Les critiques de livres

Jemina0043
Apr 01, 2021
Annarasumanara review
An Na Ra Su Ma Na Ra. I'm not even sure what this means, probably the author's own spin on the ol' "abracadabra" but it grew on me after its repeated use in each chapter. The story of a girl struggling to survive amidst poverty is not an original plot for a manga or manhwa. However, with the introduction of the magician, the story becomes surreal. I wasn't even sure what to believe or even what was going on until the last chapters of the series. Overall very short but incredibly thought-provoking and though I did not cry, the feeling was definitely there. It was almost personal for me as I have had parallel thoughts to both what L and Ai believed: the conflict between securing social and financial security or pursuing your passion.

The art in this tiny 27 chapter series is stunning. The art style is very sketchy (in the sense of rough-draft and not suspicious) and the use of thin lines gives the whole story this delicate aura; most characters (Ai and L) are beautiful. Evidently, there is a dark, monotonous palette that lends the eerie vibe of some indie horror game or dystopian wasteland occasionally contrasted with a splash of color. The use of color in a gray background really does wonders for emphasis and the author's use of real life images, backgrounds, as well as some homestyle paper animation made me feel like the entire series was some sort of art piece. You can tell from the variety of art mediums and detail of drawing the amount of work and effort that was put into making this series. Each and every component has purpose and meaning.

Ai's character really clicked with me. Not unlike other manga heroines, Ai is smart, hard-working, and responsible, having had to pull up the remnants of her family by the bootstraps. But I find she's also a lot more realistically portrayed and three-dimensional than your typical shoujo lead, something the author does fantastically well with the other characters as well. She struggles, she feels resentment, she is flawed (though if I'm honest, not by much. Most of her faults lie in her family's state of poverty.) L, the star of the show, is also another amazing character. Something about him, so whimsical, random, mysterious, immediately draws you into the story. I was quite confused about his character initially, wasn't even sure if he existed or not in the beginning, but he gets his own explanation towards the end. I do wish that his character consisted of more than just the dude who does magic throughout the story; it seemed as if we didn't see his entire personality until the conclusion. And then Il-Deung. What was up with his head, right? I think the author did a great job with his character development especially in the short amount of content she had, I turned out to really like his character in the end. For the other characters--rather typical; they fit quite neatly into those character tropes you always see in manga. Clearly, the MCs were given the most attention.

Ultimately, it boils down to this: I wanted a quick read and chose this relatively short series that exceeded expectations. Annarasumanara, though not perfect, is definitely one of those obscure manga that deserves higher praise and more coverage. Surreal is the word I would use to describe it and I honestly regret not giving this series the full attention it deserves (if I had, there would've been tears I'm sure). Read this if you want something different, something kinda sad, or something that makes you think!
0
0
0
flyingflames1311
Mar 31, 2021
Annarasumanara review
Every child must be an adult whom everyone envies respect and acknowledges if he want to live in this world ,our magician Ryu Min Hyuk has another opinion about how to live and adulthood problems.
One day i wanted to read a (Manhwa ) because i was curious which is the best( manga) or (Manhwa) ?i read several Manhwa but just to make sure so i pick up( Annarasumanara).
Story:
A psychological,Slice of life story a magician lives in amusement park all alone with his Parrot and one day a girl destiny drove her there then with a beautiful shining face Ryu Min Hyuk ask: do you believe in magic ? and the story begins .
Interesting story i found it not excellent but it deserves 8/10 . growing up issues is shown with a nice beautiful way mixed with an incredible art work but author only showed the issues he wanted to talk a bout without any solutions .So it is 8/10 for the story .
Art:
I have never seen an art work like this before grey drawing with a little touch of colors makes a fantastic Compound.
Evey single detail is well drawn and there is almost no flaw in it .So it is 10/10 .
Character:
A realistic characters fit perfectly in the story ,and because of this i find them some kind boring.
7/10.
Enjoyment:
frankly i did enjoy but not much when i was reading this i was convincing my self to read every time because of what i mentioned be before about the realistic thing.
7/10.
Overall:
Finally after reading the whole thing i came to a conclusion if i had a choice between manga VS Manhwa for sure i will chose the manga .
overall : 8/10


0
0
0
TheElfiestElf10
Mar 31, 2021
Annarasumanara review
“I looked about me. Luminous points glowed in the darkness. Cigarettes punctuated the humble meditations of worn old clerks. I heard them talking to one another in murmurs and whispers. They talked about illness, money, shabby domestic cares. And suddenly I had a vision of the face of destiny. Old bureaucrat, my comrade, it is not you who are to blame. No one ever helped you to escape. You, like a termite, built your peace by blocking up with cement every chink and cranny through which the light might pierce. You rolled yourself up into a ball in your genteel security, in routine, in the stifling conventions of provincial life, raising a modest rampart against the winds and the tides and the stars. You have chosen not to be perturbed by great problems, having trouble enough to forget your own fate as a man. You are not the dweller upon an errant planet and do not ask yourself questions to which there are no answers. Nobody grasped you by the shoulder while there was still time. Now the clay of which you were shaped has dried and hardened, and naught in you will ever awaken the sleeping musician, the poet, the astronomer that possibly inhabited you in the beginning.”
- Wind Sand and Stars, Antoine de Saint-Exupery

Wow, a work about holding on to the inner child inside you and never entering the dirty adult world. Where have we seen that before?

