Les critiques de livres

TsubasaFamily12
Apr 01, 2021
Hinamatsuri review
I am surprised this manga isn't that popular, despite being a hilarious comedy that shares similarities with Yotsuba to! or D-Frag!, implementing the manzai-type of comedy, in addition to a lot of situational and everyday life of humor. It is has a fantasy type of setting, as well as great characters and art style that enhances the comedy greatly. It must be said that it shares some dubious and ridiculous aspects as well that broke a bit with the immersion in the manga.

~Story~

The setting of Hinamatsuri is quite unconventional, especially considering the characters presented. Readers are presented with Nitta, a Yakuza member, who finds Hina in a box one day, a young girl with supernatural powers. Reluctantly taking her in to avoid further problems, the daily lives of both are presented. The fact that she goes berserk whenever not using her powers doesn't alleviate the situation at all.

What makes this manga so hilarious are the situations presented: these are for the most part everyday life of events, often easily relatable to the readers. These include aspects such as housecleaning, going to the shop, visiting relatives and the likes. Another addition is the representation of the doings of the Yakuza and adults: these range from retrieving money from loaners, going to the bar, or visiting the cabaret - which are fantastically relayed, due to misunderstandings or the characters themselves. It not all comedy in the manga: there are is also some drama on the stories of the different characters, such as becoming homeless or realizing how their own personalities are. These are well conveyed, in addition to mixing some humour in it, which was surprisingly well done.

Another thing that should be considered is the fantasy element to the manga: as story progresses, reader are presented with the supernatural powers, in addition to the introduction of different characters from the world from where Hina comes from. Although such characters are interesting, these remain a bit unexplored after its introduction, returning to these whenever the author felt like. This caused little inconsistencies throughout the story, lacking cohesion between these events; nevertheless, these issues were a minor drawback. The fact that the powers remained unexplored in addition to the world from where the main protagonist came from was lacking. Some events became rather ridiculous as well, such a teenager being able to do everything possible.

~Characters~

The characters of Hinamatsuri were one of the most important aspects to the manga, as without these, it wouldn't be even half as good as it is. The cast is not huge, yet sufficiently large to enhance the experience, as well as slowly introducing different ones, all with a variety of personalities than can't really be tied to stereotypes. The most interesting character was Nitta, whose personality an actions were certainly amusing as well as alluring, in particular seeing the hardships related to taking care of Hina. She herself could be described as a dumb and ignorant child, in addition to being egoistic.Although it certainly added to the humour of the manga, I personally disliked her a lot due to her personality. Character development and fleshing out of these are rather lackluster, albeit having some of these presented; however, this did not work against the manga.

Moving on to the supporting cast, these were for the most part amusing and interesting, presenting in some cases character development as well as fleshing out of these. This effects in particular the case of Hitomi, Hina's classmate, who evolves to be quite an incredible character, yet rather unbelievable due to her cunning. Other character of interest is Anzu, who becomes homeless and needs to deal with her situation, the author managing to portray the hardships of being homeless, both through the character and the supporting ones. For the majority of the interactions presented, these are well done, albeit exaggerated in some cases, yet immensely entertaining. The different personalities of these certainly enhanced the humor in the manga as well.

~Art~

The art style of Hinamatsuri is befiiting of the story, yet average as a whole, matching backgrounds as well as character designs; although these were generic and simple in most cases. There were also some inconsistencies found such as distortioned faces, yet was a small drawback. However, what stood out are the facial expression of the characters: these easily transmitted the characters emotional state, such as anger, confusion, surprise, you name it. These were hilarious and masterfully conveyed through correct shading techniques, without distorting the characters faces in any way.

~Enjoyment~

Hinamatsuri was overall a hilarious manga which I thoroughly enjoyed in the comedy aspect; the more fantastic side of the manga was rather lackluster, yet never really a huge issue, as it managed to maintain me entertained throughout its duration. There were some drawbacks story wise, especially when it got a bit to ridiculous for my liking, as it didn't really fit with it; the comedic slice of life were certainly the most entertaining ones. To people who enjoy reading a comedy based manga it is highly recommended, yet for those who is in search of a good story and deep characters may want to skip this one.

Thank you for reading.
0
0
0
futanaripeen4
Apr 01, 2021
Hinamatsuri review
Nitta is your typical yakuza. He is a womanizer gangster with a scar on his face and enjoys spending his evening in shady bars and cabarets. His whole life is changed when a strange pod containing a young girl crashes into his apartment. Nitta has no choice but to take the role of a father figure for this girl while trying to maintain his yakuza status. It's hard to become a parent in one day, but the girl Hina, also appears to possess very powerful esper powers. Will Nitta manage to fulfill his role as a new father AND as a Yakuza?

This series is a very nice and lighthearted slice of life/comedy that also has some gangster story elements to it. I've read 13 volumes so far (out of 16) and I find it very enjoyable, even though a very light read. The comedy is mostly driven by situational comedy and absurd adventures. The contrast between the word of Yakuza and the mundane tribulations of a father and a daughter and the contrast of a disinterested girl with superpowers in japanese middle school are the main focus of the story. I strongly suspect that this manga is funnier with good insights into japanese society and social expectations since a lot of the conflict and the humour seems to rise from the strange cagaracters misunderstanding the social norms, or simply have their social groups completely misunderstand them.
The art is commendable and serves the comedy well but isn't remarkable in any way.

