance either.
Art looks decent and easy to read, the character designs are some nice eye candy and you can probably get a good meat beating out of it, but it's overall nothing special in terms of detail and sense of space.
At the end of the day it's nothing more than a fetish manga really, so if you are into this type of content you can probably give it a go. Despite starting off with a single fetish, it has been expanding itself as well, though the "muscle girl" is still the focal point.
Don't expect anything beyond the manga's attempt to present you the fetishes in the most boring and cliched way possible. There is no real nuance even with its main forte, and every other aspects of the series is as bland as it can get. Every chapter is structured the same way, and almost every attempt at progressing the relationships gets written off as a joke instead, so you won't get anything meaningful with its "fluffy" elements and romance either.
Art looks decent and easy to read, the character designs are some nice eye candy and you can probably get a good meat beating out of it, but it's overall nothing special in terms of detail and sense of space.
At the end of the day it's nothing more than a fetish manga really, so if you are into this type of content you can probably give it a go. Despite starting off with a single fetish, it has been expanding itself as well, though the "muscle girl" is still the focal point.
WindBreaker13
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
This ended up being a disappointment more than I thought.
It forced itself to have a serious plot in the end, but it didn't work since... it's a comedy. It's not supposed to be serious.
Also, a lot happened without explanation. Like, you have that 131 chapters and you can't even explain shit??? Not even being a comedy can save it.
Moving on,
Characters are forgettable af, and they aren't even likable. Except for Helga btw. She cute. But other than her, the cast is pretty damn unnecessary. They introduce characters just for them to never do anything at all. The main characters are so weak. They have their development? But it is so cringe-ly done that I won't even accept it as development.
Art is decent. It's on the rough side since the "action" panels are so d*mn unreadable. I can't understand half the shit the characters do or how the f*ck did they ended up in that position.
Enjoyment is also decent. My immersion was broken in the last few chapters since... there was no tension at all. I gave it 4 since I laughed at the first few chapters. If it wasn't for that, then this would be lower.
Overall, it's a disappointment. I wished it continued being a comedy rather than having an actual plot.
VaskoKasko12
|
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga review
CHAPTER 43 reporting...
Story:4
There is none at the very least I'm talking about progression. Basically everything is established by chapter 1 or might be even 2 and if it weren't for new characters who are introduced later then you could open any chapter and read it, because you won't spoil a single thing.
Art:8
Not bad details, gonna say i think i might have fallen in love in those ABS....Now humor aside art is fairly good here characters are drawn to be likeable, background nothing special (since i already don't remember it) as for panel placement and bubble placement, VERY GOOD since it is readable and didn't irritate my eyes.
Character:5
Well characters are basically taken as standard manga/anime stereotypes we have tsundere, harem boy(does things to make females fall for him but doesn't understand it, yet this one proclaimed his love interest), oppai loli sister with brother complex, mature cock-tease and last but not least shy anti social one. Character backgrounds are mostly mystery besides female knights since world spins around her.
Enjoyment:8
To be fair i enjoyed it, but after reading and brooding for a bit i kinda understood one thing it is one of those never ending mangas where it will only end when manga sales will drop and then we might see 1 or 2 chapters where they marry or kiss and establish real relationships. So genre seinen is a lie i would give it shounen, romance is mostly one sided with tsundere reaction (WAS ok first few times grows tiresome, especially when female knight has been already told dead right that she should open up or else....). So if you aren't a brooding type enjoyment will be good but do not brood or overthink about series.
Overall:6
Nothing special and my brooding made me rate this series lower since you shouldn't over think about this series simply turn off your brain and enjoy if not you will start to have this peculiar feeling of annoyance for female knight and feeling of shame for magician (this dude doesn't have a speck of self dignity....love i guess but it is more like a fan boy in love in virgin idol than romantic love where 2 hearts intertwine since female knight is god of tsundere).
Story:4
There is none at the very least I'm talking about progression. Basically everything is established by chapter 1 or might be even 2 and if it weren't for new characters who are introduced later then you could open any chapter and read it, because you won't spoil a single thing.
Art:8
Not bad details, gonna say i think i might have fallen in love in those ABS....Now humor aside art is fairly good here characters are drawn to be likeable, background nothing special (since i already don't remember it) as for panel placement and bubble placement, VERY GOOD since it is readable and didn't irritate my eyes.
Character:5
Well characters are basically taken as standard manga/anime stereotypes we have tsundere, harem boy(does things to make females fall for him but doesn't understand it, yet this one proclaimed his love interest), oppai loli sister with brother complex, mature cock-tease and last but not least shy anti social one. Character backgrounds are mostly mystery besides female knights since world spins around her.
Enjoyment:8
To be fair i enjoyed it, but after reading and brooding for a bit i kinda understood one thing it is one of those never ending mangas where it will only end when manga sales will drop and then we might see 1 or 2 chapters where they marry or kiss and establish real relationships. So genre seinen is a lie i would give it shounen, romance is mostly one sided with tsundere reaction (WAS ok first few times grows tiresome, especially when female knight has been already told dead right that she should open up or else....). So if you aren't a brooding type enjoyment will be good but do not brood or overthink about series.
Overall:6
Nothing special and my brooding made me rate this series lower since you shouldn't over think about this series simply turn off your brain and enjoy if not you will start to have this peculiar feeling of annoyance for female knight and feeling of shame for magician (this dude doesn't have a speck of self dignity....love i guess but it is more like a fan boy in love in virgin idol than romantic love where 2 hearts intertwine since female knight is god of tsundere).
Imamade Ichido mo Onnaatsukai sareta Koto ga Nai Onna Kishi wo Onnaatsukai suru Manga
Auteur
Matsumoto, Kengo
Artiste
--