Les critiques de livres

bitsypookums2413
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
Gantz is not a beautiful depiction or ugly depiction of the soul, it is a near perfect mirror of the human soul under the foot of despair. Gantz is an amazing work of manga that I will admit is not made for the faint of heart but is made to strengthen anyone’s view and love in the world around them. It creates nearly perfect depictions of what it means to be human and it shows constantly throughout the series. I could praise that side of Gantz all day but I have to admit the faults in the beginning volumes and the exaggeration of darkness in characters. I also have to confess that there are a lot of really messed up moments in Gantz that at that point I wouldn’t recommend it to random people I think have to stomach for it. But I will continue to say that Gantz is not a story about triumph or the beauty in something but it is about humans. Btw spoilers from here on out.
The story of Gantz is a bizarre and extremely interesting thing that if explored correctly can lead to some incredible thought-provoking content, and Oku delivers on that and more. The front layer of the story, the plot, is an extremely cool premise that I find fascinating due to the insane spectacle of each fight and key event, And I love that the story embraces it’s bizarre side to the point of nearly breaking it. The back layer is almost if not more beautiful than the front layer, what I mean is that the content of the plot is fantastically well made. I will say this though, I don’t like the pacing at all. Chapters and arcs move way too fast and have little content individually of what exactly happens in them or they move so fast that too much happens for the reader to really keep up. There are chapters that can move at a snail’s pace and then others that move way too fast in terms of events and it can easily interrupt the flow of something to the point that it can disorientate the reader. The one thing it never failed to do was leave me on the edge of my seat and I can’t imagine someone putting this series down once they get hooked. I will have to warn certain people that this manga gets messed up and heart-breaking a lot to the point that it can be exhausting. But the story is gripping and dramatic with philosophical points that
The art of Gantz is a master-class of set pieces and detail. I am amazed how well Oku understands the way textures work and the insane believability of everything he draws. The reason I find this amazing is because when Oku draws something he puts work into understanding the material it is made of and how that works, without color he is able to draw skin, rubber, brick, feathers, metal, and clothing in a way that your brain doesn’t have to rationalize what something is because your brain knows what that thing is so you already believe that it exists. Oku is also a master of visual story telling through facial emotions and mannerisms that make the world more believable the longer you look at it. The way Oku draws scenes also allows for realistic viewpoints and that also allows it to be easily translated to the human brain however because of the way he draws it takes away the ability to overexaggerate and enter dynamic situations, which isn’t a criticism it’s just something I want to point out.
The characters of Gantz are not paragons of hope nor are they truly villains to disdain and hate but they are merely people trying to survive and live their lives in peace. Every character is written with this complexity and insanely real depth that they take center of the story and are the singlehandedly best part of Gantz. I believe that they hold such importance to the story is because the idea of it wouldn’t hold value or longevity without them. As an example the main character, Kei Kurono, starts this story no better then the rapists and average people around him that refuse to believe in hope but over the story he matures in a believable and even admirable way to the point where I felt the emotion of him every step of the way and its not just him that goes through this but every character that goes through the story and its that sense of humanity that makes the story an amazing one. It’s the characters that make that last panel worth it all.
Despite everything I’ve said so far, I don’t think I fully enjoyed my reading of Gantz. I’m not saying I don’t like it and I’m definitely not saying it’s bad but I believe that there were a few too many things that hindered my overall enjoyment of reading through it. The pacing I mentioned earlier is very minor compared to some points I’m about to make. There are some points in the story that begin to include graphic imagery and violence for sheer shock factor and that there are an almost unrealistic sense to the amount of close call rape scenes, meaning that they weren’t full on rape scenes but instead that they were either hinted at and or nearly happening, so many that at this point its less about how many but that they were also put in for random shock factor every once in a while however this problem stops being a main problem after chapter 70 or so. Another thing I found that became sort of problematic was that there was an over excess of using girls in sexy clothing as the cover, I like seeing boobs as much as the next guy but theres an almost too much of it. Besides all that, this series suffers from deus ex machinas and Oku manipulating characters into what he needs rather then what would really happen more times then I’d like. There are a lot of times where I felt straight up uncomfortable with some scenes that just made me feel wrong but I fully believe that follows in Oku’s intent and not a mistake. But I have to defend that the moments of relief and happiness are so spectacular and amazing I can’t help and smile when I think of them. There are moments in the story that click and are amazing in their own way to the point where they alone help me put faith back into humanity.
Overall I believe that Gantz isn’t a story that everyone should experience but it is a story everyone who goes through it can come through as a better person. I would refrain from recommending it to anyone squeamish and not used to gore, horrific imagery, or graphic content. At the end of the story, I felt good and happy about it and I don’t regret picking up and reading that first chapter. Gantz is an amazing story about humans and their will to survive and fight for what’s good in this world. At the end of the day, that final panel does nothing more than fully give me joy and hope in life. Gantz is a story of humans.
0
0
0
Ro-ro3314
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
(just for the record, this is a slight alteration of my anime review)

