Les critiques de livres

dodex10004
Apr 02, 2021
Kitchen no Ohimesama review
I saw this manga at the bookstore, and was intrigued enough by the cover to pick up a volume to give it a try. I must say, it wasn't money wasted... just not put to the amount of enjoyment that I wanted. Don't get me wrong, this manga is definately a ten- if you're around eight years old. That is precisely the age group that this manga was written for.

The plot is typical for a young girl's manga- a bright, bubbly girl as the lead, and two boys competing for her heart. Knowing that it was for young girls didn't make the plotline more palatable- I still winced when it became clear very early on who her 'prince' was. The lead's boys are stereotypical, cookie-cutter leads for their roles. One is the bright, friendly, most-loved son oif the family and the other is an angry, argumentative 'black sheep', if they can be called that at their ages. And the Lead Girl? She can cook, and she's nice. Not terribly original- these same concepts have been put to use elsewhere with better results.

Given the legnth of the manga, you don't really get more of their personality. Of course, you also have the standard mean classmates, clueless school administrators, and the lead girl always showing them the light with her cooking. I must say, all the dishes she makes look delishious, but it still doesn't say much when that's the most memorable part of the story.

Do NOT make this the end-all of your manga experience. Use it as a chance to leap into better and better series. If you're looking for good manga that's similar, try Shugo Chara! and Beauty Pop, or if you're a bit older, Chibi Vampire , Ouran High School Host Club, or even Ah! My Goddess. Those do the same story, but with a twist each time and are classics in their own right.
0
0
0
Lolzipop99715
Apr 02, 2021
Kitchen no Ohimesama review
When you look at the cover of this manga, you might think to yourself, "This is a typical shoujo manga, and it's probably about some girl who likes cooking.". Your assumptions would be correct. So why have I given this an 8? What's so special about this manga?

STORY:8 The plot is common for a shoujo manga. Two popular boys fall for the nice, good girl protagonist. The protagonist gets bullied by others and yadayadablahblahblah. And of course, the true identity of the prince is pretty obvious. But I have to admit, there were some good, unexpected twists and sad scenes in this story, and that's what makes me give it an 8.

ART:9 I love the art in this. The characters are cute and the food looks delicious.

CHARACTER:6 MAINSTREAM CHARACTERS. MAINSTREAM CHARACTERS EVERYWHEREEEEE.
Their personalities have been seen 10000 times in shoujo manga and ehhh. I didn't feel much affection for them either. Honestly, I have to say the only one I liked was Fujita.

ENJOYMENT:8 This manga was a pleasant read. It wasn't moving or anything like that, but it was still nice enough to keep my attention. Some scenes were exciting, and happy endings are always nice.

OVERALL:8 Overall, if you're looking for a unique or realistic manga, this isn't for you. However, as some people have mentioned before me, this would be a good manga for someone who is new to shoujo manga (probably because they wouldn't be as familiar with the clichés). I'd also recommend it to people who like to look at pictures of delicious food because the sweets in here are just ^o^ !
0
0
0
Blood_Diver_A8
Apr 02, 2021
Kitchen no Ohimesama review
Story: I found this anime to be cute. Najika reminds me a lot of Tohru from Fruits Basket. Though she lost her parents, she tries to be cheerful for those who need it the most. So what is this about? When she was a little girl, Najika was rescued by a boy as she was drowning in a river, and this was after her parents died. The boy gives her a silver spoon to remember the day. Older now, Najika lives in an orphanage, and she is accepted to the best cooking school in...fictional Japan. Though she doesn't want to leave, her caretaker insists she go. Well, she does and she meets two brothers, Sora and Daichi, who both look similar to the boy who rescued her from the river when she was little. Sora is a gentleman, and Daichi is the complete opposite. However, they both try their to best to keep Najika in school whenever she gets picked on by the other students. Who is the one who saved her life? Well, I thought the story as cunning, and though Najika may be a stick sometimes, she has feelings, which keep the story going. 10/10

Art: The art does remind me of Gentlemen's Alliance Cross, but Kitchen Princess is less cluttered, which makes the pages nicer to look at. Though the brothers are supposed to look very similar, they are not identical twins. Yeah, it's the big eye shoujo manga, but it's not creepy or annoying. Plus, the artist did a fantastic job giving emotions to their faces. 10/10

Character: Najika is gonna like Tohru; she may not have personality in the beginning, but later on in the series, she begins to understand the real world a lot better than she did while she was living in the orphanage. I didn't hate her so much as her rival (I mean that girl was a real bitch); however, I would appreciate her being less of the stereotypical girl in a romance shoujo manga. Sora is a gentleman, but he is also a lady's man. Almost all the girls in the cooking school fawn over this boy, and I don't usually like that. I also don't like Daichi's asshole personality either, but the difference with Daichi is that he is very sincere when it comes to Najika. He tells her what she needs to hear, not what she wants to hear, which might be mean sometimes, but it's important as well. As the story goes on, Daichi becomes less and less of a jerk because he comes to realize what Najika had to go through when she was a child. He's also pretty jealous of his brother being so popular, which is understandable. 9/10

