Les critiques de livres

bluebird01611
Apr 01, 2021
No6 review
No.6 is one of my favorite books series.

Story - 10

In the "future" of 2013, after a huge war, most of the people around the world live in what they call city states.

Our main character, Shion, is an elite in the city of no.6, and after saving a stranger (Nezumi), he is stripped of his position as an elite, because the boy that he saved was actually pursued by the authorities of the city.

Several years latter, he gets again in trouble and he is sent to the correctional facility of the city, but Nezumi rescues Shion before he is sent there. Now Shion will discover that no.6 is not actually utopia as well as the true reality of the world.

The main story focuses on that, the life of Shion outside the city and his findings about no.6.

There is a sub-plot, which is the relationship between the two MCs, Nezumi and Shion (their friendship and romance). Since it's not the main focus, it would be not fair to label this as shounen ai, due to the fact that the rest of the mangas are not labeled as romance just because there's a relationship. (And I actually think shounen and shojo ai should be just romance, but then again, different mindsets exist) So, if you don't like this issue, you know what to do.

So this gets a 10 because I find that the world the author has created is really amazing, and because the relationship between Nezumi and Shion it's a really special one. It's one of my favorite pairings ever.

Characters -10

Each character is complete and unique, and you get to know some background story about most of them. Did I already say that the two protagonists are amazing? No, right? Well, they are.
The character development of Shion and Nezumi, individually and as a pairing, is also another of the best aspects about the books.

Enjoyment - 10

I enjoyed these books a lot. Proof: I finished all the books in a bit more than one week. The books are short, 150-200 pages each, well written. Some of them are slow-paced while others are intense, but every one of them is truly enjoyable.

Still, I warn you, they are not completely flawless, since they include some unexpected fantasy. (Deus ex machina?)I didn't find it too bad though.
(You'll understand if you read the books)

Summary (TL; DR)
- Story: 10 (It is a fantastic dystopia)
- Characters: 10 (All of them are complete and unique; lovable MCs)
- Enjoyment:10
- Overall: 10
- Shion and Nezumi are more than friends, but unless you are an homophobe, you won't mind this/will find this really adorable.

I would recommend this to anyone in general, but specifically to the people who enjoy dystopian-type sci fi.

The last thing I want to say is that this is a hundred times better than the anime (and it was not a bad anime), you don't really need to watch it, go for the books instead. If you liked the anime, you will enjoy the books. There's also a manga, but it's not finished, sadly.


Thanks for reading! ^^
0
0
0
patrat12
Apr 01, 2021
No6 review
This is my first review, but I felt entailed to write a review as there is none and this novel was really spectacular in many aspects. I will start off with a warning - if you are not open-minded of male on male relationships then don't read this. This novel may not be hardcore yaoi but it contains shounen-ai scenes that may not be tolerable for tight-laced male on female enthusiasts.

Story: I will not write a summary as there is already one provided for you on this website. I rated the story a 10. I am not a hardcore sci-fi fan so I am not really qualified to speak on that aspect of the story; but for those in my position that may have indulged in sci-fi novels once every blue moon than you will be fascinated by this story. The whole post-apocalyptic world that No. 6 is based on is magnificent. This story brings out the maliciousness of human nature, and at the same time brings out that human kindness is out there. Not everyone is cold-hearted and greedy. This is what you may call, "regaining hope in humanity."

From the anime, many viewers were turned off by the shounen-ai scenes between the two main protagonists in the story. This is understandable as not everyone has the same likes, but for those of us that enjoy male on male relationships then this novel is for you. I gladly enjoyed indulging myself on the special bond between Sion and Nezumi. Like I mentioned before, this is nothing hardcore - but the relationship doesn't lack anything. The best I can describe this as is an unbreakable bond that traspasses romance.

Characters: I rated this section a 10. The characters in this story were unique and weren't cliched. I enjoyed their personalities and their sarcastic way of communicating with each other. I'm sure you can get a smile or two from reading their conversations in even the most dire situations during the novel. All these characters have unique backgrounds and they're all united by the unfairness and struggle of survival.