The French may have said “Make love, not war” but then Gantz appeared and said “Why not do both”…

Gantz is one of my favorite dark sci-fis and I gladly suggest it to everyone who likes this sort of themes. The characters are all unmoral and carnal, violent and devoid of sympathy, a bunch of miserable cowards and horny creeps instead of idealistic super-powered kids. It is both a plus and a minus, depending on what types of people you want as a main cast. I personally have gotten fed up with the idealistic good hearted heroes so I really like them for the bastard nobodies they all are. It doesn’t mean they are meant to be hated as in various moments they show signs of heroism and ideals; but to the most part they act selfishly like any average person would, so that tends to make them more plausible. Most of the magic of the story is how these bastards need to find the guts to get active and cooperate against their deadly adversaries instead of being apathetic idiots, waiting to be slaughtered like sheep. It was a social commentary around the modern way of life of sorts and I must say it was brilliant.

It also packs a very violent and mysterious story that can easily glue you just to see what will happen next. It also has a very slow build up that usually confuses you since it is never clear at what it is this fuss all about. Why are all these things happening in the story? For what purpose? Again, this is a very unorthodox approach to storytelling as most people want a clear goal early on and yet all they saw here was a bunch of unsympathetic people being ordered to kill stuff. What for? The penalty for not obeying is death. The penalty for not playing right is death again. Ain’t they all dead already? So what is the point of fighting? Yet the series plays along in a way to not offer anything clear. Not even the rules of this game are explained at the unwilling players. Many need to randomly be killed just so the rest can figure it all out on their own. There are even some who have played the game before but refuse to reveal everything and just use the rookies as cannon fodder, distraction just so they can flank the enemy themselves. All that create a very aimless and seemingly pointless premise that leaves the average viewer at a complete disarray. And that is the beauty of it.

Imagine your average moe show that lacks an objective, other than to make you feel fuzzy inside with its easy going plotless stories. Gantz tries to do the exact reverse. You don’t understand the ulterior motives of this continual bloodshed yet you need to endure it. That actually works as means to think of stuff on your own and give your own interpretation of what is going on. So besides mindless action it was also a mystery that was asking from the viewer to solve it himself, without nothing be spelled for him. That of course can look as if the scriptwriter is too lazy to think of a story and just makes everything cryptic just to make it look cool. Sure, you can say he is. It also works fine because I was constantly thinking of possible reasons for all this mess.

The experienced eye can also figure out fast enough that everything is basically a social criticism of the modern way of life. The aliens in the story all represent various negative aspects of life, such as immigrants, NEETs and religious fanatics, all are in fact extensions of human folly that the average Joe needs to fight even if he doesn’t want to. Why? Well, because he is forced to do it, in the same way we are forced to spend decades in schools and workplaces. What is the ulterior motive of all that? Why, to survive in an industrialized world that cynically treats you as an expendable peon. There is no ulterior motive other than that. That is also what the show is all about, dressed with extreme doses of violence and sex. Because down to it, our most basic desires drive us no matter how idealistic we think we are and most hobbies, wars, studies, work hours end up being pointless time, existing just to keep us occupied. Even the dead can’t rest and are thrown to survive a second time in a perpetual on-going struggle for the most basic of all needs: Survival. The purpose is not to win but to stay alive. Indefinitely!