Enjoyment: Like Gentleman's Alliance Cross, I wanted to know what happened next. I'm sorry that I couldn't tell you much about this manga because it is only a few volumes, and if I give away too much, I would just spoil the manga for all of you. Let me just say that it doesn't have much humor, but it is extra sweet. Not annoying, but it's the type of manga that plays with your heartstrings and starts playing classical music with them. By the time this manga was done, I did tear up a little. 10/10

Overall: As said in Gentlemen's Alliance Cross, I've pretty much said everything I needed to say. If this manga were to become an anime, I would totally watch it for sure. Overall, the total score is a rounded up 10 out 10 as well.
0
0
0
Chokyo4
Apr 02, 2021
Kitchen no Ohimesama review
Simply put, it's a sugar-encrusted dessert of a manga.

More elaborately put...well, let's start simply with the characters. Our protagonist Najika has a tragic history, but is an excellent cook and seems to be a very kind, caring and generally nice person. A little bit of a Mary-Sue, but not horrible.

Our two male leads don't have much background when we first meet them, and though this does change later, we still aren't very sympathetic with their love for Najika. The supporting cast is mediocre at best, most of the characters fitting easily into stereotypes without much pushing and shoving.

The tragedy of Najika's past is continually put into the spotlight, so that, I can only assume, readers feel more sympathy for her than they would otherwise. It was fine in the first five or six volumes, but by #9 it was just ridiculous.

The art is okay, it's nothing super-special. The food is drawn well with enough detail so you can tell exactly what it's supposed to be, but it's no mouthwatering gourmet meal leaping off the page.

This story is perfect if you're a younger reader looking to start out with a nice simple manga that's easy to read and enjoy, but if you've been reading for a while and are past the stages where you gape over the huge eyes and flip confusedly through the pages reading the wrong way, Kitchen Princess won't satisfy you.

Pros:
-Good for younger readers.
Cons:
-Plotline is overused.
-Characters come off as stereotypical.
-For $10.95 USD a volume, I would say it isn't worth the money.

Recommended? No.
0
0
0
animelancer12
Apr 02, 2021
Kitchen no Ohimesama review
Kitchen Princess...a very fluffy and cute shoujo romance. But it is actually more than that, it is very gripping manga with great characters and a worthwhile romance.
STORY:
8/10
The story is fairly cliche, a girl named Najika is trying to find her "Flan Prince" who saved her from drowning in Hokkaido when she was younger. Though the original concept was not the best, the story is actually well done. There are very big twists in the plot and various love interests.
ART:
10/10
Beautiful artwork, very well done. Fits the typical shoujo image.
CHARACTER:
9/10
Najika: The heroine of the series. She dreams of becoming a professional chef like her parents and has attended the academy based on a spoon that her "Flan Prince" left her years ago when she almost drowned. I really enjoyed her. She seemed like an airhead but was really not. She is actually highly skilled and is very caring. She is also very clever and always thinks of others.
Sora: Najika's initial love interest. Very typical shojo boy. Nice and a very fast mover with girls. Very popular with girls and is captivated by Najika's talent, and later Najika herself. Again, a typical shojo boy but still adds to the story.
Daichi: Sora's brother. He is also fairly popular except he is almost the opposite of Sora. While still nice, he is more secretive and colder. Yet this is just to hide the fact that he generally cares and is carrying a huge guilt on him.
Akane: Najika's initial enemy, but later her best friend. She is a model who is very pretty. She is in love with Daichi. I really enjoyed her. She is very interesting and funny. Overall, a brilliant character.
ENJOYMENT:
10/10
More than just a shoujo romance to me. I was very upset when I finished the series. You can't help but feel happy during some of the chapters. It is an addictive one.
OVERALL:
10/10
As usual, I would not recommend this unless you like romance manga but it is a very good read.
-OtakuKLP >.< hope this helped!!
0
0
0
LithiaMysteryX3
Apr 02, 2021
Kitchen no Ohimesama review
I've never reviewed anything before, but I'll do my best to be honest and say what I truly thought rather than just buttering the manga up with praise it doesn't deserve.

When you read the first volume of this manga, you will assume it to be stereotypical and like many other shoujo manga. You have your cheerful and energetic lead and the two main boys who are complete opposites. At first, they seem like cardboard cutout characters. You can find them in any story.

As the story goes on, it changes. At first, it's just a flick, but then it delves into character depth. Starting with a character death (not saying who because of spoilers.) You see the background of each character and you start to sympathize with them. They become much less stereotypical to you.

