Les critiques de livres

SANstorm8
Apr 04, 2021
Maga-Tsuki review
The following review is based on my separate opinion will be in two languages: Spanish and English.

My English is really bad by the way, it is also second review.

History: 8/10.

The story of Maga-Tsuki seems great to me, although it has several cliches the story knows how to get along so that it is not the typical harem, I found it interesting that the MC could not get away from the girl he is with because if not I would die that seemed quite original, the ecchi and comedy scenes were my favorite, and the end of the best.

Characters: 8/10.

The characters do not have so much complexity but it is normal because in a manga of comedy, ecchi and harem these things do not matter so much, for my part if I saw a small evolution of characters, which I liked because it was fair and necessary.

The MC seems to me to be a great protagonist, although his personality is not so original, he seems to me a very good character, the heroines are all very good for me, they cannot imagine how happy that end made me.

Art: 7/10.

Art is not the most best thing there is but it is quite nice to see, ecchi scenes are great, what I liked most about art were the expressions of the characters in moments of comedy and/or romance.

Enjoy: 10/10.

Maga-Tsuki is my favorite genre harem manga, without a doubt I have repeated it several times since I always enjoy its simple but very good story, the end always seemed to me the best there is and the characters were always my favorites, I highly recommend this manga to all people who like harem, romance, ecchi and romance, the end without a doubt the best there is.

Español
Historia: 8/10.

La historia de Maga-Tsuki me parece genial, si bien tiene varios clichés la historia lo sabe llevar bien para que no sea el típico harem, me pareció interesante que el MC no se pudiera alejar de la chica con la que este porque si no el moriría eso me pareció bastante original, las escenas ecchi y de comedia fueron de mis favoritas, y el final de lo mejor.

Personajes: 8/10.

Los personajes no tienen tanta complejidad pero es normal pues en un manga de comedia, ecchi y harem no importan tanto estas cosas, por mi parte si vi una pequeña evolución de personajes, lo cual me gusto pues fue lo justo y necesario.

El MC me parece un gran protagonista, si bien su personalidad no es tan original me parece un personaje muy bueno, las heroínas son todas muy buenas para mí, no pueden imaginar lo feliz que me hizo ese final.

Arte: 7/10.

El arte no es lo más sensacional que hay pero es bastante agradable de ver, las escenas ecchi son geniales, lo que más me gusto del arte fueron las expresiones de los personajes en momentos de comedia y/o romance.

Disfrute: 10/10.

Maga-Tsuki es mi manga favorito de género harem, sin duda lo he repetido varias veces ya que siempre disfrute su historia simple pero muy buena, el final siempre me pareció de lo mejor que hay y los personajes siempre fueron de mis favoritos, recomiendo bastante este manga a toda la gente que le guste el harem, el romance , el ecchi y el romance, el final sin duda de lo mejor que hay.
0
0
0
blushjoy14
Apr 04, 2021
Maga-Tsuki review
Maga-Tsuki in my opinion is a harem that has a fairly unoriginal plot in that it focuses on the "goddess coming to Earth and falling in love" scenario that I myself see quite a lot in the world of anime and manga. However, having an unoriginal plot doesn't mean that this manga is doing anything wrong, or that I disliked it. On the contrary, I am enjoying it and can see myself enjoying it for the rest of its publication. Let's look at why:

Story: 6
As mentioned above, the story itself is nothing overly interesting, with one of the plot keys being instantly relatable to that of Double Arts by KOMI Naoshi. To those of you that read both, you will know what I mean. Aside from that though, as of yet, there isn't anything overly original. However, that is okay since it is a school life manga.

Art: 9
The art is great, with the characters being well drawn and flushed out, while not being overly detailed to the point that you feel like you're reading a piece of fine art. The characters are cute and funny when they need to be, and also comical and serious at the right times. I also like the character designs, especially that of our main character's childhood friend Akari. The backgrounds, while sometimes lacing detail, give of a surreal environment that closely matches the goddess premise that this story takes place in.

Character: 7
The characters are all quite good, having distinct personalities and backstories behind some of them that add depth to the character. Only being 16 chapters in, there is character development happening, but whether that will continue is hard to say. The characters are good, and the only reason I give a 7 instead of 8 is because they all fit the stereotypical roles, with possibly the exception of one. You have the tsundere, the childhood friend and the overly innocent one, as well as the overly serious one (The overly serious one has only made one appearance up to where I have read, so I cannot say for sure that she is part of the harem). However, that is not to say that they do not execute these roles well, which they do.

Enjoyment: 8
Being the kind of manga reader and anime viewer that I am, I really enjoy romantic comedies and slice of life. I don't know why, but I do. That's why, while this story up to now lacks too much serious plot or drama, I am fine with that. The comedy does its part and is funny. The art is great and the characters have wonderful personalities. I also love a great romance, and while it is a harem, each of the girls have their own legitimate reason for loving our main character, and it isn't hard to find at least one to sympathize with and root for.

Overall: 8
If you're one for high action, scintillating dialogue and deep, philosophical/psychological real world connections, this isn't for you. This manga so far embraces its identity as a romantic comedy slice of life, and therefore does not appeal to those who do not enjoy those genres. However, if you enjoyed things like Nisekoi, Chuunibyou or perhaps the less well known Mahoraba, then this is definitely something to throw on your watch list because they are all very similar, and are all great reads/watches.

Note: Akari for the win!
Note: Please submit helpful or not helpful, I want to hear it all!
0
0
0
Jinjun11
Apr 04, 2021
Maga-Tsuki review
So yeah a little review.
Some slight spoiler.