Enjoyment: I rated this a 10 as I highly enjoyed this novel. I wished from the moment I started reading this to be able to indulge into it until I was finished - but reality called and I had school the next day. Every chance I got I used for reading this novel. This only happens when I highly enjoy something so of course I was obliged to rate this a 10.

Overall: I rated this a 10 as well (yes I rated everything a 10 - I'm only a human that enjoyed this, give me a break). The only part of this novel I wish was different was the ending. It was not bad don't get me wrong, but I would have hoped for a more detailed explanation of the aftermath.

Well this was it for my first review. I was surprised to find no reviews on here so I decided to give it a go. I hope if you're planning to read this novel that you'll enjoy it as much as I did.

-RubberSoul
0
0
0
washington-rain3
Mar 27, 2021
No6 's review
The human emotions are a very sensitive thing to begin with, but what if you had grown up not knowing of the negative emotions? A place where there is no crime, and everything is perfect? Welcome to no. 6, a 'Utopian' town where everything seems to be perfect.

STORY: 9/10
The story follows the journey of two boys, Nezumi and Shion, along with many others. It is a story that can at first be hard to fall into (for some, at least), but as you continue reading, it's almost impossible to stop yourself from being interested. There are a wide variety of emotions in this manga, which is a big part of the story itself. If there were no emotions, this story wouldn't have gotten far. From character growth to plot direction, this manga is strong in its story and overall has a very good one to it.

ART: 9/10
There's nothing much to say about the art except for the fact that it's truly pleasing to the eye. It was amazing on its use of body language, facial expression, and more. Someone could read this manga without any dialogue,
and still possibly make a story out of just what they see.

CHARACTER: 10/10
One of the most important parts of a show (not including story), is its characters. No matter what you watch, it is hard to go through a show or manga without having any character development or importance. In no. 6, the characters were what this story was almost entirely based around. Shion's growth as a person, and the relationships between everyone showed its own uniqueness. Nezumi and Shion are two very loveable characters that you can't help but love - as well as (most of) the other characters.

Enjoyment: 10/10
If we're going to go personal with enjoyment, no. 6 was something that I fell in love with and grew deep connection to. From the characters to even the town(s) it is placed in - I almost felt as if I were there. It was a manga that could make you laugh, smile, and cry at the same time. It is a story that I will keep in my heart for a long time. I am personally happy have discovered this manga.

Overall, I give it a 9(.4) out of 10.

-----------------------
This was my first review, so I apologize for any errors here and there. Besides, I wrote it a bit tired.
But, I felt the need to write a review for this manga simply because of my enjoyment, and how it managed to go far above my expectations from what I was expecting. I can proudly say that this manga is one of my favorites.
0
0
0
Tobuay15
Mar 27, 2021
No6 's review
No.6 follows two boys from opposite ends of the socioeconomic ladder as they try to reveal the secrets behind a so-called utopia. Although it's only 35 chapters long, I'm giving it a 10 because it's incredibly well-done despite its length. Read below for the full review.

- - - - -
Storyline: 9

To some extent, No.6 is just another dystopian story--perfect society with a dark secret, disillusioned citizens, etc.--but the inner workings of its dystopia are both unique and unexpected. Its plot is well-developed and easy to follow. The only reason why I don't give a perfect score for this category is because some moments within the manga feel a bit rushed.

- - - - -
Characters: 10 (Mild spoilers below.)

The backstories and personalities are well-crafted, and everyone who is introduced has a role within the story. Character development is executed well. The issues that the protagonists face, as well as the personality changes they undergo, are believable and never left unexplained.

I also have to give props to this series for being one of the few I've read that aren't exclusively BL, but portray a same-sex couple as realistically as they would a heterosexual couple. (Note: No.6 is not a yaoi manga. It does, however, have shounen-ai elements.) It doesn't dole out fanservice. Nezumi and Shion's relationship isn't established to pander to BL fans; it's there to represent a legitimate bond between two characters--one that develops over time, and through mutual understanding of each other's strengths and weaknesses. There's no masculine or feminine binary, no "husband" or "wife" imposed upon Nezumi and Shion. They're just two characters that happen to fall in love.