The whole story becomes serious, something that you didn't expect. It starts making you actually feel things partly due to the beautiful art that depicts the emotions so well. It had me in tears for a character that I didn't even like.

Also, just one more thing, something that was fun in this manga was that even though it constantly teased you with who the flan prince was, it was never right! It always changed and you thought it was someone else. First it was ********** and than it was ******** and than you finally figured it out with ******. All in all, it really a complete shock to me.

Overall: This manga is amazing. It's emotional, cute, funny, and wonderful. That's all I can really say. It's a lovely manga that I would recommend to all shoujo lovers.

0
0
0
Profesor_Teto9
Apr 02, 2021
Kitchen no Ohimesama review
I'm not going to open up with a cheesy opening quoting a famous line in the manga or something no I'm just going to jump write into writing this review

Story it's a big factor of almost any manga that you will read and it is no different in this manga. The story in this manga makes the veteran otaku think "Hey, haven't I read that somewhere before?" well I will answer that question and say yes you have read it somewhere before or something like it the story is generic only with different characters setting and set up if you're coming into this manga expecting something amazing in the ways of story then you will be thoroughly disappointed, Which leads me on to my next subject.

Art it's important when reading manga because if it wasn't for the art the manga would just be a novel, but you don't want that right? I thought so. So this manga just has any generic art style you will find almost anywhere in the shoujo manga realm it's unique since the art style doesn't have much show outside of shoujo manga, but it is generic but tasteful like that salad you ate last monday.

Character's are generic bland and tasteless in this manga, but they will still make you feel warm inside after full completing the manga why? Well I will tell you why because the mangaka represents them in a way that will leave a deep impression on you heart and soul.

Enjoyment well what can I say I thoroughly enjoyed this manga inside and out I sped through this manga in 2 days because of how much I enjoyed it and how it shows the characters and story.

I rate this manga inside and out a very solid 8 why because of how the ending and the story progressed and they showed every thing in a tasteful way especially the very last line in this manga.

"I want to hear them say with a smile on their face, Thanks you! It's really delicious!"
~ Kazami Najika

Those were the last words you will read at the end of this manga and after you read those words tell me that you didn't think they presented the manga a great way.
0
0
0
harudandy3
Apr 02, 2021
Kitchen no Ohimesama review
Having found this from a recommendation sending me from Beauty Pop to here, I wasn't expecting much.
But I must admit, I got more than I was hoping for.

The story maybe isn't the most original, but in the world of shoujo manga, what is these days? The female protagonist, Nijika, as a young girl is saved by a mysterious boy who tells her "When you eat something good, you smile." These words, a flan dessert, a spoon with the engraving of a famous academy named Seika and her promise that she will one day make him the best dessert ever, stick with Nijika, until she studies hard and gains entry to the prestigious Seika academy - all to find her 'Flan Prince'.

I was incredibly impressed with the pacing of this story, having read it in a day its still very fresh in my mind and I applaud the way the writer has done it. Often a story can be too rushed or too slow to pick up - especially one with only 10 volumes but is a fully-fledged story. For example, shoujo's can very easily become a minefield of 'filler' chapters reverting back to cliches when its moving too slowly. Or, on the other hand, it can just seem to go too fast, the main character seemingly jumping into a relationship with the guy faster than I can click my fingers.

Saying that, this story definitely falls back on those oh-so familiar plot lines. There is a love triangle, controlling parents and love rivals littering the path of this poor heroine's quest for love and ultimate success. But I think it's refreshing the way the writer approaches them. Or maybe its the fact this story is full of plot twists I was definitely not expecting, which almost made up for the cliches.

The art was incredibly well done for a cutesy shoujo. Sometimes the characters can go from one look to another in a matter of panels, giving us unfamiliar looks to our favourite characters we've come to know so well. This definitely wasn't the case here, the characters stayed true to form beginning to end.

Talking of the characters, they were all developed fairly well. Nijika is an admirable heroine, and didn't change throughout the whole thing - and stayed stronger than I would of in those sorts of situations. The two main male protagonists were developed to the level acceptable for a 10 volume shoujo, though no more than necessary. The few other filler characters there were, were kept up to date and involved throughout the series, something I'm always pleased to note.

So reading this, you'll probably wondering why I didn't give it a full 10 marks - considering how much I seem to be raving about it? I think for me, it was because, while it is an enjoyable manga, by no means did it break the boundaries. Having read classic shoujo such as Mars and Akuma to Love Song, I don't believe this shoujo did anything but stick to the boundaries of the said genre, and stick to them well.
However, if you've got time and your looking for a enjoyable and fairly well done manga, I'd definitely recommend this.
0
0
0
Kitchen no Ohimesama
Kitchen no Ohimesama
Auteur Kobayashi, Miyuki
Artiste --