Despite the fact that everything Saint-Exupery has written, and especially the Little Prince, is probably better crafted, and despite the fact that Inio Asano writes better, in Solanin or Umibe no Onnanoko for example, about the sheer brutality of trying to live in a bubble-world despite having no backing of real-life pragmatism, and despite the fact that Aku no Hana has a better portrayal of the darkness of the screw-all attitude towards life, and despite the fact that the works of Salinger has better crafted witty and endearing characters (such as the Glass Family members), and despite the fact that, even in its pessimism, a work like Kyoko Okazaki’s Pink is simultaneously more optimistic and more poisonous in its depiction of how to get through the crap life…

Well, I guess Annarasumanara is a very good illusion.

That is, it is technically brilliant and perfectly paced enough to create the sheer oomph of an effect. Like any great Magician’s trick, you know the whole deal is a lot of smoke, mirrors, and flourishes, and yet you still buy yourself into the moment (and hey, that’s even the main theme of the story). You know that everytime something bad happens to the token archetype poor-girl, the mysterious bishounen white-haired Magician will step in and bedazzle. But even when you know this it still does not kill the thrill of how it’s done, mainly because the manhwa artist has synthesized this style that’s like Studio Shaft translated onto comic-book format. The effect, of watching the whole black-and-white world change to colour (which, by the way, is so obviously a ploy done by way too many people… even The Wizard of Oz) is still so magnificent that you’re sucked in. Oyasumi Punpun probably has a better communication of the Fantastic to the Real, even without colour, and yet we can’t expect all artists out there to be as well versed in psychological shorthand as Inio Asano… right?

All sarcasm aside, I think the work is quite endearing, and maybe if it was marketed as a children’s book instead, and created with more focus on the Magic and Metaphor and less of the supposedly ‘real life’ stuff, it may have supplanted the Little Prince as the next big amazing children’s book. But then again it still probably wouldn’t really beat Steven Universe.
0
0
0
WuxianXiaozu3
Mar 31, 2021
Annarasumanara review
Review also avalible on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUxhsA5Jbv0&t=89s

This manga annarasumanara is a really well written and illustrated manga that touches upon a topic that many people can relate to.

So I found this manga because I am Sean the magical weeaboo (I am a weeaboo magician) And I was curious if I could find any manga about magic tricks, sleight of hand, magicians or anything along those lines. What I eventually found was this one right here. At first I was skeptical, I thought there was a possibility it might end up being really cheesy due to my past experiences with magicians in manga. I decided to give it a try however, because of both the high score, and my curiosity. I was not disappointed.

Annarasumanara is a drama series that touches upon topics many of us can personally relate to and uses magic elements to create a mysterious atmosphere to go with it. What this story tackles the best is the whole concept of people growing up and giving up on their dreams mainly because they believe their dreams are childish, and they feel like they need to move forward. If this intrigues you in any way, you must read this manga because the entire manga is basically this premise but in a extremely well developed format. The way it was put together is done in a way where you can really get inside their head. I guess the best way I can put this is the emotion felt real.

So now onto the second reason why this manga is so good. The art. This is some of the most creative and cool looking art I have ever seen used in manga. If you have ever read goodnight pun-pun, I guess you could use that as a example of what the art is similar to. Some parts look absolutely beautiful, while others look really interesting and abstract. Let's just let it be known, the visuals are absolutely amazing.

And finally, the atmosphere. If you like mysterious feeling stories, this is a manga for you to look into. I wouldn't classify this book as a mystery, but it defiantly has some of those aspects.

Overall, if you want to read a really good book about magicians with relatable emotions and insane visuals you should check this out. As a magician who has seen many fictional stories revolving around magic tricks, illusion, sleight of hand, etc, I would probably say this is the best one.

8/10
0
0
0
warniefn14
Mar 31, 2021
Annarasumanara review
*Warning: spoilers for Annarasumanara, they was necessary to gush about it*

Annarasumanara isn’t like any manga I’ve read, and it probably will be the same for you too. I don’t mean that in the sense that it is a Manhwa, it does far more than just ‘being a manhwa’. Despite this claim, the story, or at least the setup for Annarasumanara isn’t anything particularly special, a girl living in poverty, tragedy and harsh reality. It’s a great way to make people empathize and root for a character, when it’s done well; and in this case, it is! Annarasumanara stands out not in its story and plot. The story is good and it carries a valuable message about life and society.