- - - - -
Art: 10

No issues here. No.6 is beautifully illustrated and skillfully paneled. As well, the character designs are memorable and unique without being over-the-top.

- - - - -
Enjoyment: 10

All the factors mentioned above culminate in a series that's difficult to stop reading once you start. I'd recommend it to anyone looking for a good action/adventure/sci-fi manga.
0
0
0
blushinggeek6
Mar 27, 2021
No6 's review
(WARNING! THIS REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS! READ AT YOUR OWN RISK!)

No.6 is a manga set in a dystopian like era, where supposedly there are no crimes or hardships to speak of. It's centered around two boys, Shion (a top-ranking elite) and Nezumi (an escapee from the special security area), as their lives slowly change after their first fateful meeting.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Story 8/10: I found myself mesmerised in the world of No.6 and it's conflict between the outside and inside borders. The inner being the home of ignorance and security while the other is overwhelmed with devastation and filth. This is an important point in the story for it plays a key part in the characters' motivation later on. I liked how we were given little details of information as the plot progressed, answering questions that the anime failed to do. (Spoiler alert!) However, there were a few parts that I wished were more elaborated on. For example, Elyurias' character. It felt like she was clumsily added in as an afterthought. Being briefly explained as the 'Forest God' who wanted revenge on No.6 for killing her people. I wanted to go more in depth with her goals and hatred for humans, instead of getting a quick summary of her existence.

Art 8/10: The art style was a bit simplistic, though not in a bad way as it suits this kind of story. It's pleasant on the eyes, and a joy to look at.

Characters 9/10: Shion and Nezumi are fairly complex characters. They both have very distinct personalities, and I feel is an outcome of their upbringing. Shion being raised within the borders, he lived a life of peaceful bliss, never having experienced a single hardship. Although, this doesn't seem to make him happy as he feels there's something missing. This feeling grows and gnaws at him after he meets Nezumi, a seemingly stranger whom barged in his world and changed it significantly. This, of course, makes Shion drawn to him and want to learn more about him. On the other end, we have Nezumi. A child born from the Forest tribe. We learn that No.6 killed his family and people by burning them alive and that an old lady who had raised him after that, drilled it into his mind that No.6 is filled with sinners and deserves to be eradicated. These two major events is what created the character we have now, a boy with an everlasting hatred towards No.6. And so, Nezumi had to learn how to survive on his own from a very young age, this caused him to not give out his trust easily and think that bonds were just burdens. But then Shion comes and completely destroys his beliefs, making him turn into a big walking contradiction. Of course, this scares Nezumi because of how easily the other boy had done it. These two characters are like books themselves. They're intriguing and I never seem to get bored of them. Although, I would've liked it more had we explored Shion's dark side whenever he would witness a loved one hurt. For example, in the cave, when Nezumi struggles against Sasori, Shion snaps and wraps a wire around Sasori's neck to strangle him, only stopping after Nezumi forces him to. He has also shot and killed a guard, who had in turn gravely injured Nezumi. Shion seems to take on a different personality when he does so. This is proven when he murdered the guard, becoming shocked and frightened once he had pulled the trigger.

Enjoyment 9/10: this was a thrilling ride that had left an empty void in my heart when I had completed it. It made me want to find out more of what happened to Shion and Nezumi, I didn't want to stop reading about these interesting characters. Either way, I highly recommend this to anyone interested in sci-fi/dystopia with shounen ai elements.
0
0
0
azuriknight3
Mar 27, 2021
No6 's review
No. 6 may be overlooked but after getting a glimpse of its world, you can say it’s worth your time.

I can’t say the story is unique but it is well written and delivered that the flow is, without a doubt, fluid. The manga has its share of gore, thrill, and sometimes humor and every mood was well-balanced to the convenience of its reader. The only problem is that the plot isn’t shown in a particular light whereas it appears mysterious or suspenseful. You may be thinking, ‘does that mean I can easily tell what’s going to happen next?’ and, somehow, yes but not exactly. You may be able to guess a portion of it but No. 6 has its own way of telling the story. Simply put, the story was very good!