Even if you don’t think so deep, the show is still violent and sexual enough for you to just mindlessly stare at it. It is exaggerating a lot in terms of gore and in depicting everybody as idiots and bastards as means to make you angry or disgusted with all that. And they do have some cool suits and weapons to break havoc if they ever manage to figure out how to use them properly. All that create potential for a numerous possible outcomes and it hardly feels it is predictable. I mean, in an average show you know early on how everything will end. The heroes will survive and beat the monsters and get married or something. Gantz is not like that since you don’t know who the main villains are. Plus, anyone can be killed at any given moment. It is its unexpected, violent, sexual formula that makes this anime extremely special. Highly recommended.
0
0
0
vhOtaku14
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
*sigh* waste my time once again didnt i?

story 5:
honestly from the beginning i was intrigued and had such high hopes because its an interesting concept. You almost die and you get sent to this room where you then have to battle aliens? like wow really rad, fun time this is going to include a lot of critical analysis and battle strategies with powerful characters who become more powerful. Wrong. The concept is amazing and really interesting but just nt at all well executed, it seems similar to the Liar Game or that kdrama called Alice in borderland but unfortunately didnt live up to the same potential as the other two did. Its just filled with plot holes which honestly you can forgive once in a while, i mean its hard to keep track of what your writing because you gotta make sure sex, boobs, and overall nudity is involved because those are so important to the plot right? Like oh my god the amount of nudity specifically from the female characters only made me incredibly uncomfortable, specially all the panels where they had sex. Like isnt kurono supposed to be 16, im sorry but im just not into seeing so much unecessary nudity randomly when im reading an alien/horror/action manga. If you can get past that, it doesnt change the fact of the mysoginistic undertones throughout the whole novel. the whole purpose of the female characters were for fan service and be damsels in distress who have no thoughts except, "wow this guy i just met five seconds ago saved me and now im in love with him and will die for him even though i have so much in the real world at stake". dont get me wrong not everyone can be a superhero and be able to fight aliens BUT AN OLD MAN CAN SURVIVE BUT A CHICK WHO STUDIES MARTIAL ARTS CANT???? honestly it had so much potential and actually interesting plot arcs that just went no where and honestly is comical when you think about it. like you introduce vampires and they get no backstory nothing except for kill this one kid? like aight alright dont bring em back up every again.

art 7
honestly the art and the gore is amazing as much as i hate some parts i will give credit where credit is due

character 4
there is one good character and that is MUSCLE MAN
thats all
0
0
0
ae_shinobi6
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
2 teens dies via "subway attack," finds themselves in a room somewhere in tokyo with some other people. they are then sent on missions to kill aliens by a weird black ball. I read this manga because i liked the anime adaption and wanted more of it. To my amazement, these 383 chapters delivers the most intense and interesting science fiction I have ever gazed upon.
Story:
10/10 every large story arc is unique and great in its own way.
Each arc presents a different set of problems and rules our protagonists must endure or bypass. The setting is almost never the same, and the intensity of each battle only ever increases. the scifi side of the story questions many things we do as a society, our humanity, our purpose and future. the story also touches many other subjects such as crimes, education, and many social issues; leaving you thinking what "it" really meant.
Art:
9/10 during the first few chapters the art seems fairly average. However, as the manga progress to its later stages, the "art" becomes so amazing in every aspect. the characters are uniquely drawn, while they are all different, each group shares its own style. the settings (includes the area the plot is at + atmosphere + other art words) is just astonishing, this I simply cannot explain with out spoilers so go see for your selves (art major here if u want any credentials).
Character:
10/10 main characters basically pushes the whole "hero's journey" to a whole different level. all and I mean all side characters adds some kind of value to the story. Even the comic relief characters are important! (ok maybe the panda is pushing it a little) the author had these characters do exactly what they need to in order to add their weight to the plot. these characters also have a huge variety of backgrounds from students to politicians to criminals and even infants.
(oh god Kei gat so bad ass durin the last half im startin to question my sexuality)
Enjoyment:
10/10 knees weak, arms are heavy. There's vomit on his sweater already, mom's spaghetti. 2 intense 4 me. jokes aside, this whole thing can sent you through a full range of emotions such as anger, sadness, joy, spaghetti
Overall:
10/10 so far I have read the whole thing twice and interpreted its ending twice. the plot follows a typical science fiction writing style blending perfectly with amazing shonnen like battles and adult action movies. I think neither the anime nor the movie interpretations did this series justice, so I strongly suggest reading it.
p.s. very violent and sexual in some parts, not for the faint hearted
0
0
0
skthegreat15
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
A horny highschooler boy dies after a train accident and finds himself in a room with people and a big black ball. Later on he gets in a "game" which he and others are missioned to kill aliens and whoever gains 100 points gets to resurrect. Gantz is a very misunderstandable manga. Well, it ain't a surprise since there are so much content of nudity and gore,but you absolutely mustn't judge it too quick. To be perfectly frank, I don't think it should be judged through its harsh contents. Gantz is my personally favorite manga. It didn't just give me a good reading time,but also it taught me a lot of things(u know moral values, psychologic message or meaning,etc.) Its certainly not an educational manga, but u get to learn a very important lesson by the end. I wont tell you that lesson,go read the manga yourselves and get the lesson. But the thing is main character (kei) he all starts as a sort of perv ( a horny kid dreaming of losing his virginity) and he also gets bullied a lot. As the story goes on Kei also develops mentally and the person he became at the very end in my opinion is one of the finest example to a character development in manga history. And also the readers get to improve and develop just like kei in overall. So it leaves a very big impact on reading community. The story is very creative and follows an unpredictable storyline( im telling u its just u literally cant figure out what the hell is gonna happen next) which makes each chapter exciting and fluent. There arent tons of dialogues,usually vital part is the drawings in chapters. So it makes it easy to read and move on chapter to chapter. The artwork is impressive at the beginning but it gets incredible as it goes on. Designs of the aliens are also very unique and well drawn. There are many scenes that require sex and violence throughout the whole manga but its not very disturbing in my opinion you may read it since you arent sensitive for this stuff. Gantz is a true masterpiece. Please dont mind the people who despise it. Read it. You wont regret in the end.
0
0
0
lem0906191
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
Games are always fun, specially when they involve mayhem and aliens. Coming out almost at the same time as Battle Royale, Gantz is one of those types of stories that we are all well familiar nowadays, that have our protagonist trapped in some sort of twisted survival game along with some other unlucky bastards and their lives are on the line at all times so they must develop survival skills in order to keep breathing, just to play some more later.