Despite it being mostly a comedy, it has very sweet moments and some thought provoking ones as well (although a bit rare). I would recommend this manga for people that like slice of life comedies with a focus on family and strange characters (in the same vein as Gintama). But I recommend that people who are looking for something more meaningful or with more emphasis on drama look elsewhere.
0
0
0
Ani_Love6
Apr 01, 2021
Hinamatsuri review
Apparently, "with great power comes great responsibility".

Hina in Hinamatsuri is a powerful esper who essentially forces Nitta the yakuza to take her in. The two together find themselves among a memorable cast and ridiculous circumstances that make you wonder "how are they gonna worm out of it this time?"

Hinamatsuri was a joy ride from start to finish and I've, like countless others, found myself laughing out in public much to my dismay. Setting crippling social standings aside, Hinamatsuri is an excellent example of comedy manga done right. The reason why it this series is so successful is due to comedy's essential mantra: "write characters and the jokes will come naturally".

Every character from Nitta & Hina to the rest of the spectacular cast (my favourite is Hitomi) has their moment to shine. Every chapter finds the cast in an absurd scenario and therefore requiring equally or more absurd solutions which lead to more hilarious scenarios. It's the chemistry between the writing of the characters and how they interact with each situation that makes Hinamatsuri so charming.

Nonetheless, due to Hinamatsuri's thrill ride nature, there was little time to stop for scenery. Many of the more emotional and serious tones are outright shafted for a cheap gag, ruining the mood. The early section regarding Anzu's character development, in my opinion, was a great way to establish not only character development but creating a "heart" in the series. There is very little of heart in the series as it is traded in favor of jokes and a quick laugh. Furthermore, the ending climax felt slightly underwhelming in the grand scheme of things with a few things feeling like it was rushed in a last minute frenzy.

Ultimately, with a greater power comes a greater responsibility--and it's frankly the characters' lack of responsibility that makes for the most entertaining circumstances. Despite its lacking in some more heart in its heartfelt moments, no one can argue the charm and the familial sense of home that the series has going for it. It is an excellent series that despite the somewhat lack-lustre climax, felt phenomenal in respect to the journey since chapter 1. Hinamatsuri is a first-class manga in its own right and you'll find yourself right at home if you give it a chance.
0
0
0
709_70713
Apr 01, 2021
Hinamatsuri review
Hinamatsuri is a solid comedy manga that starts out super strong, but ends a little bit awkwardly. I greatly enjoyed the majority of the series, mostly because of the hilarious scenes and great characters (Anzu, Hitomi, and Nitta for example). But, the final arc honestly ruined the manga a little bit for me, as it focused on some of my least favorite characters in the series, and the answer to the question "Who is Hina and where did she come from?" is never concluded very solidly. The ending also felt very rushed, and sometimes it also felt like the author was just making things up last minute. There are a lot of 10/10 moments spread throughout the series however, and I think that this manga is definitely worth a read.
Note: Although there are only around 100 chapters, the chapters are pretty long, so the manga does feel like it is somewhat lengthy. That being said, I binged the entire thing in 2 days.



Story: 8/10
Really good plot developments in the beginning, (I love Anzu's arc, for example), but the ending arc docks off 2 points for me.

Art: 9/10
Solid art. Great reaction faces.

Character: 9/10
To be honest, not the biggest fan of Hina, and I found the band bros annoying, but I loved all the other characters.

Enjoyment: 9/10
Really enjoyable series, except for the stuff with the band bros.

Overall: 9/10
This series might've been close to a 10/10, if only the ending were better. However, it's still really good and worth a read.
0
0
0
amy2205
Apr 01, 2021
Hinamatsuri review
There are three things I want to mention about "Hinamatsuri":

1. This is a full-fledged comedy manga.
2. Despite the unusual setting, this is a slice-of-life manga without 'depressing drama moments'.
3. This is a very awesome and very unique manga.

Ok, let me explain:
1. There are a lot of comedy mangas out there, often with some girls talking about random stuff, but most of them aren't really that funny. And that's actually fine! Even though they might not be that funny, still they bring a smile to my face and are worth reading.
Well, "Hinamatsuri" is different. This manga is REALLY funny. There were some scenes were I actually had to laugh for a while before I could continue reading. Hina is just such a dumb and weird girl, it's really hilarious, and also some of the situations with the side characters are just pretty funny.

What I really like about the manga is how it isn't really exaggerated: Many comedy mangas try to present some 'crazy' and 'over the top' stuff to make people laugh, but not here: Most of the time, the stuff which happens here isn't that unrealistic, it could actually happen in real life (to some extent), and that's also what makes it so good. It's kind of 'real-life-situations', which would be really funny is those actually happened. The art, which doesn't uses SD scenes, but rather 'realisticly warped faces', does a very good job in supporting this. The manga doesn't feel like a completely detached 'fantasy world', but rather something you could relate to, to some extent.