That isn’t why Annarasumanara is as good as it is. It’s all in the art and the visuals.

Speaking of, the visuals are simply amazing. They are so original, they blend so many styles and incorporate so many techniques that throw the ‘draw on paper and scan it’ standard out the window. It’s just breathtakingly original and different. Just scrolling down that first chapter (Manhwa format) is like the best thing since sliced bread. Collage, panorama, patterns, photos, heavy contrast, good grayscale, landscape arranged in portrait it’s just an amalgam, and It just works™. I mean the guy even used LEGOs, like excuse what, and he made it work!

Back on topic, the art isn’t the only thing compelling about this work, the characters are very interesting, in that they are used to great length by the author to explore universal ideas and challenges that people face. Each of our three main characters suffer from very bad cases of misfortune, and all three feel stuck. Yoon Ah-ee is stuck in poverty, Euh Lee is stuck in the child-like wonder of the past and Il-Deung Na is stuck on a predetermined path. All of them are great, they aren’t one-dimensional sheets with no discernible personality. I personally found myself easily having empathy and sympathy for them.

I really enjoyed reading this manga, it’s a treat on a visual level, and the story and characters are very engaging and well made. They don’t come close to the level which the art has obtained, but this is still a once in a lifetime read.

10/10. 
0
0
0
TsubasaFamily12
Mar 31, 2021
Annarasumanara review
Well, this story leaves a lot to the imagination so i think every individual will perceive it in their own way. But here is mine.

Why i liked this manhwa and why it is a genius.

The story is very straightforward and simple yet touches deep.
And what i find really genius about this manhwa is how it has nothing related with supernatural.
At the beginning of the story, i was skeptical. Thinking "magic does not exist, it is just a trick" drawing a fine line between reality and magic. Yet, the story just blurs that line. No matter how realistic you may be, you will find yourself wanting to believe in this magic.
The magic makes your hearth flutter. It is colorful, it is bright. It almost makes you believe that it is real.

And what i absolutely love about this story is, it makes you believe in magic but then it hits you in the gut with harsh reality.

The reality is "inescapable". You struggle to survive, it is full of hardships, and sometimes it overwhelms. Some chooses the magic as a scapegoat. But this story tells you to embrace the hardships, cope with it, and move on. And it also tells "Magic is real. You just need to believe". Yeah, "how convenient" i know. But if you really think about it, isn't it simple? As long as you believe, it will never cease to exist. It might ask you to blindly believe in it, such thing, only possible for an innocent mind.

Finally the story comes to the conclusion, where it asks you if you believe in magic. And you can guess what my answer was.

0
0
0
Erik_The_Red6
Mar 31, 2021
Annarasumanara review
There is a dreamer in everyone. As kids, we would often harbor pure and naive desires to want to be like those in the fantasies but through the vicissitudes of growing up, inevitably sealed those elusive thoughts away. As we matured, we rationalized that certain things are simply unachievable and unrealistic. We couldn't fly and save people like Superman; we couldn't be like Peter Pan who will never grow up, nor was there any Neverland in our world. We didn't have powers.

And that magic is not real.

Some point in our life we became adults and started prioritizing more earthly, materialistic wants. In order to conform to society's expectations, in order to 'live'; gone were those innocent wishes of the past. But what about those who couldn't abandon them and still clings onto the hope to be something they couldn't possibly become? What about those who are conflicted in-between? In this manhwa titled Annarasumanara, we get a glimpse into said characters with those struggles in all of its unforced candor. A thought-provoking and touching story told earnestly and devoid of unnecessary contrived plot devices. A truly wonderful read.

As it'll be a shame to spoil anything for future readers, I will not discuss about the story or its cast. Instead, I want to divert your attention to the visuals. Just take a look at the first few pages.

It's hardly surprising how this manhwa has the ability to grip its reader from the onset. Any decent writer can tackle a story about magic and life but are they able to embellish it with jaw-dropping illustrations? This aesthetic aspect is what I feel makes Annarasumanara so mesmerizing and a cut above the rest. After all, humans are naturally attracted to beautiful things. Annarasumanara does not only tugs our heartstrings with its beautifully-woven tale but also possesses the gorgeous arts to complement with its mystical atmosphere, making for a truly immersive and surreal experience.

It is no wonder how easily us readers could be so captivated in the fanciful flights of this manhwa when you have such enchanting visuals graced upon you.

"Do you believe in magic?"

You know, there is a dreamer in us all. A purity deep down that wants to believe that magical things do exist. Just like our characters in the story.

I wish I could better express how special Annarasumanara is but the right words just don't seem to flow through from my incompetent self. It saddens me how such a beautiful manhwa isn't that particularly well-known and there's nothing much I could about it. If there's even anyone reading this so-called review, do yourself a favor and give this manhwa a try. I sincerely believe that you'll like it :)
0
0
0
Annarasumanara
Annarasumanara
Auteur Ha, Il-Kwon
Artiste --