Les critiques de livres

TheMuffinOfLife8
Apr 02, 2021
Beauty Pop review
Beauty Pop is a pretty decent manga that just seems to leave you content in every factor. If you happen to not have a masterpiece at hand,I assure you Beauty Pop will not make you feel like you have wasted your time while you search for another masterpiece. If you are still not certain,follow on and read the rest of my review.

Story:7(Good)
Sure the 'genius meets hidden prodigy' idea isn't really all original. But then again how many more original ideas are there nowadays...It all depends on how you weave it yes? As I was saying the plot itself might not be all that original but the idea of hairdressers is really different.(Okay. It might be common. I don't know.) It doesn't just hang around with the two characters standing off but to find out you'll have to read it for yourself. I'm not going to spoil anyone here.

Art:8(Very Good)
I am not a really good judge of art but since the art throughout is not horrible and better than just readable so it should deserve a 7. Why 8? Oh I added that extra one point because of the beautiful characters that come out of the transformations by the hairstylists. Not really detailed but this will do.

Character:8(Very Good)
The development for each character isn't very deep to the point you can relate and feel for the character. But at the same time they give you enough hints just enough for you to understand the character. The interactions between characters helps with it too. Not too many interactions but they do the crucial points so it's all good.

Enjoyment:8(Very Good)
I was just looking for something decent to read and happen to land on Beauty Pop. Overall as a person who needs beautiful characters and romantic interactions,Beauty Pop has given me a really enjoyable ride. It isn't outstanding but it doesn't have flaws in any factor. Just an all rounded manga.

Overall:9(Great)
Overall Beauty Pop is a fairly enjoyable manga that has a start and an end(Literally). I gave it a nine because they had an ENDing and the characters didn't spend time being Tsun and indecisive.

Thank you for reading my first review,see you around I guess...
~In the far away land of Gensokyo~
0
0
0
ikutokun906
Apr 02, 2021
Beauty Pop review
There is only one reason I'm not giving this manga a 10-so hear me out.

The story revolves around Koshiba Kiri, a slightly aloof girl who comes off as being self-centered. However, she has an extraordinary knack for hairstyling. This isn't taken well by the resident 'genius' hairstyle Shougo Narumi, who vows to beat her along with the help of his club, The Scissors Project.

So yeah, your probably reading this thinking it's an average run-of-the-mill shoujo. Which, if I'm honest, I was expecting that myself. Trust me you couldn't be more wrong. It's almost like the characters have been reversed. Instead of the guy being the aloof, calm and contained lead you expect (very few shoujo male protagonists seem to be anything but) and the girl being a heart-rules-head, temperamental firecracker it's completely the opposite. Which I think hugely contributes to the manga being so fresh.

I think one thing that might put some people off reading it, is that Koshiba doesn't look like your run-of-the-mill shoujo heroine either. Granted some shoujos have a girl who is 'ugly' or 'shy' or 'not liking her looks', but they all have their TRANSFORMATION moments-where someone dresses them up or circumstances forces their hand and they have to change.
Warning: that doesn't happen here.
But I think that's a huge bonus to this story. It makes it more natural. Who here on MAL is ever going to go through a radical transformation which makes all the boys/girls fall madly in love with them? Most of this story revolves around how well Koshiba and Narumi change other girls, so why interfere with Koshiba-who is the complete genuine article?

I only had a few problems with the story. And they were mostly technical rather major plot holes, so nothing to put you off. I think the relationship between Koshiba and her mother didn't quite work for me, and the ending I found too abrupt.

Aside from that, this is a story that makes your heart race, you laugh out loud, and get behind the two main characters as they fight to the finish. I will definitely be watching this mangaka!
0
0
0
muntasir1239
Apr 02, 2021
Beauty Pop review
Beauty Pop is a fun reading.
The main character: I loved her. Her attitude is what I loved most. That cool, not caring attitude drew me in since the beginning. I sometimes wish more female characters were like her. To not care for gossips or what people say about her. She is fun to read and I just find myself smiling every time I reread the manga.
I like competition manga a lot. I like challenges and stuff like that. So Beauty Pop with its main plot being beauticians, I really liked it.
So in the school where Kiri goes to, there's like a monthly show were this group of boys transform a random girl into a "swan". Kiri doesn't care about them. She doesn't even want to be a beautician because of something that happened in her past.
But when she transforms a girl that the boys didn't want to transform, she is catapulted into their worlds. Although she doesn't want to and she doesn't pay them attention.
Narumi, who is the male main character, is the leader of this group of boys. He cuts hair flawlessly. He loves cutting hair. He hates that Kiri cuts hair much better than him. I think that he doesn't really hate her, like I think he is afraid that she will leave him behind in the beautician world. I think he really looks up to her as a rival.
And also, I loved that they had a goal since the beginning. I mean, they knew what they wanted to be in the future. They wanted to succeed. And they did something about it. They weren't afraid, they kept trying and trying and that's what I loved most about this manga.
0
0
0
stardreaming9711
Apr 02, 2021
Beauty Pop review
Short Overview:
The main character, Kiri Koshiba is an extremely gifted hairstylist. She is not very interested using her special talent for the fame and glory. However, she runs into three popular boys who run "Scissors Project" or S.P. for short at school. They have a super awesome goal to be the best makeover team ever in Japan. They give out random makeovers to chosen girls during S.P. sessions. Kiri tries to avoid the Scissors Project at all costs, but she finds herself adding a little 'magic' to people's lives..