So good things first. The action is extraordinary. One of the best I've ever seen. And not because it is extremely frenetic (although it kinda turns out this way later on), but because we can feel the lives of the players at stake. Gantz is (in)famous for its explicit portrayal of violence, but I have to admit it works really well here. Witnessing such horrific ways to go (twice if you read the synopsis) makes the characters realize how fragile they really are and how that affects their psychological states. No one is safe in Gantz, and although the players have ways to defend themselves, you can always feel the danger lurking in the corners, it's extremely unconfortable but it feels realistic. It is easy to be turned off by the extremely violent, nihilistic approach towards human nature Oku presents and the gratuitous nudity, but once you get used to it, it becomes immensely addictive, making you even feel guilty by the numbness to gore that comes after the few chapters.
The art is also a highlight. While some readers may be dissatisfied with the computer made backgrounds, you cannot deny Oku's tremendous talent for action sequences, human anatomy and facial expressions.

But I still have to say, Gantz is far from perfect. The characters are extremely unlikable and it's hard to root for any of them, specially in a case where caring about them is very necessary (it's a game anyway, you need to want the character to survive) even if some of them are somehow well developed.
The story quality also suffers considerably when we get to the final arc. All the "realism" established in the beggining simply vanishes and you start to get the "shonen tropes" feeling lingering in your mouth. Add this up with some half-baked contradictory philosophy and you start to wonder why the author didn't quit while he was ahead.

Gantz is a sci fi/action manga. Not a very "scientific" one, but fun and well done (at least artistically) nonetheless.
0
0
0
Mr_NoName4
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
It's 2020 and I'm writing a review about Gantz. That's how good this manga is!
In order to appreciate this unique masterpiece you need to be comfortable with:
Mass genocides, blood, gore, cute girls dismembered, hot girls dissolved in acid, love stories ending in death, sex, sex interspecies, all possible kinds of brutal death, drug abuse, ultraviolence, rape, nudity (A LOT OF NUDITY!), well... you need to be comfortable with a lot of stuff.

Why? Because Gantz is merciless, there's no room for good things, for a future, there's only the endless fear of one battle after another, one delirious monster after the other, while your companions disappear into clouds of blood or get used to paint the walls.

But Gantz is not pure violence and fight, but a mystical journey inside the human nature, its boundaries, and force of sheer will when given the tools to succeed.
Because Gantz is a love story.
Romance in a deathmatch? What's next, love stories inside a ww1 trench?
The ability of Hiroya Oku is to create deep, growing, complex characters and to insert them into an orgy of death and horror.
Acutally: love stories are one of the cornerstones of Gantz, one of the powerful engines moving this train of genocides into a concrete solid ending.