Shion and Nezumi, being the main characters, were amazingly portrayed. For some reason, the personalities of these characters didn’t appear to be clichéd. The track of development of the characters weren’t predictable and you can easily have second thoughts from time to time. Shion and Nezumi developed in a good way that I found their actions and thoughts based on their experiences were convincing and even natural.

However, I wasn’t able to feel a strong connection with the characters because there were still gaps in between – there wasn’t enough depth in their personalities. To point out, it looked like the story didn’t really have a main antagonist that stand out among the challenges faced by our main cast.

I have to commend the artists for their brilliant work with the illustrations! The graphics seemed sharp and detailed, not to mention it looks very clean even with all the action going on. The frequent and well placed appearances of artistic touches such as unique speech balloons, expressions and emphasizers were all appealing but most importantly, the totality of the art did really good in extending the story – giving us a better perspective of it.

Being the first manga I’ve completed, I am very satisfied that I chose a good one. I enjoyed all the thrills the manga had to offer that I wasn’t expecting to find myself unaware of my surroundings for moments – seriously, it wasn’t likely for me to lose focus that the person beside me had already called my name three times (two would have been acceptable). In the end, No.6 isn’t one of your mangas worth missing!

0
0
0
Nibel1
Mar 27, 2021
No6 's review
Neck Bees: the Manga series.

If the prospect of reading a (gay??????) scifi story about a bipolar jerk (Eve/Rat), a confusingly determined piece of paper (Shion), and bees coming out of people's necks appeals to you, then I can recommend it.
To start, there's nothing particularly bad about the premise, I mean having bees erupt from people's necks is equivalent of a disease that kills people in a horrifying way. It's silly and dumb, but most anime is and I just found myself laughing about it anyways.
The characters are decent at first, Shion being a levelheaded guy who just wants the best for his friends and Rat (oh god that name) is a cold, heartless guy. But then they don't really go anywhere. The character progress resets sporadically and you'll have to sit through the same scene 4 different times. This happens with many different scenes, such as: Rat and Shion fighting but then resolving it, Rat and Shion monologing about how much they saved each others life, and Rat and Inukashi having their spat among a bunch of other types.
If you found this manga because you heard about it's mains being the best couple evar, you'll be met with Rat tossing Shion around half the time like a 6-year old with a pinata bat. Rat kicks the crap out of Shion on several different occasions and professes his hatred for the guy. They kiss like twice, but then don't ever address it. They don't even address homosexuality at all. Yeaaah, it's a far stretch to call it romantic. There's a reason why it's not listed as Shounen-ai in the genre tags.

It's a waste of time as an action dsytopian scifi romance (?), because it doesnt know what it's going for and it keeps repeating itself, getting nowhere with the characters.
0
0
0
Faisa_Dragon1
Mar 27, 2021
No6 's review
It is rare to find an original and riveting story in an unconventional world, that also fosters to the wishes of unappeasable fangirls. A mix of action, sci-fi, and drama; No. 6 is a manga that is not only thrilling, but prods at your emotions, focusing not only on the story at hand, but a complex relationship between two major characters.
I found this manga to be pleasantly progressive in its focus on romance, but not gender. It is rare to find an anime with two members of the same sex in love and confirmed in canon. It is even rarer to find one that does not focus on the homosexual element. No. 6 creates a complex relationship between two characters that happen to be male, yet the homosexuality is not a relevant topic to the progression of the manga.
It is a sweet respite to find an emotional approach to the topic of homosexuality, as opposed to the more common physical approach that animation and books more-so often emphasize.
In addition to this open-minded concept, this manga centers on a dystopian world of a mysterious nature, a set of events put into motion by a corrupted government masking an acclaimed utopian city.
This manga enthralls you with the story of a corrupted government, a topic that typically interests people as we hardly trust the governments in our real world. Appealing to the overly-curious nature of mankind, the story is not slow in reeling you into the city called No. 6. The common trope of two entirely different people coming together to expose a hidden truth, leads No. 6 to build a story based not only on action, but how the relationship between people can change more than you realize.
The characters are given complex personalities, imperfectly designed to be peculiar individuals that the reader grows to care for as the series darkens in its progression.
This manga gifts many scenes of delightful details that work to emphasize the little things, bringing an aura of positivity in the dreary atmosphere created. From one character's love of classical literature, to the simple incidences of everyday lives, to the budding romance subplot; the manga invites you into the world of No. 6; showing a realm full of not only horrors but also beauty of an alternate universe.
0
0
0
TravisBickle15
Mar 27, 2021
No6 's review
No. 6 is still, to this day, my favorite manga series. I've been meaning to sit down and write a review for this wonderful series for a while, and what better time to do it than now (you know nobody's actually doing anything right now). This manga just absolutely blew me away. I actually first encountered the series with the anime about a year ago, but it just didn't sit well with me; there were too many loose ends. That's how I ended up buying all the manga in one go.