My reaction:
[Please note this will probably change once the series is done. These are my impressions so far ^^;]

Story:
9/10
I loved this story to death. It is a really good shoujo manga. I hope it becomes an anime someday because I think it would be watchable. I also recommend it to fans of Ouran High School Host Club. Why? Because there are characters similar with the Host Club members! If you want to find out, read the manga. I thought a manga about hair styling would be boring, but the manga-ka makes it very interesting and exciting. Even if you don't like fashion, you will probably like this.

Art:
9/10
The art is fairly pretty at times, so it is bearable to read for picky art folks. The art is kind of similar to most shoujo manga of course such as Ouran and what not.

Character:
9/10

The characters were pretty interesting. I thought that a lot of them reminded me of Ouran characters like I have said before, so mangas like this have been done before of course with one girl being surrounded by a group of pretty guys. Most of the characters come from super rich backgrounds and are popular in school. It seems like it has been done before, but it seems to still make a good story.

Enjoyment:
9/10

It is a pretty enjoyable anime despite the fact of being similar to other mangas. In fact, I noticed this manga because it was similar to other mangas to begin with. If you are looking for a shoujo that is like the next Ouran look except is not as popular..give Beauty Pop a chance.




0
0
0
Chokyo4
Apr 02, 2021
Beauty Pop review
when I 1st knew about the story from the following summary:
"Although a truly gifted hairstylist, Kiri Koshiba has no interest in using her talent to pursue fame and fortune, unlike the three popular boys in the "Scissors Project" at school. They give showy makeovers to handpicked girls, determined to become the best makeover team in Japan. As much as Kiri tries to shy away from the Scissors Project spotlight, she finds herself responding to beauty's call..."
the part of what interest me most was a gifted hairstylest girl who doesn't have interest of becoming hairstylist and other guys who wanted to be famous.
so I given a shot...
and I say as one of best manga shoujo I've read besides Fruits Basket and Hana Kimi.
Story:
for a shoujo manga, which usually shoujo manga has so much romance in with obvious hints, I'm suprised because in this one the romance is not the real focus, is a story where unfolds and flows with a different rythm than the usual shoujo manga.
the only problem is that te story development can be a bit slow.

Art:
I like the art a lot, clothes in special and perspectives, is not a masterpiece, to me is good, I like how it shows the emotions of the character.

Character:
to me is what this manga has best, the characters with their unique ways and personality, and so as their beliefs in development, they always have great development and how shows more of their personality while the story develops.
very entertaining characters XD.
one of good points, they are not those fancy characters in usual typical shoujos.

Enjoyment:
is sure big because I've re-read 2 times, and I found very enjoyfull, good comedy, it has good cool moments.

Overall:
I say is really good, too bad is not in anime.
has 10 volumes, enough to have 26 eps D:

we could say is part of my wish list of mangas to turn into anime.
0
0
0
ArtMagicGirl14
Apr 02, 2021
Beauty Pop review
Beauty Pop -

A Manga full of laughs, seriousness, and slight hints of romance. Its a wonderful and enjoyable manga and I'm surprised barely anyone reviewed on it. The Story mainly focuses on Kiri Koshiba; girl gifted with the talent of hairstyling and is the daughter of the famous hairstylist Seiji Koshiba. Her life has changed ever since she encounters the S,P (Scissors Project); three popular guys at Ryokufuu High School that gives the selected girls a beauty touch. I really liked this manga because of its style and the funniness.

Art -

I liked the Art, it was very neatly drawn and also funny. Their looks really suit their personality and you could make out right away if the character is bad or not.

Characters -

Ha, My favourite thing about beauty pop. I like the characters a lot; especially Kiri. She has the i-don't-care-just-go-with-the-flow personality in her, and to me she mostly lives inside her mind. Thats what makes her so enjoyable and funny x3 Each of the characters has a different personality, but that doesn't change the laughter they can bring you.

Enjoyment

Yeah, I enjoyed this manga a lot. It's one of those kind that keeps you reading from the very first chapter. I hope it never ends, but of course that isn't possible.


Overall, I liked it a lot. Although the Romance doesn't stick out a lot, the comedy really keeps you from wanting it. I want everyone to read it since its not very popular : (

thanks for listening. ^_^
0
0
0
pk8list7
Apr 02, 2021
Beauty Pop review
I rarely enjoy all that school stories. But surprisingly after reading four chapters translated into Russian I surfed the Internet for more of "Beauty Pop".

What I mostly like about this manga?
Story. Art. Kiri. Reverse harem.

Story is great. It has much more unexpectable twists than you think a story about hairstiling can have.

Art is very nice. It looks simple but it's just what you need to both enjoy cuteness and not stare at each picture till you forget what you are reading.

Kiri is drawn amazingly. Her smiling face is so cute! And what I also liked about her is that she is often sleepy and pretends she doesn't care, though she does, really. And she is very kind to help all that people.

And reverse harem is enjoyable too. In fact I think "Beauty Pop" is kind of "Ouran High School Host Club"(which I also love) clone. Only main heroine is MUCH better. And that childish guy has no Bun-Bun x) So don't be amazed if while reading you cry out smth like "Tamaki! What Are you doing here?"

This is manga about hairstylists. And at first I was a bit nervous. In fact I'm afraid of ones x) You see, there is hairstyling department in where I study and guys from there always try to catch me for their trainings cause I've long hair. But after I've read "Beauty Pop" I realised that they are not so bad (which doesn't mean I'll let them cut my hair short)

So I strongly recommend you "Beauty pop" if you are afraid of hairstylists. Or if you are "Host Club fan". Or if you just want to have some fun.
0
0
0
Beauty Pop
Beauty Pop
Auteur Arai, Kiyoko
Artiste --