I love everything in Gantz, the level of details, the complexity of the plot, the suspense, the surprises, the plot twists.
And the approach of Hiroya Oku: normality is just a thin veil, you can easily rip it and something extraordinary will take place.

37 tankobons that scream with the lives of hundreds of millions and drip of the tears and blood of many more, questioning the meaning of life and the value of an individual, and telling the struggles of heroes and idiots, businessmen and yakuza, suicides or victims of abuse.
And love.
Unexpected, overwhelming, heartdefeating love.

Start the journey of your life with Kei Kurono.
And make some friends in the meanwhile, just in case you happened to die.
0
0
0
Bestsymuri6
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
This manga for most people seems to be a love or hate relationship, It contains lots of extreme content, including gore, horror, psychological , and some sex. If you cannot stand any of those genres don't bother reading it, if you enjoy or don't mind them, then you may want to read this manga yet.

Gantz is a story about a 14 year old teenager named Kei Kurono, who among nearly 10 others dies and in the moment of their death found themselves transported to a locked room with a big black ball and forced to participate in a "game", In which they must hunt down and murder aliens. This story is shrouded with mystery, who is Gantz? why do they need to kill the aliens? Where did humans get this technology? Does god even exist? Gantz progressively gets more and more complex and continues to question reality and human existence.

Here is my personal analysis of Gantz:

Story 10/10: (I can't be that descriptive while avoiding spoilers)I found in the beginning I was interested right off the bat and while this was not a plot driven story, the idea was done well. In the beginning the only goal was survival, in the middle it was adapting, and learning to do more then just survive, to win. And near the end (FAIRLY OBVIOUS SPOILER) the goal is the survival of humanity and the main character going through hell and back to rescue the women he loves.

Characters 9/10: The main character Kei Kurono starts off as a pitiful loser, not the "ahh I feel bad for him." kind of thing, but more like "This guys fucking gross, what a dumbass pervert, you won't amount to anything." But while in the beginning you hate him (as you are meant to), he has the mind of a realistic normal highschooler, not super hero, nor secret potential, he's a regular guy. But he quickly develops (realistically though imo) into a survivor mentality, he goes from being pervy, desperate and weak to getting the need to be stronger, and the will to survive, he enjoys power but doesn't go crazy with it. Eventually he becomes a character who you respect, he becomes a cool guy. he doesn't suddenly develop extreme morals, or the need to save life, he just cares about others while he cares about himself. The other characters are not that major, and honestly most of the die and stay dead (permanently or for a while). First off Kato Masaru is a stereotypical good guy hero that was childhood friends with Kei and believes in Kei unrealistically who is used to contrast Kei being a loser. Kishimoto Kei is used to make Kei Kuruno seem like more of a loser and make him jealous of his friend Kato, who she likes, although obviously she turns out to be a fanservice (Big boobs) side character. Nishi Jouichirou is an obvious selfish monster who shows the true harsh reality of Gantz. Reika is actually important and is a stalker who loves the main character unconditionally and tries to get him to love her, in any way possible. Other characters not mentioned were either unimportant, died, or did not have a strong relation with the main character.

Art 9/10: The art was very dark and gory, it portrayed the exact atmosphere intended, the only problem I had was the shading was too intense at times, (ex: black suits, night time, black weapons, dark enemies), Sometimes it was a bit overdone, but overall the art was very suitable and good.

Action 10/10: The action was top notch, amazing fights, realistic pain and struggling, no extremely overpowered fighting moves or abilities or weapons, while the weapons may seem extremely strong, the enemies are also extremely strong, evening it out. The fighting allowed for any of the main characters to have a good chance to die, allowing Gantz to be very intense.

Romance 10/10: The "romance" in the beginning was of a sad guy trying to get laid and lose his virginity, Kei Kuruno is extremely desperate and has a pathetic non-existent love life, being so pervy he would do scumbag things (taking advantage to feel up a homeless girl), but then again he was never loved, ever. His parents disliked him, his brother ignored him, he was a loser to them. But eventually he finds love. Not a babe or a goddess, or a genius, or a slave girl, but a realistic homely girl that for once in his life gives him love. That means more then anything to him and from then on his love for her makes romance a major and beautiful part of this manga.