2. "Hinamatsuri" has a very weird and unusual setting: The male protagonist is a respected yakuza member, and one day, a girl with strong psychic powers appears in his appartment and their life together begins. This really sounds like that there will be some real plot to where the girl actually came from, how she got her powers etc. Usually, you'd think the manga would go like this: Parts with lots of comedy, and in between parts with serious scenes (or in bad cases, 'forced drama', see Haganai anime) with no comedic content. There are some comedy mangas which executed this formula well, and a lot which did this miserably.

Well, Hinamatsuri is different. There has been no chapter so far which was 'depressing' or had no comedy in it. You know, a manga dealing with serious topics isn't bad, but most of the time, I just want something relaxing with no content which would get me "emotionally worked up". Slice of Life is the perfect genre for this: Just relaxing content, no drama stuff.
Every chapter of "Hinamatsuri" stays true to it's comedic nature. There's no chapter where suddenly everything gets tense and serious, no. It's always got it's bright mood.
But don't get this wrong: The plot definitely progresses. Situations changes for many of the side characters. Also, we do actually get to know more about Hina and where she came from. But it's all presented in a funny manner and really slowly, so that the manga always maintains it's "Slice of Life" character.
Also, some scenes can be somewhat emotional, for example, when a side character has to start living as a homeless person. As I mentioned, the manga doesn't make a "Hoho, she's homeless, how funny!"-thing out of it (like some other exaggerated comedies might do), but rather presents this rather dire situation in an appropriate way. But even so, the mood never gets dark. The character stays strong, and so does the comedy.
Here, I also want to praise the characters: They are really really awesome. Not only Hina and her yakuza caretaker, but also many of the side characters, which get into pretty funny situations in their life.

3. The setting is very unique. The comedy is very good. The way how the story unfolds is pretty awesome. The manga never fails to keep up it's bright mood and soon, you will come to love most of this manga's characters.
Really, give it a shot ;-)
0
0
0
chaspete9
Apr 01, 2021
Hinamatsuri review
I don't usually write reviews but this... this manga is way beyond my expectations! Yeah, we got that this is like Saiki or Mob Psycho but this manga had a league on it's own. We don't see very often a metal pod coming out from nowhere. We also don't see a girl, that had been kidnapped, mistakes the scene as a T.V shooting. We will never see a pot-addicted yakuza (I don't mean drugs, really) buy a 7-million yen worth of chinawares. This manga is very much unique and the features it's showing keeps on coming. Seriously, this puts the nail in the coffin that this manga deserves more from this community.

Artstyle: 7/10

Well this doesn't doesn't eclipse the whole overview tho. Well, for a 2010 manga debut-er, this is very much expected, but don't let it sway you from reading.

Story: 10/10

Let me guess... you wanted an ultra-op character that doesn't do anything but sleeping, eating, and playing video games but in the most weird way possible? You're in the right track.

Character: 10/10

Simple as this. A middle-school bartender, a homeless psychic, a crazy yakuza organization, a class that comprises 30% popular idiots, 20% quiet idiots, and 50% normal idiots, and many more! I like the fact that these characters (side or main) are so relevant as the story goes on. Makes you glued to your goddamn toilet seat.

Enjoyment and Overall:

Dude, this is the sh**! You can't really expect the unexpected because in here, expectations are beyond imagination! The manga has high quality jokes and scenarios that can parallel to Gintama sometimes (that's a high praise coming from me, HAHAHA). Seriously, if you wanted a running-gag that is a literal running-gag, this is it! 10/10!!!!!!
0
0
0
vaberella12
Apr 01, 2021
Hinamatsuri review

Surprised this manga has this little popularity, its one of the funniest comedy manga I have ever read and i think it deserves more recognition and support as SOL comedies usually don't make me laugh or interest me that much.

Story- Slice of life, comedy manga about an eccentric young girl, Hina, who has Esper powers that's currently living together with an infamous Yakuza member, Nitta, and the troubles she always causes him by using her powers whenever she feels like it. Most chapters usually revolve around their home, school, the bar and the dealings of Yakuza activities. The story does not have much progression. However, new characters are introduced and developed along with the main characters and they are absolutely hilarious especially Hitomi and her classmates.

Art- Great art, very detailed and oriented nicely. The art is more of a "proper human-like" style compared to other manga as this bears more resemblance to reality showing a plethora of pretty,ugly and funny faces.

Characters- The characters are very unique and have their own personal quirkiness. Not only has the author put in a lot of work into the main characters, the side characters as well have their own story to tell which differs from typical manga.

Overall: This series is honestly one of the most unique and enjoyable comedy series I have ever read. Other comedy SOL manga usually gets stale and dies off after awhile as the jokes are repeated way too often and the characters lack life with its typical generic cliche personality. I highly recommend this manga to anyone who wishes to be entertained

First time writing a review, so I just keep this short and simple. Feedback is welcome, will try to improve myself so that I can write better reviews in the future.
0
0
0
Hinamatsuri
Hinamatsuri
Auteur Ohtake, Masao
Artiste --