Hotel

Ecrire une critique
Devenir seigneur
Des alternatives: Japanese: HOTEL
Auteur: Ishinomori, Shoutarou
Taper: Manga
Volumes: 37
Chapitres: 331
Statut: Finished
Publier: 1984-09-25 to 1998-03-10
Sérialisation: Big Comic

En train de lire

Veux lire

Lis

Retirer

En train de lire

Veux lire

Lis

Retirer

4.5
(11 Votes)
63.64%
27.27%
9.09%
0.00%
0.00%
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Des alternatives: Japanese: HOTEL
Auteur: Ishinomori, Shoutarou
Taper: Manga
Volumes: 37
Chapitres: 331
Statut: Finished
Publier: 1984-09-25 to 1998-03-10
Sérialisation: Big Comic
But
4.5
11 Votes
63.64%
27.27%
9.09%
0.00%
0.00%
0 En train de lire
0 Veux lire
0 Lis
Sommaire
A hotel is a living thing. Love and joy, sadness and hate, and even betrayal; all contained within these walls. It is also a metropolis. Beauty parlor and jewelry store, restaurant and pharmacy, hospital and shoeshine. Everything you need to live is here. The Room Key is all-powerful. You can use it to buy food, jewelry, and to clean your clothes, all without a single reach of the wallet.

As a new morning comes, the being continues beating. Supplying blood into every extremity from its center. And as problems arrive, they are dealt with, leaving no abnormalities.

This is the Hotel Platon.

(Source: MangaHelpers)
Commentaires (11)
Ecrire une critique
Hotel review
par
labrizzle942
Apr 03, 2021
I stumbled onto this manga when I was looking for a good one-shot to spend my time on. The apocalyptic premise of the story appealed to me immediately, and the cover looked promising as well, with the skyscrapers half submerged into the glittering ocean. Furthermore, hotel was the highest rated one-shot on this site and so I decided it would be a good investment of my time.

I still think it was, but I'm not sure I would rate it as highly as the others who read it. The poignancy of the story is marred by a rather bizarre and hilariously bad attempt at making Keira Knightley (yes) a main character. She's married to a Japanese professor in the manga and doodles all over the hotel's supercomputer. It's admittedly a little funny but the oddity of the starlet's appearance and the inconsistency of the slapstick humor with the backdrop of a doomed world leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

Once past all that though, the story gets significantly better. I really enjoyed the recounting of the supercomputer's attempts to stabilize its environment and protect the last DNA storehouse on earth. It's a beautiful variation on the Noah's ark theme and the mangaka does a good job at illustrating all the difficulties the AI had.

My only other complaint is that there seems to be a certain patronizing symbolism towards the end of hotel. It's not quite racist per se and it's likely the artist meant no harm, but it's still something that may bother people who catch the implications.

Overall, I did enjoy the one-shot a lot though. I just think it would have been better if the author had stuck to a more serious beginning.
Hotel review
par
Gin-iro14
Apr 03, 2021
Present is a short 40-page-long story about love and presents. Yes, it‘s all about love and presents. But don‘t expect it to be sweet and shallow. It‘s much deeper than that.

Story
Present is a one-shot manga so I won’t say much. Basically, it’s a story about a student who falls in love with her teacher. Sadly, she has a rare disease which causes her to fall into a deep slumber. Doctors do their best to prolong her life but when Hanako finally wakes up, she has only three days left to live. It’s up to her husband to help her spend her last days happily.
Actually, the plot is very unique but you probably won’t realize that until the very end. And let me warn you, although the plot is short and quite simple, not much is explained. It’s left for the reader to grasp everything on his own so it might be confusing at first. It’s just like receiving a present: you get a beautifully wrapped box but no one tells you what’s inside.

Art
Well, Boichi obviously has his own style. His art is nice and consistent and even though it’s not really my type of art, I have to admit that he manages to capture the mood incredibly well.

Characters
You can’t expect much of the character development in 40 pages. Surprisingly, this is not the case in this manga. The characters are consistent and very profound. Sometimes their behavior is unexpected but realistic nevertheless. Each of the main characters has a unique personality and a strong presence. This is probably what I appreciate the most in this one-shot.

Enjoyment
As for me, this manga was very enjoyable. I liked it even more than Hotel (a very popular one-shot from the same author). Boichi managed to trick me into believing what I was supposed to believe so the ending was quite a shock. I actually had to just sit for a few minutes and let everything settle in. I was in awe.

Overall
All in all, I give this manga a big round 10. If you like one-shots, read Present. If you don’t like one-shots, read this anyway. You won’t regret it. It might not become your favorite manga but it’s definitely worth your time. Well, it won’t consume much time anyway:)
Hotel review
par
T3Deliciouz2
Apr 03, 2021
This is a scintillating tale that will put more emphasis on the time that we share with our loved ones. A Present once opened, the inclement struggle of life shall pass.

Story-There's nothing especially grandeur or ground breaking about this story. A student falls madly in love with her teacher, their is a reluctance in dating his pupil.Fast foward to Hanako being in chronic coma liked state due to an incurable disease , takao sucumbs to these difficulties as times. These stories at times try to be sensationalistic and unrealistic in trying to enthrall the reader but the story tries to be computational to real life. The propriety elicited from this manga showcases the strength of the human heart and mind that combats the turbulent events that can happen in life.

This story entails the struggles that one must go through when witnessing their loved ones suffer. This story also displays how tradegy is an ordinary and common outcome in life which Takaos father is able to empathize with his son. A coalescing of emotions become resurgent within his father remembering the life that his wife took from him will waiting at her bed side. Contrarian to that he also felt helpless watching her suffer and the continuity of her suffering with no consolation.

Due to the recuperative powers of some of the treatments her consciousness is restored but her personality is still dormant. Hanako will never be the same as her lack of what makes her uniquely herself which makes Takao feel that the world is filled with perfidy. Hanako senses Takao's innerdisorder residing inside of him, even though she can't express herself freely she still has some remote cognition.She gave him the present that Takao's father's wife failed to endow and that was the present of severring their bond. The gails and naked winds of suffering finally ended with a Present, as a gesture from a loved one telling him in a way to move on.


Art-As a relatively new manga,the colouring and usage of variations fit well with the mood of the story.Everything congealed well together, with the art being continuous in its consistency.

Character-Some might say that you need an archive or volumes of pages in order to sequester development. In this particular case that would be wrong with Hanako seeming to be a regular day girl at first and then becoming a resolute woman through sufferance. Takao fit the bill of being a concerned and trepidious spouse for his wife and the enduring pain in which he rationalized to keep on going. Their was an innumerable amounts of conflict that prompted development,which would otherwise be maladjusted and weak characters because of the length of the story. Takao's father also remonstrated within himself through the same conflicts, as readers we got a taste of how different people deal with the similar circumstances.

Enjoyment-Heavily enjoyed but saddened when reading a piece that is based upon such a sacred and personal subject.

Overall- If your a fervent supporter of a tear jerker type then I recommend this. However if your conducive to being too emotional then you might be turned off. If you believe in integrity or in the dutiful power that it takes in order to steer the ship out of the storm, I imagine this as your type of manga.
Plus