Enjoyment/Overall 10/10: I found this manga, in total, to be beautiful .The extreme realism in a sci-fi manga, the main characters development, the amazing romance, and finally the inspirational messages this story has in the face of humanities weakness.
If you actually finished this, thanks for reading, I just wanted to share my recommendation, because In my opinion this manga, was very amazing and had a lot you could learn from. (Note anime while good, is nowhere near as good as the manga imo)
0
0
0
WhoCanPeliCan7
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
Gantz will always be one of my favorite manga ever created.
I will try to touch a different subjects for this review - hope you will enjoy it.
Minor spoliers in the first half of the review.

This manga explores human nature in an extreme condition.
The Story starts as a survival game with the awful horny main character Kei Kuruno and his friend Kato, that instead of dying like 2 complete idiots to a train - they "teleported" to a room with a black ball and alot of confused people, after a few minutes of a vague explations by the black ball they call "Gantz" they sent to a random location with aliens, that they have to kill.
If they kill enough, they can earn points, with 100 points they can be set free from this murders game, revive someone, or gain a new weapon.
After each successful mission, they will allowed to go home, and will be teleported again in about a week for a new mission until death/100 points

The premise is great, interesting concept with great sci-fi designs like the Gantz's suits, the hard suit the huge mech and the cool guns - you would not be disappointed.

The gore is extreme in this manga, and there are nudity everywhere - so yeah, NFSW.

I won't spoil the story, but its a huge roller-coaster of emotions, you are in for a ride!

Now for what I didn't like about Gantz, because any story have flaws.

First thing I would like to point out, this manga is racist, and homophobic.
Black people in this manga are usually bad guys, Izumi painted his face black and goes on killing people, the gay black guy in the start of the manga that want to beat up and... fuck Kato, I'm sure I can find more examples but yeah its a racist manga, hope you can overlook it.

Its Homophobic, if someone is gay, everyone immediately gets away from him, even one time a character scream at a gay person to get near him.

2nd thing - and its a real shame:
Women are objects in this anime, the author is misogynistic, every girl in this anime is boneless, pair of tits that chase guys.
no strong woman lead in this manga, and not any developed woman characters.

But hey its the same guy the wrote Angel cop - a manga about American-Jewish bankers wants to destroy Japan so i'm not surprised.

3rd and last thing I am gonna talk about - (but its not like the manga have no more flaws than that)
The characters - Gantz have a lot of characters, some are good, some are not.
The characters that are not, are usually typical and boring, just waiting to die.
(but it got a lot of good characters too)
It will be more interesting to have more character developments beside our main character and really a few more. (Also I would like more rounded characters)

Gantz is a great manga, a huge gift for the seinen genre - I didn't read it 3 times because its boring!
0
0
0
monosyllable9
Apr 02, 2021
Gantz review
Gantz is a popular manga that has been in print since 2000. The creators of the series released the final issue in August 2013, and fans were anything but satisfied with the ending. Gantz was not afraid to push boundaries, offering an entertaining mixture of gore, sex, and philosophy between the front and back covers of each issue. It got to the core of what mankind is capable of, sometimes depicting characters going above and beyond for others, but more often showing the selfishness that is our desire to live.

This series really made one think, questioning religion, mortality, and even what the human soul is. And despite these heavy themes, the series maintained a well-paced story studded with action at every turn and a plethora of characters that you began to really root for.

The creators of Gantz were also bold in their willingness to kill off characters, doing this at the moment you least expected it, and to those who seemed the most untouchable–even the main character was killed off at one point (technically). Almost every time a new group of characters came together in a well-formed, cohesive team, the authors of the series would slaughter them.

As the story progressed over the years, the plot lines became more and more complicated until the story stopped making sense in certain places. A great example was when vampires showed up, meddled in the affairs of the main characters, and then disappeared, never to be mentioned again. Although these holes in the plot existed, it did not detract much from the quality of the overall story.

Until the final story arc, that is.

The ending was pure disappointment. It did not do the series justice, and what was otherwise an almost perfect manga will now be forever marred by its atrocious end. Overall, I'd still give this series a nine out of 10, but it sadly only misses the 10 mark because of the way it ended. Unfortunately for Gantz, it won't sit alongside other series I've given perfect 10s, such as Great Teacher Onizuka (GTO), just saying.

I wrote this in the heat of reading the final chapter and taking a few moments to think it over, but I still feel these are all valid points. I'd like to hear your thoughts on this ending, especially if you can poke holes in any of the points I've highlighted here.
0
0
0
Gantz
Gantz
Auteur Oku, Hiroya
Artiste --