Story: 10/10

The minute you open the first volume, you're swept into the carefully crafted world of No. 6. I was immediately enraptured by the way the mangaka revealed the real No. 6 little by little throughout the series. The pacing was perfect; it never dragged at all, unlike in the anime, and kept me turning the pages. The plot was also very intriguing. It was definitely not something you see everyday. In fact, I've never seen anything else like it. It also didn't go in the direction I was expecting, but I love where it ended up. I really liked how the author set the world of No. 6 in the future because it kind of makes you wonder if that's what our world could end up being.

There really was never a dull moment in this series. I will admit to crying multiple times while reading, but that just shows that the story is just that moving and will occasionally tug at your heart strings. I honestly don't have anything to gripe about plot-wise. Well, except maybe the bittersweet ending (If you've already read it then you know what I'm talking about). But overall, I really enjoyed the plot and the way it unfolded as the series progresses.

Art: 10/10

I don't understand how, but the mangaka manages to make even the most unimportant and uneventful frames gorgeous. I absolutely adore the art in this series. Half of the time I spent reading this manga was just me staring at every frame for a ridiculous amount of time, just admiring the art. She makes Nezumi so graceful but with tangible strength, and Shion both sweet and powerful. Sometimes there would be a frame that I couldn't stop looking at, and I would turn the page, but end up going back just to stare at it again. This manga was definitely easy on the eyes.

Characters: 9/10

I'm giving the characters a 9/10 mostly because of the side characters, even though they were all great. But I'll start with bad first. And it's not "bad" per sae, just something I wish was there, but wasn't. I enjoyed Rikiga's humor, but I wish he had a bit more substance. The only things we really know about him is that he is (or was) a fan of Eve, and that he likes Karan. Other than that, his character was a little flat. And then there's Inukashi (for the purpose of this review, I'll refer to Inukashi as "they/them," although I have an inkling that they are a transgender male. Don't quote me on that though). I honestly really liked Inukashi because of their extremely real fear of dying. I think this is something a lot of us can relate to. Of course, they also had their funny moments, especially with baby Shion. That was adorable.

Moving on to the main characters, who, in my opinion, were the highlight of the series. Let's start with Nezumi. Nezumi is a very three dimensional character. He is both emotional and cold at the same time. I think he really hated No. 6, and that was what made him occasionally lash out at Shion. He couldn't understand that there was such a kind person living in a horrid place like No. 6, that hadn't yet been corrupted. But under his hard exterior, he had a big heart, and he really cared for Shion. Speaking of Shion, I both loved and hated his character development. I loved how he was a just a naïve boy in the beginning of the series, but he couldn't have grown without everything that happened throughout the series. He did become much colder as the series went on, but it was fitting for the plot. Overall, Shion was another interesting character that changed drastically during the manga.

It's time to get to my favorite part: the relationship between Nezumi and Shion. Now this definitely isn't a BL series, nor is it really shounen-ai, but it does feature a gay couple, although it isn't the focus of the series. Of course they kiss a few times, and maybe dance together for a while, but that isn't why I like this couple so much. I found the developing relationship between the two of them very natural and fitting. Even from the beginning you could tell that there was something between them. And it only progressed from there. Nezumi was obviously fed up with Shion's naivety early on, but I think he came to accept him for who he was, and also became a little more like him. They both grow to care for each other deeply throughout the manga, and you can see it in every scene they have together.