First of all, the setting; ok it was good taking japanese gods and thier story but seriously how can they have electricity in heaven?? How could the goddness not make money appear in front of them when they needed to make Akari's birthday?? This is the biggest plot hole yet. Author be like: "Manga logic ~" or "the readers wont mind". THIS DIDNT MAKE SENSE.

Now the plot; So yeah putting a childhood friend rival loli, her imouto and so on... Even tho its cliche and have many filler chapter, author think we wont mind if he add 'plot'. Whats more, he add new girl when he ran out of ideas. I mean why the fu*k adding Momo( or whatever she is called) in the 50th chapter when you plan to finished it 15 chap after??

Once again, TOO much filler chapter; "More chapter = more volume =more money". Yeah some author's mind...
His sister... Plz god re-name her "Plot armor". Author didnt even do the character development for her. How the fu*k she has that much influence on the principal, university or even the heaven?? Yeah 'Plot armor nee chan' is a better name.
Futhermore those goddness be like: I am 1000+ years old but im still young ~. I will fall in love with a 15 yo boy which is also a pervert♡"

....
........

FFS MC PUSH A GIRL DAMN ALREADY, YOU WILL BE BOTH HAPPY!!!(Note:it is not consider as rape if both of them accept.They would marry anyway.) You have five f*cking girl beside you and still need porn magazine?????

No development with side characters either. Author just make his friends perverted like him, with one being rich and own an apartment. Idk why he dont need his parent permission to let them stay a night there. The other one just disappear like nothing without any one notice. How? Even the author dont know. Author, do readers appears stupid ,illiterate to you??

Well, the last 5 chap good and fun to read AT LEAST.
Only Akari development was good so far and this ending is barely satisfying.


Overall 6/10.
(Me being very very considerate)



0
0
0
rueful6
Apr 04, 2021
Maga-Tsuki review
Well on first glance it looks like you typical harem with supernatural beings, at second glance it's exactly that and while it may sound kind of critical it is not meant as such.
In fact this is a really funny, light hearted romanctic harem comedy.
I will try to keep this review rather short and may expand it depending on how long this manga will run (currently chapter 28)

Story: 6
Nothing special, you have your highschool boy and cute girls popping up left and right and then fall in love with him. Luckily enough there is a little twist in the story that has a lot of impact. (Minor Spoiler)
Yasuke's soul was forced out of his body and the girl with the strongest feelings towards him harbors it and while the soul is in possession of the girl, he has to touch her in some way (usually holding hands), if that connection is broken he dies and has to be resurrected with a kiss, which leads to a lot of comedy and hilarious moments

Art: 9
The art is absolutely flawless, clean and beautiful, the only problem i would have is that the backgrounds are rather boring or not even there, but thats a minor problem and can be overlooked.

Characters: 8
While they aren't necessarily very creative, they are well executed and all very likeable.
You have your tsundere, your childhood friend, the big sister, your allmost yandere (although more accidently) and so on, they are all funny, cute and fit well with the story.
The MC Yasuke is your typical good guy, but I like that, he is kind to the girls, understanding and very likeable in general, which is in my opinion one of the most important things in a harem manga/anime.

Enjoyment: 9
If you like this sort of Manga, you will have a blast with this one. I loved pretty much every chapter of it, the moderate ecchi scenes were in very good taste and the relationships between the characters are more or less believable.

Overall: 8
As is said in the beginning, it doesn't really bring anything new to the table concerning your usual harem rom-com, but it has everything you expect and want so see, for fans of the genre a absolute must-read and you might even give it a chance if you are not.

For simliar mangas i would recommend Tsuki Tsuki or Omamari Himari, both harems with supernatural beings, but with a little bit more action (especially the later one)

0
0
0
MangoPamda5
Apr 04, 2021
Maga-Tsuki review
If there is a ranking for the character most oblivious to women, the number one spot has to go to this manga's protagonist Yasuke.

genre: Comedy, Ecchi, Romance, School, Harem = Your copy paste harem manga through and through.

Story - 5
The synopsis on MAL gives way more expectations than what the story ever delivered. The plot about the protagonist's souls is to create ecchi situations. From volumes 1 to 6 everything flows well and the manga is very funny, then half of the volumes are filler and the story starts to drag really hard, reading it started feeling like a chore. The gods girls spin is interesting at the start but then you realize it was just a coat of paint to the same shit we've read before.

Art - 6
The manga took 6 years to complete so drawings at the end gets a little better. The girls are definitely very cute and that is the best the art of this manga has to offer. Nothing else stands out.

Characters - 4
The author Taguchi Hoshino commented that he wanted to make the protagonist more assertive but was advised to change it. Yasuke is the most detestable creation after Rito from To Love Ru and characters alike.
The girls are just blindly in love with the protagonist and their only trait is to show love for him.

Enjoyment - 7
The start flows so well i couldn't stop reading. Then it goes to hell very quickly. The manga starts repeating itself, going in circles, tons of blatant filler, mini story arcs that come out of nowhere and make no sense. The last third was dreadful.

Overall - 5
Reading a manga is giving your time to it, expecting a good ending is the least we should get back! After reading Maga-Tsuki i couldn't not let people know that it wasn't worth it.
The worst about this manga was the blatant filler, the dumbest protagonist ever and the harem cliches that riddle every chapter to the point of repetitiveness
(like falling on top of a girl or getting interrupted in the middle of an advancement).
The start is good, overall i don't recommend it.
0
0
0
Maga-Tsuki
Maga-Tsuki
Auteur Taguchi, Hoshino
Artiste --