Enjoyment: 10/10

This manga was an extremely enjoyable read. The characters were believable, the story kept you on your toes and never disappointed, and the art was wonderful. There really isn't much to complain about. It was just straight up (straight lol) good. Now the only thing left for me to do is to read the novels. The manga didn't leave any plot holes, but I NEED MORE CONTENT!

Overall: 10/10

From everything that I've said so far, I would hope that you can tell that I adore this series, but if you haven't, I'll say it again: I. Love. This. Manga. So if you've come from the anime hoping there would be something to fill in the gaps it left you with, the manga definitely delivers.
0
0
0
WaiifuPillow13
Mar 27, 2021
No6 's review
The No. 6 manga is the only thing from what I've encountered so far that I've been able to give a 10 to. I'll do my best to refrain from any spoilers or summarizing the plot.

Story. (10/10)

The Good: the plot is excellent and I thought it was extremely well paced. From the very first page you're transported into the fake world of No. 6. You're then taken for a crash course on reality in the Western District. You're swept away by the every line, every detail on the page.

When I first saw the anime, I was jaded. When I read the light novels, I wept. It wasn't until I read this manga that everything felt complete. The execution of the plot was perfect. There was never a dull moment for me and I couldn't stop reading. In the end, everything came together in a way that exceeded every hope and every desire I could have had.

The Bad: I spent quite some time trying to come up with something to complain about when it came to this manga, something-anything- that irritated me. I found...nothing, much to my own amazement.

Art. (10/10)

Wow, that art. What can you really say? The art was simply mesmerizing. You weren't just reading a manga. You were there. You were living it. Facial expressions, body language, backgrounds, panels, and bubble placement- it was all perfect and easy to follow. More than that- the art of the characters themselves were flawless. More often than not I found myself taking quite some time per page just to really appreciate the beauty of the characters and the fantastic details. I can't find a single thing about the art that I'd change.

Character. (10/10)

This is where the manga shines brightest. The struggles of these characters are real. They've all been shaped by their experiences, and oftentimes not for the better. You end up at the edge of your seat with baited breath watching as these characters are forced to make decisions and how those decisions are going to effect their personalities. The more you learn, the more you eagerly wonder what will happen next.

With that said:

This manga does feature two 16 year old boys who are romantically attracted to one another. It is this relationship, this friendship, this bond that makes the story great. This manga is not about a gay couple having gay sex (which they don't, by the way). It would work just as well if Nezumi or Shion were a female. I love that it doesn't stereotype gay relationships. It shows two people who find each other against all odds and dares to take charge of their own lives.

Quite frankly, I don't think people should freak out over Nezumi and Shion's relationship. If you chose not to read the manga because of that, I certainly can't stop you, but if you like an amazing dystopian manga with lots of action, and character development that makes you think, then this isn't one you should skip over lightly.

This is about two boys, as different as night and day, who form a seemingly impossible bond and change everything. In their own lives and in the world around them. It's a story of personal growth. To be a ignorant or to be knowledgeable. To be conquered or to be the survivor. To be human or to be...something else. It's a plot driven by characters evolving and it's utterly amazing to behold. In light of that, so what if two boys like each other? It's their relationship that makes the plot all the more worth while, and every decision they make so much more intense because of how they force each other to change.

4. Enjoyment. (10/10)

I am enthralled with every single aspect of this manga. It glides effortlessly through the pages, engulfing you in a world of horror, action, despair, and hope where hope should only be done while dreaming (if even then). It makes you question what you'd do if you were in any of the characters' positions. How far would you be willing to go for someone else? How much horror can you see, hear, smell, touch, before it becomes a part of you? How deeply can you change, before you lose yourself completely?

You are put on a roller-coaster of emotion and the ride doesn't end just because the manga is over.

5. Overall. (10/10)

This was, quite simply put, a very outstanding and unforgettable manga. In fact, the only thing bad about it is that it ends.
0
0
0
No6
No6
Auteur Asano atsuko
Artiste Kino hinoki ; No6 36